Showing posts with label Paul and Women. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Paul and Women. Show all posts

Thursday, 31 December 2020

House rules and cultural accommodation: the Pastoral letters

Icon of St Timothy. Via Wikimedia Commons.

The Sunday lectionary reads selections from 1 & 2 Timothy through in sequence towards the end of Year C,1 and uses a couple of short excerpts from Titus in the selections for Christmas Day. As I noted in my introduction to Paul’s letters, these three are sufficiently like each other to be grouped together, and sufficiently different from Paul’s other letters for many people to wonder if he wrote them. Although they are usually called, collectively, the Pastoral Letters, I think they might better be thought of as “organisational letters” written for those who have some responsibility for organising the church.

Whether Paul did write them, directly, indirectly or not at all, they are in any case different in form. They are not letters to churches, but letters from a senior to a junior colleague. If Paul (as the letters say) calls Timothy and Titus his “sons” in the faith, we should remember that was not simply a relationship of affection, but one in which the father could lay claim to the obedience of the son, and direct him how to carry out his life and work. That alone would be enough to give them a very particular tone.

In the presumed relationship between Paul and these two “sons”, we also see something of the way in which the church comes to structure itself. The offices of bishop and deacon, which first appear at Philippi (Phil 1:1) now seem to be becoming more widespread as terms for leaders (1 Tim 3:1-13). The family relationships that Paul claims for himself, and Timothy and Titus as his household, also become a model for church leadership, and a means of discerning the calling to it: “if someone does not know how to manage his own household, how can he take care of God’s church?” (1 Tim 3:5).

The place of women in the church seems to be taking a further step backwards even from the situation in Colossians and Ephesians. First Timothy in particular seems to take a very big step away from Paul’s acceptance of women as colleagues. There is unfortunately insufficient context to help us understand if a very particular problem is being addressed, or if this apparent change in the status of women in the church is a good reason for doubting these letters come in any straightforward way from Paul’s pen.2

Bishops and deacons, and the letters still seem to expect women to be counted among the deacons (1 Tim 3:11), seem to exist as groups sharing leadership rather than isolated individual ministers. Elders (Tit 1:5) and bishops (Tit 1:7) seem to be interchangeable titles. The idea of a single bishop in a place doesn’t seem to really arrive until St Ignatius of Antioch at the beginning of the second century. However, Timothy and Titus do, rather like Paul, operate much more as individual leaders – much more like later monarchical bishops – even if they have collegial groups to work with. Whereas First Timothy and Titus address the role of each as church organiser, Second Timothy concentrates on Timothy’s role as a teacher, continuing Paul’s work of passing on the nascent Christian tradition (2 Tim 2:2; 2:24-25; 3:14-4:5).

If the previous section on the Thessalonian letters showed us a church carried away with enthusiasm for the end of the world, these three letters show it dug in for the long haul. They form an early version of handbooks for managing the pastoral care of the church, and legislating practically for a church that isn’t yet organised by law and custom.

Some of the trajectories which will lead to the more fully developed church of the second century are now plainly visible, and this strange mix of radicalism and conservatism will continue to interact with each other in the history of the church. There is always a tension between passing on the faith and teaching of the gospel, and seeking to adapt the life and understanding of the church appropriately to the world in which it does so.

Notes

  1. Propers 19 – 25, 24th – 30th Sundays in Ordinary Time.

  2. The most problematic verses (1 Tim 2:12-15) also bristle with translation issues: does the writer forbid women to have authority over men, or forbid wives from bossing their husbands about? Does he say women’s salvation depends on having children, or that women will be kept safe through childbirth if they live appropriately obedient lives? It is these kinds of questions that help stir the pot about whether Paul could possibly have written such verses. Fortunately, these verses need not trouble readers of the Sunday lectionary, as they are (quite wisely!) not used.

Colonies of heaven: Christianity as a Roman religion in Philippians

Christianity might have been born in a thoroughly Jewish home, but it quickly got sent to a Roman boarding school. In Paul’s letter to the church at Philippi, we see something of that happening. Philippi, like Corinth was a Roman colony, and Paul draws rather more positively on that heritage to shape his language when he writes to the Philippians, than he does in his more troubled relationship with Corinth. Indeed, it may well have been the Philippian church Paul had in mind when he spoke of the generosity of the Macedonian churches (2 Corinthians 8:1-7), appealing to the competitive spirit at Corinth, and trying to get them to up their game in the generosity stakes.

