Showing posts with label Justification. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Justification. Show all posts

Wednesday, 30 December 2020

Tracing Paul’s argument in Romans: from Abraham to Jesus and beyond

In my previous post, I offered a picture of the context at Rome which causes Paul to write this letter. It is written to a city in which divisions between Jews and Greeks focussed on claims about Jesus have previously boiled over, and may be heating up again. I noted that more than in most letters, with Romans you need a grasp of the overall argument to see the meaning of any individual reading. Today I offer that kind of outline of how I read this letter. There are others.

The Colosseum, built after Paul’s day, reminds us how much violence was a feature of the Roman Empire

Paul’s first three chapters, after an opening greeting, step straight into this. Paul initially takes up and repeats the common criticisms Jews made of the pagan world, and then he echoes some not atypical Roman anti-Semitic attacks on Jews. Both are shown to deserve the criticism the other dishes out, but Paul goes on to privilege the Jewish scriptural tradition, not because it was given to the Jews, but because it was given by God. God will be faithful even when God’s people are not. In point of fact, the scripture reinforces the mutual criticism Jew and Greek heap on each other, for it says “There is no-one righteous, no, not one.” (Rom 3:10)1

From this rather dismal conclusion, that everybody is in the wrong, Paul recounts God’s call to Abraham, and how Abraham was treated by God as righteous, because he put his trust in God. The theme of chapter four is that God treated Abraham as righteous before he was circumcised, and therefore circumcision is not necessary. Abraham’s trust, that God could give him new life (a son) even though his body was as good as dead (being well past the age of reproduction) is paralleled to the Christian trust in God for life, as the one who raises the dead Jesus.

Paul goes on in chapter five to contrast Jesus with Adam. The biblical story reveals how things were changed for the whole human race through the acts of one man, and so Paul argues that equally through the acts of another man, the condition of the human race is changed again. Yet the comparison is limited: the first man was judged for one single sin. Since then countless sins have been committed, yet the relationship-restoring gift of Jesus – a life faithfully obedient even to death – is more than enough to overcome all sin.

If this is God’s gift to us, Paul goes on to say in chapter six, then we need seriously to reciprocate by giving our lives to God. If God in Christ has taken human death, the consequence of sin, to give us life, then we must leave sin behind, and live our lives with the same faithfulness that Christ has shown. Paul extends that in chapter seven with a parable of everyman, or Adam. God’s commandment, God’s law, was precisely the thing that made disobedience possible. If there is no law, I can’t break it. Once I am taught morality, I can be tempted to do wrong. What I need is a new kind of life, a new nature and not a new law.

The death of Jesus is the death of our old humanity: the mortality promised Adam as a punishment for his law-breaking is embraced by Jesus in order to bring it to an end. In his resurrection, Jesus opens up a new kind of life. That life, as Paul goes on to say in chapter eight, is the life of the Spirit, and it is not just about the renewal of humankind, but the liberation of all creation. If in his opening chapter, Paul described a creation having gone wrong, turned away from God, and into itself, in this closing chapter of his primary theological argument, he looks forward to “the hope that the universe itself is to be freed from the shackles of mortality and is to enter the glorious liberty of the children of God” (Romans 8:21 REB).

In all of this, Paul has effectively put the law to one side. The good things the law teaches are now enshrined for us in the example of obedience given by Jesus: this is what faithfulness looks like. The bad effect of the law, tempting us to disobedience, is now dealt with by Christ, who has experienced the promised judicial punishment of the human race, and has been acquitted on appeal by God, setting the human race free. The law, therefore, has no continuing purpose. It can neither function any longer as a barrier separating Jew from Greek, nor can any Jew expect Greeks who believe in Jesus to keep its commandments. It belongs to a past humanity that died with Jesus on the cross.

On the other hand, Paul is well aware that he runs a real risk that the Greek Christians will feel themselves superior, certainly to non-Jesus-believing Jews, and probably to Jewish Christians as well. In chapters 9-11, he therefore tries to set out the ways in which the Jewish people belong to God’s purposes, and are his chosen way of getting from Adam and then Abraham, to Christ.

