Showing posts with label Sin. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sin. Show all posts

Monday, 28 December 2020

On the impossibility of describing God: the weird of Ezekiel

Ezekiel may be one of the longer books of the bible, but there are comparatively few readings from his prophecies which occur in the lectionary. Those that do tend to reflect the most straightforward aspects of his message. Right from the beginning, however, Ezekiel draws his listeners in to bizarre descriptions of his visions. Perhaps fortunately for readers and preachers, these are omitted from the Sunday cycle of readings.

Ezekiel’s visions – a woodcut by Hans Holbein via Wikimedia Commons

As a priest, he has a particular interest in the Lord’s glorious presence dwelling in the temple. The book begins with visions given to the prophet in Babylon, and part of the burden of Ezekiel’s message is that the Lord’s glory had left the temple in disgust. Much of the first half of the book, despite being set in Babylon, seems to be addressed to the residents of Jerusalem before their exile.

Ezekiel puts a great deal of stress on the transcendence of the God who nonetheless addresses him as “mortal man.”1 Even in his visions of God, he stresses that what he sees is only an approximation of the living and invisible God: he sees “the appearance of the likeness of the glory of the Lord” (Ezekiel 1:28). The combination of detailed description, and the way it is presented as an approximation of what cannot be fully described leads to Ezekiel being a favoured source for mystics, especially some Jewish mystical traditions.

However, the passages used in the lectionary draw on some of Ezekiel’s less visionary prophecies. He characterises Israel as a rebellious people.2 He offers a parable of Israel as a tree showing God as the one who brings the high low, and raises the low up high.3 Most notably he rejects a traditional understanding of law and divine punishment: children will not be punished for the sins of their parents, but parents and children for their own sins. It goes some way to forming the basis from which an understanding of individual personal responsibility can emerge.4 The priest or prophet, however, is responsible for another’s sin if he does not warn the person to repent.5

Ezekiel devotes some attention to the calling of the leaders, the shepherds of Israel, here seemingly including those aristocracy who share the king’s rule. This leads to one of his more famous prophecies, that God will raise up a true shepherd, a new David. As well as providing a related reading for Christ the King,6 this provides the background to John’s presentation of Jesus as the Good Shepherd.

His most famous prophecy, however, comes in chapter 37. This is the vision of the valley of dry bones coming to life as God sends his Spirit upon them. Selected verses from this are used as the first reading for Lent 5 in Year A, when the gospel is the raising of Lazarus. It is one of the key texts that helps develop the language of resurrection that later writers will draw on, although here in Ezekiel it is resurrection as a metaphor of new hope for the nation, rather than about the afterlife for individuals.7

Notes

  1. Literally, “son of man” one of the many times that expression is used, beginning in 2:1 and then very frequently throughout the book. It is not a title, but a reminder of Ezekiel’s identity as human and mortal before the indescribable glory of God.

  2. Ezekiel 2:1-5, the related reading in Year B for Proper 9, the 14th Sunday in Ordinary Time.

  3. Ezekiel 17:22-24, Year B, 11th Sunday in Ordinary Time, Proper 6.

  4. Ezekiel 18:1-4, 25-32 (Ecumenical) or 18:25-28 (Roman Catholic), Year A, Proper 21, 26th Sunday in Ordinary Time.

  5. Ezekiel 33:7-11 (or 7-9) Year A, 23rd Sunday in Ordinary Time, Proper 18

  6. Christ the King, Year A.

  7. The Revised Common Lectionary also includes it as a possible reading during the Easter Vigil, and an alternative reading for Pentecost.

Friday, 11 December 2020

Exodus: plagues and prohibitions

The second book of the bible launches into the story of Moses. It very quickly bridges the gap between the story as we left it at the end of Genesis, (with the favoured Israelites living in the nicest part of Egypt) and the point where the story of Moses begins (with the descendants of those Israelites all fully enslaved by the Egyptian Pharaoh).

We begin with Moses’ birth. The story of the midwives is a masterpiece of subversive humour as the slave-race outwits the master-race (a similar sly humour pervades the story of the plagues). From there the text skips through his upbringing in Pharaoh’s household, to the story of his first attempt to take action in favour of his birth nation. Attempting to defend a fellow-Israelite, he kills an Egyptian, then flees in fear for his life. In the desert he encounters God in a burning bush1 and receives the commission to lead Israel out of slavery from Egypt to a distant promised land.