Paul envisages in Philippians that his death might be a very real possible outcome of his imprisonment. The picture is the traditional site of Paul’s burial in Rome.

Certainly there is a strong note of thanks in the letter, not least for the practical help the Philippians have sent Paul via Epaphroditus (Phil 2:25; 4:18). This practical, probably financial, help also appears to be included in what he means by their “sharing in the gospel” (Phil 1:5) He returns at the end to more thanks for their support even in the earliest days of his mission (Phil 4:15-19).

At Corinth he turned down financial support, fearful of being tied to the richer factions of the church (1 Cor 9:3-18). From the Philippians he accepted it, and saw it as more than enough to reciprocate what God had given them through his ministry. It is in reciprocal gift-giving that both divine and human relationships are created and sustained. In this letter, we see Paul making much of that.

Much of the letter is read in the Sunday lectionary, especially in Year A, yet if gratitude expressed in thanksgiving and joy provides the frame for the letter, and the subject of some of those readings, there are still problems Paul needs to address. One of those problems seems to be coming from outside the church, from those who continue to commend Torah observance (Phil 3).

Whether that is a serious problem at Philippi, or whether Paul has it on his mind because of dealing with it elsewhere is unclear. Combatting such views allows him to rehearse his characteristic themes of Christ as the model of faithfulness (Phil 2:6-11), of the overwhelming value of God’s gift in Christ devaluing by comparison all human achievement (Phil 3:2-10), and of the transformation of our physical reality by the coming of Christ (Phil 3:17-21).

One difference in the way he addresses this future transformation seems to be occasioned by Philippi’s status as a Roman colony, refounded by Augustus Caesar after his defeat of Mark Anthony at the battle of Actium some 90 or so years before Paul writes. It may be that he shows off a little bit to this pro-Roman city, that through his imprisonment (probably in Rome towards the end of his life) his message is known both to the imperial guard (Phil 1:13) and to the imperial civil service, where he has made converts (Phil 4:22)1

The most significant use Paul makes of this Roman context (his imprisonment and the Philippian heritage) is, however, the metaphor he picks to describe the future appearance of Christ. Augustus had appropriated the title Saviour of the World for himself as emperor, and Paul and other early Christians applied it to Jesus. It has always been political as well as religious language. Moreover, in theory at least, if a Roman colony was beleaguered, it could expect the army to come to its rescue. Paul now uses that imagery to talk about what we typically call “the second coming” but the New Testament tends simply to speak of as the arrival or presence of Christ.2

If the point of a Roman colony was to have Roman citizens staking Rome’s claim to a foreign land, Paul’s use of this language portrays the church as heavenly citizens staking God’s claim to a presently alienated world. And if they are beleaguered by this world’s powers, the true Saviour of the world is coming from the heart of God’s heavenly realm to their rescue. (Phil 3:20-21) Paul is quite comfortable in appropriating imperial language for Christ, as for God. It is one of the early steps that made it easier later on for Christian emperors to borrow religious language in turn for their own purposes.

As always, Paul also wants to urge unity on all his churches. One practical reason, and perhaps the dominant one for this letter, is that, as so often, Paul has to respond to a divided church, urging them to have one mind, and reject the all-too-Roman pattern of competition. It is in this context he produces one of his most famous passages, the poem-like verses celebrating Christ as the exemplar of putting God and others before oneself in faithful and humble service (Phil 2:6-11).

He returns near the end of the letter to what may be the heart of the dissension, an argument between two leading women in the church, Euodia and Syntyche (Phil 4:2-3). It is worth noting that he asks someone else to help them reconcile, rather than giving orders. That may reflect that they are high status in both society and the church: another example of women in leadership in the earliest churches. Paul certainly seems to want to get to this important point in a fairly roundabout way. The importance of unity, whether for quarrelling individuals, or for the whole church, is never far from Paul’s mind.

Notes

  1. The phrase Paul uses, “the household of Caesar” has, particularly since the ground-breaking work of Wayne Meeks (The First Urban Christians New Haven and London: Yale University and Press, 1983) been regularly seen as referring not to literal relatives of the emperor, but to the extended family of slaves and freedmen, whom Augustus and especially his successors, used to carry out imperial business.