Paul himself is proud of being a Jew, but puts his trust not in his ethnic and religious inheritance, but in the gift of God – in the Christ to whom the Jewish scriptures have now led him. It is a a cause of sadness for Paul that so few Jews seem to accept Jesus in place of Torah as the model of faithfulness and the life-giving gift of God. Despite this, Paul still wants to hold on to the overwhelming generosity of God’s gift as being stronger than the human power to reject it. He draws this section to a close affirming his faith in God’s love, his hope for Jewish redemption, and his inability to plumb the depths of how exactly God will work it all out.

From there he passes to the practical outworking of this new life, and new set of relationships. We have already looked at the key plank of avoiding violence and vengeance, as befits those who follow the crucified Christ rather than a warrior Messiah. Paul elaborates some of the key themes of Christian living, stressing the unity of the church, and maintaining good relationships, with those outside, as well as within the church. There are a number of echoes of Jesus’ words in this: Paul is not ignorant of some of the teaching we find in the gospel. In particular, where ethnic or religious traditions give people scruples about eating certain sorts of food, it is very important to practice generosity and welcome to those who hold different views.

It is clear from a number of his injunctions that the church in Rome is (to pt it mildly) somewhat divided. Paul, however, has not given up on his hope to be sent on his way to Spain by a church united behind him. Rather than his practical need, it is the preceding lengthy exposition of the gift of God, a generosity that comes precisely to those who do not deserve it, which drives the ethical force. If we seek to be faithful as Christ was faithful, we must treat one another with the generosity God in Christ has shown to us. The thrust of the letter, as well as the very practical guidance on sharing food together, is summed up “in a word, accept one another as Christ accepted you, to the glory of God” (Romans 15:7).2

Notes

  1. This begins a string of quotations, mainly drawn from the psalms, that roots Paul’s conclusion in the scriptures he and those he’s arguing with share.

  2. The REB, which I mainly follow here, has “accepted us” rather than “accepted you”. Some manuscripts have “us” and some “you”. (The words were probably identical in pronunciation by the second century at the latest.) Most translations go with the rhetorically rather more forceful “you”.

A radical faith in a faithful Messiah: some themes in Paul’s letters

In the previous post, I looked at some of the general issues involved in reading Paul’s letters. In today’s blog, I want to explore a couple of key themes. There are core ideas which crop up repeatedly in Paul’s thinking; but the specific ways he develops them belong to the different contexts of each individual letter.

One idea which crops up in a number of contexts is usually called “justification by faith”. Since some people suggest this is Paul’s main, only, or central theme, we need to spend a little bit of time looking at it here, while saving many other themes for individual letters. It’s probably also worth repeating my previously given health warning: other views of Paul are available, and here we enter one of the more controversial (and occasionally rather bad-tempered) areas of both modern scholarship and church-dividing doctrine.

Statue of St Paul in St Paul outside the Walls, Rome. Paul is commonly represented with a sword as a metaphor for the Word of God. This church is the traditional site of his burial.

Justification by faith was a key plank in the way Martin Luther interpreted Paul at the beginning of the Protestant Reformation. In Luther’s view, this was about how people could get to heaven, and he opposed it to the piety of the mediaeval church. In a nutshell, mediaeval Christians were shaped by participating in worship, pious works, almsgiving, penances, indulgences, and the good deeds of the saints. This created an (ecclesiastically very profitable) economy of salvation which was intended to help people make their earthly pilgrimage towards God, making up for their lapses and bad behaviour in purgatory, and helped along by the prayers of the faithful and the merits of Christ and the saints.

Luther cut through this economy, and the papal purse strings with it, by a simple insistence that faith – perhaps better “trust” – in Christ as having died for him (me, you, everyone) was all that was needed. When he did this, he mentally and literally translated Paul’s language of “works of the Law” into meaning the general “good works” mediaeval Christianity encouraged people to practice.

In doing so, he certainly captured two of Paul’s most important ideas. First, that trust in Christ is central to the Christian life, and second, that Christ’s crucifixion is central to how God transforms this world destined for death into the new reality of a creation restored to eternal life. On the downside, he made the Jews into examples of everything Christians shouldn’t be, and gave later German anti-Semitism some of its most forceful impetus.

