Showing posts with label Corinth. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Corinth. Show all posts

Wednesday, 30 December 2020

Keeping up with the Corinthians: a second letter to Corinth

Paul wrote more than two letters to the Corinthians: it’s the only way of making sense of the letters he mentions in his correspondence with them. It’s just that we don’t have any more than two collected in our scriptures, and don’t know what happened to the other(s). We have no way of knowing exactly how many there were. Some scholars, observing that the letter in the Bible called Second Corinthians seems a bit of a patchwork, suggest that it could have been stitched together from at least two, and perhaps three original letters.

There’s no real evidence to say so. The changes of mood and direction could just as well come down to getting interrupted mid-dictation by some event or news which caused a swerve in the argument. Since no-one has ever found a fragment of manuscript that shows a version of the letter with a different beginning, middle or ending, I think I prefer the simplicity of an interruption causing Paul to alter course. Either way, it’s a reminder that there are simply gaps in our knowledge, and not everything Paul wrote ended up as scripture.

Corinth and the Gulf of Corinth: a reminder it was a busy maritime city. Via Wikimedia

Selections from Paul’s second letter to Corinth are mainly read through in Year B following Eastertide. These are the 8 Sundays running from the 7th to the 14th Sunday in Ordinary Time.1 These are readings that tend to focus on Paul’s understanding of his apostolic ministry. Only on occasion does it become apparent that he is chiding the Corinthians for their behaviour. If you are reading from it in public worship, you should bear in mind that the main purpose of the letter is repair the breach between Paul and the Corinthians after they took his previous reprimands badly, while still reminding them of what they need to change. Ideally that will help you find an appropriate tone.

One thing that has changed since he wrote 1 Corinthians, is that the competition in Corinth has increased. There are more people, saying ever more strongly, that Paul is claiming an authority he shouldn’t have. These “super-apostles” (2 Cor 11:5) seem also to be arguing for a greater importance for Torah than Paul allows.

At the same time, Paul continues to teach the Corinthians many of the same themes as before. His ministry is marked by the pattern of the cross: his sufferings are borne in service to the Corinthians. His humility is patterned on the crucified Lord. Life in the present is to be marked by the hope and expectation of resurrection. “We look not at what can be seen but at what cannot be seen; for what can be seen is temporary, but what cannot be seen is eternal.” (2 Cor 4:18)2 Paul combines this with the great exchange he focused so much on in Romans. “For you know the generous act of our Lord Jesus Christ, that though he was rich, yet for your sakes he became poor, so that by his poverty you might become rich.” (2 Cor 8:9)3

Those who truly appreciate the divine gift will reciprocate not only in obedience to God, but also in generosity to others. The collection, which he mentioned at the end of his first letter to them, now assumes a more central position. Their generosity, he complains, has fallen well short of an appropriate response to Christ’s generosity. It has not (Paul rather naughtily appeals to the competitive instincts he normally combats) even matched the generosity of their poorer Macedonian neighbours and rivals (2 Cor 9:1-5).

Paul also writes this letter in a spirit of reconciliation. A previous letter, where his tone was too strong, seems to have damaged their relationship (and perhaps made room for the super-apostles to denigrate him). He is seeking to repair the breach, and also presents his whole ministry as one of reconciliation: as an apostle he is an instrument of God’s reconciling work. His appeal, like his pattern of ministry, is based on this: God’s great exchange in Christ: “Christ was innocent of sin, and yet for our sake God made him one with human sinfulness, so that in him we might be made one with the righteousness of God (2 Cor 5:21 REB).”4

Yet in competing with the super-apostles, his tone is as angry as it ever gets. Perhaps one of the reasons he so often reminds others, and particularly the Corinthians, of the need to pattern oneself on the humble service of Christ, is that like most preachers, he needs to preach it to himself. In something of a parody of boasting, he lists all the humiliations he has suffered as an apostle (2 Cor 11:23-33), yet there is a deadly serious and equally competitive point underlying it: “Are they ministers of Christ? I am talking like a madman—I am a better one (2 Cor 11:23).”