  2. The word “presence” (Greek parousia) is probably not a technical term at this early stage: even in Philippians Paul simply uses the same word to mean his own presence again with the Philippians (Phil 1:26; 2:12).

A bold vision of a cosmic church: Ephesians

When we turn from Galatians to Ephesians, the change of tone is startling. This is one of those letters where the tone is rather less argumentative as well as less specific than Paul normally is. For many scholars, that suggests a disciple of Paul summarising some key elements of his master’s teaching. For others, it represents simply a different scribe, and Paul in a more reflective and different mode of teaching. The letter certainly shares Paul’s love of long and convoluted sentences, with Eph 1:3-14 essentially being a single sentence in the original Greek (depending on your view of what a sentence is!).

Extracts from Ephesians are mainly read in the summer months in Year B. It also provides a number of epistles for saints’ days. As I say, it seems less specific than many of Paul’s letters, which is a reason some people raise questions about how closely it is connected with Paul himself. Indeed, some of the best and earliest manuscripts don’t actually have a destination: the words “in Ephesus” (Eph 1:1) may well be a later addition to the text. This would further add to the sense of a more general letter. For some that is another reason for questioning how it relates to Paul, for others that is further explanation for why Paul adopted a different writing style. 

The ruins of the theatre at Ephesus. The second tier was added in Paul’s day,
the third tier rather later. Via Wikimedia Commons

Two key emphases in this letter, which seem to develop Paul’s earlier thought, are on the cosmic dimensions of faith and the placing of the church at the heart of the gospel. The union of Jew and Gentile in a single body of Christ, a single humanity in Christ, at the heart of a restored and harmonious creation, is presented as the eternal plan and purpose God has been working towards, even from before he created the world.

The nuts and bolts of that idea are scattered throughout Paul’s earlier writing, but here they are drawn together more boldly. The first three chapters riff on this theme of the mystery of Christ as God’s means to bring about the unity and harmony of the cosmos, with humanity restored in Christ – the church – as the centrepiece of a renewed creation.

The next three chapters (which make up the second half of this letter) bring this vision rather more down to earth. Paul reprises his themes on the unity of the church, with the differing gifts God has given it needing to work together in one body. In 1 Corinthians and Romans, those gifts were mainly conceived as abilities, talents that people brought to the common life. Here, however, they are the different ministers or ministries, which God has given to the church, so that all God’s people can serve him as they grow in mature faith (Eph 4:11-13). There are still plenty of imperfections that need to be addressed, and Christian need to live out in practice the life to which they are called, and continually renounce unethical behaviour.

Towards the end, the letter seems to take a step back from some of Paul’s earlier positions, in a passage not used in the Sunday lectionary. Although the writer puts some stress on the need for husbands to love their wives, fathers not to wind up their children, and masters to treat their slaves well, he nonetheless upholds the basic structures of a patriarchal and authoritarian society. Wives are expected to submit to husbands, children to obey fathers, and slaves give their masters the respect and obedience they owe to Christ. It seems a long way from some of the more radical statements we find elsewhere in Paul, and rather disappointing as a corollary to the lofty vision set out in the first three chapters of this letter.

The church, it seems, needed in the first century, as much as it has done in any other, to make compromises and accommodations with the surrounding society in order to make its message able to be heard. Perhaps the real spiritual battle, with which the letter finishes in fine metaphorical form, is to continue to work out how the vision of God’s purposes needs to be reimagined in every culture. Which compromises are necessary to gain a hearing, and which end up so changing the message that it ceases to be good news from God? There is much prayerful work to be done, in discerning how to translate the faith for every context. 

Constantly ask God’s help in prayer, and pray always in the power of the Spirit. To this end keep watch and persevere, always interceding for all God’s people. Pray also for me, that I may be granted the right words when I speak, and may boldly and freely make known the hidden purpose of the gospel. (Ephesians 6:18-19 REB)

Wednesday, 30 December 2020

A radical faith in a faithful Messiah: some themes in Paul’s letters

In the previous post, I looked at some of the general issues involved in reading Paul’s letters. In today’s blog, I want to explore a couple of key themes. There are core ideas which crop up repeatedly in Paul’s thinking; but the specific ways he develops them belong to the different contexts of each individual letter.

