Showing posts with label Pastoral Letters. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Pastoral Letters. Show all posts

Thursday, 31 December 2020

House rules and cultural accommodation: the Pastoral letters

Icon of St Timothy. Via Wikimedia Commons.

The Sunday lectionary reads selections from 1 & 2 Timothy through in sequence towards the end of Year C,1 and uses a couple of short excerpts from Titus in the selections for Christmas Day. As I noted in my introduction to Paul’s letters, these three are sufficiently like each other to be grouped together, and sufficiently different from Paul’s other letters for many people to wonder if he wrote them. Although they are usually called, collectively, the Pastoral Letters, I think they might better be thought of as “organisational letters” written for those who have some responsibility for organising the church.

Whether Paul did write them, directly, indirectly or not at all, they are in any case different in form. They are not letters to churches, but letters from a senior to a junior colleague. If Paul (as the letters say) calls Timothy and Titus his “sons” in the faith, we should remember that was not simply a relationship of affection, but one in which the father could lay claim to the obedience of the son, and direct him how to carry out his life and work. That alone would be enough to give them a very particular tone.

In the presumed relationship between Paul and these two “sons”, we also see something of the way in which the church comes to structure itself. The offices of bishop and deacon, which first appear at Philippi (Phil 1:1) now seem to be becoming more widespread as terms for leaders (1 Tim 3:1-13). The family relationships that Paul claims for himself, and Timothy and Titus as his household, also become a model for church leadership, and a means of discerning the calling to it: “if someone does not know how to manage his own household, how can he take care of God’s church?” (1 Tim 3:5).

The place of women in the church seems to be taking a further step backwards even from the situation in Colossians and Ephesians. First Timothy in particular seems to take a very big step away from Paul’s acceptance of women as colleagues. There is unfortunately insufficient context to help us understand if a very particular problem is being addressed, or if this apparent change in the status of women in the church is a good reason for doubting these letters come in any straightforward way from Paul’s pen.2

Bishops and deacons, and the letters still seem to expect women to be counted among the deacons (1 Tim 3:11), seem to exist as groups sharing leadership rather than isolated individual ministers. Elders (Tit 1:5) and bishops (Tit 1:7) seem to be interchangeable titles. The idea of a single bishop in a place doesn’t seem to really arrive until St Ignatius of Antioch at the beginning of the second century. However, Timothy and Titus do, rather like Paul, operate much more as individual leaders – much more like later monarchical bishops – even if they have collegial groups to work with. Whereas First Timothy and Titus address the role of each as church organiser, Second Timothy concentrates on Timothy’s role as a teacher, continuing Paul’s work of passing on the nascent Christian tradition (2 Tim 2:2; 2:24-25; 3:14-4:5).

If the previous section on the Thessalonian letters showed us a church carried away with enthusiasm for the end of the world, these three letters show it dug in for the long haul. They form an early version of handbooks for managing the pastoral care of the church, and legislating practically for a church that isn’t yet organised by law and custom.

Some of the trajectories which will lead to the more fully developed church of the second century are now plainly visible, and this strange mix of radicalism and conservatism will continue to interact with each other in the history of the church. There is always a tension between passing on the faith and teaching of the gospel, and seeking to adapt the life and understanding of the church appropriately to the world in which it does so.

Notes

  1. Propers 19 – 25, 24th – 30th Sundays in Ordinary Time.

  2. The most problematic verses (1 Tim 2:12-15) also bristle with translation issues: does the writer forbid women to have authority over men, or forbid wives from bossing their husbands about? Does he say women’s salvation depends on having children, or that women will be kept safe through childbirth if they live appropriately obedient lives? It is these kinds of questions that help stir the pot about whether Paul could possibly have written such verses. Fortunately, these verses need not trouble readers of the Sunday lectionary, as they are (quite wisely!) not used.

Wednesday, 30 December 2020

Paul: a health warning

I expect this to be the first of two posts introducing Paul. In the second, I want to take a look at some of his characteristic themes, but today, I want to renew a health warning I have occasionally mentioned elsewhere. Everything you read here is just my opinion. I hope my opinions are well-grounded in the text and the world it was written in. I hope they provide good, illuminating and helpful ways of reading the text. I hope they help you read it, for yourself, and to others, with fresh understanding. But there are always other opinions available.