It is not at all clear how the message of the super-apostles differed from what Paul preached: he clearly feels that both his message and his authority (and they are hard to separate) are being threatened. An angry Paul is not always the most attractive Paul, and the lectionary tends to edit this side of him out. He certainly believes what he is defending is the gospel, and says fiercely that how people treat him is unimportant. However, he is as human as the rest of us, and sometimes seems to take a slight against himself as an attack on the gospel he preaches. The lectionary gives us the most acceptable verses from the closing polemical chapters,5 which are also a fitting summary of Paul’s complexity:

“Three times I appealed to the Lord about [my thorn in the flesh], that it would leave me, but he said to me, “My grace is sufficient for you, for power is made perfect in weakness.” So, I will boast all the more gladly of my weaknesses, so that the power of Christ may dwell in me. Therefore I am content with weaknesses, insults, hardships, persecutions, and calamities for the sake of Christ; for whenever I am weak, then I am strong.” (2 Cor 12:8-10 NRSV)

Notes

  1. The 7th Sunday in Ordinary Time is a week that can disappear as Easter shifts around.

  2. Proper 5, 10th Sunday in Ordinary Time

  3. 13th Sunday in Ordinary Time, Proper 8

  4. Set for Lent 4, Year C, and therefore often not read by Anglicans who tend to go overboard on Mothering Sunday.

  5. Proper 9, 14th Sunday in Ordinary Time – the Lectionary for Mass leaves most of the polemic out, the ecumenical lectionary, as so often, lengthens the reading to bring some of it back in. The passage quoted is in both versions.

When the church doesn’t do “Christian”: pastoral care case by case in First Corinthians

From looking at Paul’s most carefully and tightly argued letter, we turn to one that is almost a ragbag of collected problems, First Corinthians. These problems are either ones that the Corinthians have written to Paul about, or ones he has heard of from others. Here, even more than usual, we are aware as readers that we only have half a conversation.

The lectionary leaves out most of the passages in the middle of the letter where Paul is seeking to legislate for the community: issues of incest (ch. 5), settling community disputes (ch 6), provisions for marriage, celibacy and divorce (ch 7), and eating food offered to idols (ch 8). One of the losses in this is that we miss the details of how an early (probably largely Gentile) Christian church faces the problems of reimagining Jewish community organization.

What happens when you transplant Jewish tradition into Greek soil without the framework of Torah to shape it? What does following the example of the rural Palestinian Jew Jesus look like for an urban Greek coming from traditional Greek or Roman religion and culture? These questions lie behind the whole of the letter, but are particularly acute in the disputes the lectionary omits.

Roman Corinth’s Fountain of Peirene. Via Wikimedia Commons

Unlike most of us who preach and teach today, aware of our own failings, Paul (never a modest man) is confident in putting himself forward as an example: “To Jews I behaved like a Jew, to win Jews; that is, to win those under the law I behaved as if under the law, though not myself subject to the law. 21 To win those outside that law, I behaved as if outside the law, though not myself outside God’s law, but subject to the law of Christ. 22 To the weak I became weak, to win the weak. To them all I have become everything in turn, so that in one way or another I may save some.” (1 Cor 9:20-22 REB). People looking to imitate Paul must sometimes have got mightily confused about which Paul they were meant to be imitating.

Another significant feature of 1 Corinthians is that it shows us a far more traditional Paul than his other letters do. Paul is often presented – and sometimes presents himself – as a lone radical challenging the more conventional church of Peter and James. Here he is concerned to show he is of one mind with the whole church. He is a fellow worker with Peter, called by his Aramaic nickname Cephas,1 and Apollos (1 Cor 3). Paul quotes gospel tradition at least three times: on divorce (1 Cor 7:10 see e.g. Mark 10:1-12), on the mission of the disciples (1 Cor 9:14 see Luke 10:7) and on the institution of the Eucharist (1 Cor 11:23-26 see Luke 22:17-20).2

Paul also roots his exposition of the resurrection in chapter 15 in one of the earliest creeds, summarizing also the testimony of others to the resurrection (1 Cor 15:3-7), before appending his own. Finally, at a point where he suspects he is losing the argument about how women should dress and style their hair while praying, he appeals to the universal (he claims) practice of the church, the first known example of what is now called the sensus fidelium – the “sense of the faithful”. You can almost hear the exasperation as he exclaims: “But if someone wants to argue about this, we don’t have such a custom, nor do God’s churches” (1 Cor 11:16 CEB).