  
Ivan Aivazovsky Passage of the Jews through the Red Sea via Wikimedia Commons

Initially reluctant, Moses returns to Egypt, accompanied by Aaron.2 The narrative becomes an extended account of ten plagues, visited on Egypt in order of increasing severity, before Pharaoh agrees to let the Hebrew slaves go. This should probably be read like a black comedy with a very dark ending: Moses and Aaron call a plague of frogs on the land. The Egyptian magicians say, “We can do that too” and bring even more plagues of frogs on the land. Various kinds of literature telling the story of oppressed people work by poking fun at the oppressors.

Moses leads the people out through the sea,3 and the pursuing charioteers are drowned. As we have it, there are at least two, and probably three versions combined in our bible. In one version, the sea is driven back by a strong wind all night (e.g. Exodus 14:21). We only see occasional traces of that version. In the more famous and dominant version, Moses parts the sea to create a corridor of dry land with walls of water either side of it. Then there is a poetic version as the song of Moses and Miriam in Exodus 15, which emphasises God’s action even more strongly.

This is a key story that is read especially at Easter. Christian tradition has rather minimised the violence portrayed in it (the climax of this narrative of liberation), by reading it as a foreshadowing of the cross and resurrection. This is captured most strongly in the baptism liturgy, such as these words from the Anglican blessing of the water of baptism for Eastertide.

    We thank you that through the waters of the Red Sea
    you led your people out of slavery
    to freedom in the Promised Land.
    We thank you that through the deep waters of death
    you brought your Son,
    and raised him to life in triumph. 
    (Seasonal blessing for Easter)

Putting the two together highlights Easter as a moment of liberation, not from Egyptians, but from sin and death. It is our sins which are drowned, not Egyptian chariots. Christian imagery in worship often works like this, directing attention away from any literal or historical reference, to a spiritual meaning. Given the many pages some scholars have devoted to working out what, if any, historical event lies behind the developed stories, that may be just as well. Christian spiritual reading and liturgical use is not tied to any particular historical reconstruction.

Then, in the desert, the Israelites eventually camp at Mt Sinai. Moses goes up and meets with God, receives the laws the people are to live by, with the ten commandments prominent among them, comes down, and is horrified by what he finds. In his absence, the people have invented their own version of the story, and represented God by the statue of a bull, a relatively common symbol of divine power. By contrast, the God of Moses cannot be represented by carved images. This will become the most distinctive feature of Jewish worship.

In horror, Moses breaks the stones on which the law is written. Then having prayed for the people that God will give them a second chance, he returns up the mountain to get the ten commandments4 (or ten words, the Decalogue, as the text describes them – Exodus 34:28) written out on new stone tablets. Finally, according to the instructions God has given, they set up a temple under “canvas”5: the Tent of Meeting, and worship God according to the newly given law.

Various parts of this story occur as readings in the lectionary. It helps both to have an outline of how they fit into this rather lengthy narrative, and also an awareness that quite a lot of law has been collected together into this story.

At the heart of it is a pattern we see repeatedly in the scriptures. God acts on his people’s behalf, which is usually referred to as God’s grace. God then expects his people to respond in obedience. They fail, and the covenant needs to be restored; God’s grace is then experienced as forgiveness. This is a pattern shared by both Jew and Christian in scripture and in tradition, and articulated in our liturgies.

Notes

  1. This is a very important story in which Moses is given God’s name. I will write a separate post on it at the start of next week.
  2. It seems to be another sign of the way the editors collected different traditions and wove them together, that Aaron appears, without explanation, as Moses’ brother in the land of Midian, despite Moses’ family being part of the enslaved Hebrews population of Egypt.
  3. Exactly which body of water the story has in mind is not entirely clear. The traditional translation of “Red Sea” is misleading in that it doesn’t refer to what we call the Red Sea today. It might, as many translations indicate in footnotes, be translated Reed Sea – the sea where the reeds are abundant.
  4. In fact, it’s rather difficult to divide the commandments into ten. The churches of the Reformation follow Jewish numbering, which treats the commandment to have no other gods as one, and that to have no carved images as two. The Roman Catholic church, following St Augustine, treats those as one single commandment, and takes the commandment(s) on not coveting as the ninth and tenth commandments. See, for example, the Anglican and Roman Catholic versions.
  5. Canvas is of course our material for tents. Exactly what material the Israelites used is not fully clear. In Exodus 36 some tent-hangings are made of linen (v8) some of goats’ hair (v14), and some of leather (v19).

Welcome to Lection and Liturgy

Welcome to Lection and Liturgy. I have backed up to this site a series of posts making a guide to the whole of the Christian Bible, aimed p...

Some frequently read posts