This variety of views is nowhere more obvious than it is with regard to Paul’s writings. One of the earliest comments we have on them comes in the Second Letter of Peter:

So also our beloved brother Paul wrote to you according to the wisdom given him, speaking of this as he does in all his letters. There are some things in them hard to understand, which the ignorant and unstable twist to their own destruction, as they do the other scriptures. (2 Peter 3:15-16)

El Greco’s early 17th century painting of St Paul. Via Wikimedia Commons

For most of the last 500 years, there has been a dominant tradition of reading Paul that owed a huge amount to Martin Luther, John Calvin and the Protestant Reformation. It assumed Paul was a Protestant, and often forgot he was a Jew. Most of the critical scholarship that developed in the modern period did so in a Protestant context, and this favoured the letters which stressed the themes of the Reformation, above all the letter to the Romans. Other views were very much in the minority.

In the last quarter of the twentieth century, this consensus was pretty much shattered, although the view still has many fans. But with the breaking of that consensus, just about every possible interpretation of Paul is now seriously offered in scholarly argument, even if only by a handful of people. That means that for most of us, understanding Paul has become something of a minefield.

You won’t have to go far to find someone who will passionately disagree with some or even much of what I say. Nonetheless, I hope, bearing that health warning in mind, what I say here will commend itself to you by helping make sense of Paul’s writings, not least the passages that we read in the lectionary. I will only occasionally draw your attention to these controversies, and concentrate much more on Paul’s own themes.

Gaining an understanding of Paul does matter for those who read it in public worship. The lectionary has more selections from Paul than from any other biblical author, even if we only count the letters nearly everyone agrees that he wrote. That may be a new idea to you, that some people think Paul is not the author of all the books that bear his name, or you may have come across it before. It’s one we need to look at briefly.

Which letters did Paul write? Well, in one sense, none of them. He composed letters, yes, but the actual writing was left to others: fellow workers doing the work of scribes, and possibly amateur scribes at that. Typically, we can think of Paul dictating his letters, and occasionally scrawling something on the parchment or papyrus. At the end of his most frantic and angry letter to the Galatians he adds: “See what large letters I make when I am writing in my own hand” (Gal 6:11). They are large letters in contrast to the neater writing of a practiced scribe, perhaps a professional writer, perhaps a slave in a Christian household. Sometimes the scribe adds his own line, as Tertius does at the end of Romans (Rom 16:22).

For most scholars, there are differences in style between Paul’s letters. Some are much more noticeable than others. (These are often harder to spot in translation: we might notice whether something sounds more like the King James Version or the Message, but translations often make the biblical authors sound quite like each other!) These differences of style raise questions whether they are due to a scribe having more say in the content, Paul addressing a different audience and tailoring his style accordingly, or someone else writing in Paul’s name (with or without his authority to do so). In particular, many scholars have serious doubts about whether Paul wrote the letters to Timothy and Titus.

Collectively but somewhat misleadingly these are referred to as the Pastoral Epistles. They are much more Organisational Letters in which Paul (the presumed author) tells Timothy or Titus (the presumed recipient) how to run the church. In these there is a very different style, but also a very different context, as letters written (on the surface at least) by an apostle able to give orders to a junior colleague, and expect them to be carried out. In these letters, he does not need to persuade a church to go along with him. For many people, the style (and some content) is simply too different to be Paul. Others are still persuaded Paul is (in at least some sense) the authorial mind behind the text.

Most of Paul’s letters, however, are written as letters to specific churches, addressing particular problems. We are in the frustrating position of someone overhearing a phone call: we can hear one end of the conversation, but we have no idea what the other party is saying. We have to make guesses about the situation, the problem, and the question being asked from the comments and answers Paul makes. There’s plenty of room to misunderstand details there.

Because Paul is always responding off the cuff to particular contexts, his thoughts spread across the different letters. He will emphasise one theme here, and another there. He never sits down to organise his thoughts into a neat theological system. Unfortunately, perhaps, there have been an awful lot of people who have wanted to do it for him, and they have often turned his occasional arguments into a comprehensive theology.

This is another reason for the arguments about which letters Paul himself wrote. There’s always a risk that people construct their own picture of Paul’s theology, and then chuck out the letters that don’t fit very well. For rather a long time, one of the arguments used against Paul’s authorship of Ephesians, or the Pastoral Letters, was that they were too churchy. That, however, says more about the dominance of post-Enlightenment German Protestantism in modern scholarship, than it does about Paul.

Paul is often landed with a bad reputation. That may say as much about his interpreters and their prejudices as it does about Paul. The perceived prejudices mask someone who was sometimes quite revolutionary in his attitudes to Graeco-Roman society. I find him a fascinating character: not always one I’d have felt very comfortable to be with, but someone who was and is endlessly stimulating. In my next post, I’ll take a look at some key ideas.

Welcome to Lection and Liturgy

Welcome to Lection and Liturgy. I have backed up to this site a series of posts making a guide to the whole of the Christian Bible, aimed p...

Some frequently read posts