The sections of the letter that are used the most in the lectionary are chapters 1, 12 and 15. We will look at those in a moment after a glance at the most famous chapter, his meditation on love. In the Sunday lectionary, 1 Cor 13 is read only on the 4th Sunday of Ordinary Time (Epiphany 4), Year C, but is regularly used on other occasions, especially weddings. It is worth noting that in context, it is the centrepiece of several chapters talking about the proper conduct of worship, and particularly those who are competitive about the hospitality, gifts and talents they bring to the common assembly. Love is Paul’s antidote to practicing church as a competition between its members for power and status.

The preceding chapter (12) has been read through on the preceding two Sundays, focusing first on the differing gifts each have received through the Spirit, and then on how church is meant to function as a body functions, with each part, each gift, needing the other for completeness. A section of this chapter is also read on Pentecost in Year A, a reminder that for Paul the church is a community that works through the Spirit’s energizing, but that the supreme fruit of the Spirit, love, is a far surer guide to discerning the Spirit’s work than any particular gift that an individual contributes to the community.

The first chapter of the letter shows Paul rooting everything he says in the paradox of the crucified Messiah.3 This is where he now finds God’s wisdom, a turning upside down of Roman values. The cross contradicts the values of competition, a constant seeking to come out of any argument, business transaction, lawsuit, competition or fight as top dog. Rome had elevated the pursuit of honour and glory through such practices into an art form. The cross subverts this way of life, and as an apostle of the crucified Christ Paul makes his humble service, and the poverty in which he chooses to operate, into a badge of honour.4

At the other end of the letter, the fifteenth chapter sets out Paul’s most detailed exposition of the resurrection. Apart from readings on Easter Day (and at funerals), it also provides the epistle for the 5th – 7th Sundays of Ordinary Time (the Sundays before Lent when there are more than two in the Anglican Calendar) in Year C. Paul sets out an understanding of the resurrection which embraces a transformation of the physical: the bodies we have now are constituted of flesh and blood; the bodies we will have will be constituted of spirit.

He rules out any understanding of resurrection that looks like resuscitation of a corpse. He equally rules out any understanding which reduces resurrection to nothing but present day spiritual experience. In part, he is trying to find a language to talk about something which cannot be fully put into words.5

Where we tend to use language of “the soul” to mean our continuing identity, Paul uses the language of “soul” to mean the life-force, or breath – as in the saying “while I have breath in my body”. Our present bodies are given life by “soul”, our future bodies will be given life by the Spirit. Our present bodies are made of the stuff of this creation, mortal flesh and blood. Our future bodies will be made of some other appropriate stuff, whatever the equivalent of flesh and blood is in a renewed creation.

It is all rather confusing in the detail, but clear in the overall conviction. Christ has defeated death, and will complete his victory when the creation, and our bodies, are alike transformed into something new: something that belongs to the immortal and eternal realm of God’s future, and able fully to experience God’s presence. What matters most is that we live out our existence in the here and now, knowing that this is how the human story will end, in ways that direct our lives towards that ending, and in faithfulness to the one who has “revealed the resurrection by rising to new life.”6

Notes

  1. Both Peter and Cephas are names based respectively on the Greek (petra) and Aramaic (kepha) words for rock.

  2. This last reading is of course set for Maundy Thursday and Corpus Christi.

  3. See the introduction to Paul in this post.

  4. This argument climaxes in chapter 4, which provides readings for the feasts of SS Matthias and Bartholomew.

  5. Paul seems to be almost re-inventing language here, perhaps to counteract the language the Corinthians are using. For him, soul, psyche, is the opposite of spirit, pneuma. He also uses the adjectives from both of these words: “soulish” (psychikos) and spiritual (pneumatikos). Translators have always struggled with psychikos – usually going for some variant of “physical” or “natural”. It means the opposite of whatever “spiritual” means.

    “Spiritual” here, I think, means something like, “belonging to the age in which the Spirit lives fully in all creation”, so its opposite, “physical” or “natural” means the world in which the eternal Spirit is a stranger, and life is transient, destined for death. In both worlds, for Paul, living beings have bodies, so he can talk of a “physical” or “natural” body in this world, and a “spiritual” body in the next. This strange use of Paul’s language is one reason why language of a “physical” resurrection rather than a “bodily” resurrection creates problems in contemporary discussions.

  6. Anglican Eucharistic Prayer B. The equivalent in the preface to the new Roman Eucharistic Prayer 2 is “to break the bonds of death and manifest the resurrection.”

Welcome to Lection and Liturgy

Welcome to Lection and Liturgy. I have backed up to this site a series of posts making a guide to the whole of the Christian Bible, aimed p...

Some frequently read posts