One idea which crops up in a number of contexts is usually called “justification by faith”. Since some people suggest this is Paul’s main, only, or central theme, we need to spend a little bit of time looking at it here, while saving many other themes for individual letters. It’s probably also worth repeating my previously given health warning: other views of Paul are available, and here we enter one of the more controversial (and occasionally rather bad-tempered) areas of both modern scholarship and church-dividing doctrine.

Statue of St Paul in St Paul outside the Walls, Rome. Paul is commonly represented with a sword as a metaphor for the Word of God. This church is the traditional site of his burial.

Justification by faith was a key plank in the way Martin Luther interpreted Paul at the beginning of the Protestant Reformation. In Luther’s view, this was about how people could get to heaven, and he opposed it to the piety of the mediaeval church. In a nutshell, mediaeval Christians were shaped by participating in worship, pious works, almsgiving, penances, indulgences, and the good deeds of the saints. This created an (ecclesiastically very profitable) economy of salvation which was intended to help people make their earthly pilgrimage towards God, making up for their lapses and bad behaviour in purgatory, and helped along by the prayers of the faithful and the merits of Christ and the saints.

Luther cut through this economy, and the papal purse strings with it, by a simple insistence that faith – perhaps better “trust” – in Christ as having died for him (me, you, everyone) was all that was needed. When he did this, he mentally and literally translated Paul’s language of “works of the Law” into meaning the general “good works” mediaeval Christianity encouraged people to practice.

In doing so, he certainly captured two of Paul’s most important ideas. First, that trust in Christ is central to the Christian life, and second, that Christ’s crucifixion is central to how God transforms this world destined for death into the new reality of a creation restored to eternal life. On the downside, he made the Jews into examples of everything Christians shouldn’t be, and gave later German anti-Semitism some of its most forceful impetus.

In developing his contrast between faith and works, and gospel and law, he also slightly skewed what I want to suggest is Paul’s primary contrast, which is between Christ and Torah. For Paul, this goes back at least to the experience that Luke tells us happened on the road to Damascus. The Torah, as Paul read it in his youth, does not allow for the possibility of a crucified Messiah. It teaches (as we saw when looking at Deuteronomy) that there are two ways: the way of life and the way of death. Its instruction guides the people of God in the way of life. It promises blessing on the way of life, and threatens a curse on the way of death. And, as Paul notes when writing to the Galatians, it specifically states that anyone who is hanged upon a tree1 is cursed (Gal 3:13, quoting Deut 21:23). This is no doubt one of the main reasons why Paul persecutes the early Christians. They are (in his view before his conversion) making the law out to be a liar by saying God has blessed Jesus, when the law says quite clearly that Jesus is cursed.2

When Paul has his experience of Jesus, which he insists is an encounter with the risen Jesus as valid as any of the post-Easter appearances,3 he discovers for himself that, far from being cursed by God, Jesus is vindicated by God; far from being dead, he has been raised to life. Paul, as a good Pharisee, understood resurrection as the culmination of the kingdom of God for all Israel and the vindication of God’s people.4 Now he understands it as what has happened to and with Jesus; God has vindicated Jesus and declared him a truthful teacher, a faithful servant and a righteous son. From this experience, Paul develops a multifaceted contrast between Torah and Christ.

One of the principal contrasts is between two different ways of faithfulness. Torah taught one way of being faithful to God. It involved obedience to the commands of the law; this helped mark out a pure people, and gave them the appropriate means of reconciling oneself to God through the sacrificial system. Following the Maccabean crisis,5 the things that particularly marked out the purity of the people among the nations were the food-laws (especially eating pork), circumcision, and the keeping of the Sabbath. It’s therefore not surprising that these became a particular focus for some of Paul’s conflicts.

Jesus, his whole life and death, offers an alternative pattern of what faithfulness to God looks like. At its core is his willingness to embrace the ultimate impurity of a cursed death, so that he might bring the outsider, the sinner, the cursed, into the life of God. This is the vision, poetically summarised in the hymn-like section of Philippians,6 which drives Paul into the Gentile world. He casts aside his previous Pharisaic emphasis on purity, to embrace the profane world with Christ’s love. As Christ was faithful even to death on a cross, so Christians are called to follow him, so that they also may be justified – i.e. found to be on God’s side – by imitating the faithfulness of Jesus. This is why Paul can conclude his most extended argument of the theme of justification, the letter to the Romans, with the pithy ethical conclusion: “Welcome one another, therefore, just as Christ has welcomed you, for the glory of God.” (Rom 15:7).

There is one other general point worth making in this introductory section on Paul’s letters. An unfortunate picture has grown of Paul as a misogynist. There are certainly some passages which can be read in ways which now look decidedly unaffirming of women, but that was generally true of the whole of Graeco-Roman culture, in which women lived out their lives under the authority of a male relative.

However, in both Acts and Paul’s letters we see him treat the husband and wife team Priscilla (also called Prisca) and Aquila as colleagues, and interestingly it is usually Priscilla who is named first. He calls Phoebe the deacon his patron (which implies a social superior).7 His long list of friends in Rome includes many women, one of whom, Junia, he refers to as an “outstanding apostle.”8 When he writes to the Corinthians, he does indeed say some very confused and confusing things about head-coverings, but this is part of setting out how women should pray and prophesy in public worship.9

More interestingly, earlier in the letter, setting out his teaching on marriage, he follows what might be thought of as conventional patriarchal teaching (“the wife does not have authority over her own body, but the husband does”) with a rather more radical and counter-cultural egalitarianism (“likewise the husband does not have authority over his own body, but the wife does”).10 We might feel uncomfortable with both halves of Paul’s equation today, with our deeply rooted commitment to individuals having rights over their own body rather than another’s. However, this remains a fascinating example of Paul being more radically egalitarian than he is normally assumed to be.

There are other passages we could point to, but perhaps that is enough to show something of Paul’s radicalism and complexity, while remembering that he is still a man of his time. Sometimes our translations can be so good, that we forget the ideas being expressed in our modern words may mean something rather different in the culture of the first-century Mediterranean.11 Expecting Paul to be woke and judging him where he is not is simply an anachronism. He needs to be read against the horizon of his own day.

Notes

  1. In one of Peter’s speeches in Acts, the phrase “hanging on a tree” is also used as a way of referring to the crucifixion of Jesus (Acts 5:30).

  2. This is, I think, part of what Paul is getting at in 1 Corinthians 12:3 – “So I want to make it clear to you that no one says, “Jesus is cursed!” when speaking by God’s Spirit, and no one can say, “Jesus is Lord,” except by the Holy Spirit.” (Common English Bible) The Law, which only knows the pre-resurrection reality, says there’s a curse on Jesus, the Spirit, gift of resurrection life, says Jesus is God’s vindicated Messiah – the one with God’s own name of “Lord”.

  3. Though he also seems to be aware that there was something very different about it as well: the description he uses for his experience is not so much “born again”, but “like a miscarriage” (1 Cor 15:8)

  4. See the discussion about Jesus, the Pharisees and the kingdom of God in the section on Matthew’s gospel.

  5. See the discussion of the books of the Maccabees in this post.

  6. In so far as a single short passage offers a summary of Paul’s gospel, Philippians 2:6-11 is as good a contender as any for the role.

  7. The references are Romans 16:3, 16:1.

  8. Romans 16:7 (Jerusalem Bible). Despite the name being obviously feminine, some scribes had turned this into an unknown male name, Junias, and other interpreters, like the translators of the King James Bible, has decided Paul must mean she was “of note among the apostles”. Sometimes Paul gets the blame for what his interpreters do with his writings.

  9. 1 Corinthians 11:2-16. There are good reasons (including the argument of chapter 11 about what women should wear while speaking in church) for thinking the later verses, 1 Cor 14:34-35, which command women to be silent in church, are a later addition by a scribe to Paul’s letter. In some copies of the letter they occur in a different place. This often means something a scribe originally jotted in the margin has found its way into the main text.

  10. 1 Cor 7:4. The section as a whole is longer, but continues to balance the rights of both.

  11. This introduction is already too long! But I shall say more to help locate Paul in his social context in the next posts on Romans and 1 Corinthians especially.

Welcome to Lection and Liturgy

Welcome to Lection and Liturgy. I have backed up to this site a series of posts making a guide to the whole of the Christian Bible, aimed p...

Some frequently read posts