In developing his contrast between faith and works, and gospel and law, he also slightly skewed what I want to suggest is Paul’s primary contrast, which is between Christ and Torah. For Paul, this goes back at least to the experience that Luke tells us happened on the road to Damascus. The Torah, as Paul read it in his youth, does not allow for the possibility of a crucified Messiah. It teaches (as we saw when looking at Deuteronomy) that there are two ways: the way of life and the way of death. Its instruction guides the people of God in the way of life. It promises blessing on the way of life, and threatens a curse on the way of death. And, as Paul notes when writing to the Galatians, it specifically states that anyone who is hanged upon a tree1 is cursed (Gal 3:13, quoting Deut 21:23). This is no doubt one of the main reasons why Paul persecutes the early Christians. They are (in his view before his conversion) making the law out to be a liar by saying God has blessed Jesus, when the law says quite clearly that Jesus is cursed.2

When Paul has his experience of Jesus, which he insists is an encounter with the risen Jesus as valid as any of the post-Easter appearances,3 he discovers for himself that, far from being cursed by God, Jesus is vindicated by God; far from being dead, he has been raised to life. Paul, as a good Pharisee, understood resurrection as the culmination of the kingdom of God for all Israel and the vindication of God’s people.4 Now he understands it as what has happened to and with Jesus; God has vindicated Jesus and declared him a truthful teacher, a faithful servant and a righteous son. From this experience, Paul develops a multifaceted contrast between Torah and Christ.

One of the principal contrasts is between two different ways of faithfulness. Torah taught one way of being faithful to God. It involved obedience to the commands of the law; this helped mark out a pure people, and gave them the appropriate means of reconciling oneself to God through the sacrificial system. Following the Maccabean crisis,5 the things that particularly marked out the purity of the people among the nations were the food-laws (especially eating pork), circumcision, and the keeping of the Sabbath. It’s therefore not surprising that these became a particular focus for some of Paul’s conflicts.

Jesus, his whole life and death, offers an alternative pattern of what faithfulness to God looks like. At its core is his willingness to embrace the ultimate impurity of a cursed death, so that he might bring the outsider, the sinner, the cursed, into the life of God. This is the vision, poetically summarised in the hymn-like section of Philippians,6 which drives Paul into the Gentile world. He casts aside his previous Pharisaic emphasis on purity, to embrace the profane world with Christ’s love. As Christ was faithful even to death on a cross, so Christians are called to follow him, so that they also may be justified – i.e. found to be on God’s side – by imitating the faithfulness of Jesus. This is why Paul can conclude his most extended argument of the theme of justification, the letter to the Romans, with the pithy ethical conclusion: “Welcome one another, therefore, just as Christ has welcomed you, for the glory of God.” (Rom 15:7).

There is one other general point worth making in this introductory section on Paul’s letters. An unfortunate picture has grown of Paul as a misogynist. There are certainly some passages which can be read in ways which now look decidedly unaffirming of women, but that was generally true of the whole of Graeco-Roman culture, in which women lived out their lives under the authority of a male relative.

However, in both Acts and Paul’s letters we see him treat the husband and wife team Priscilla (also called Prisca) and Aquila as colleagues, and interestingly it is usually Priscilla who is named first. He calls Phoebe the deacon his patron (which implies a social superior).7 His long list of friends in Rome includes many women, one of whom, Junia, he refers to as an “outstanding apostle.”8 When he writes to the Corinthians, he does indeed say some very confused and confusing things about head-coverings, but this is part of setting out how women should pray and prophesy in public worship.9

More interestingly, earlier in the letter, setting out his teaching on marriage, he follows what might be thought of as conventional patriarchal teaching (“the wife does not have authority over her own body, but the husband does”) with a rather more radical and counter-cultural egalitarianism (“likewise the husband does not have authority over his own body, but the wife does”).10 We might feel uncomfortable with both halves of Paul’s equation today, with our deeply rooted commitment to individuals having rights over their own body rather than another’s. However, this remains a fascinating example of Paul being more radically egalitarian than he is normally assumed to be.

There are other passages we could point to, but perhaps that is enough to show something of Paul’s radicalism and complexity, while remembering that he is still a man of his time. Sometimes our translations can be so good, that we forget the ideas being expressed in our modern words may mean something rather different in the culture of the first-century Mediterranean.11 Expecting Paul to be woke and judging him where he is not is simply an anachronism. He needs to be read against the horizon of his own day.

Notes

  1. In one of Peter’s speeches in Acts, the phrase “hanging on a tree” is also used as a way of referring to the crucifixion of Jesus (Acts 5:30).

  2. This is, I think, part of what Paul is getting at in 1 Corinthians 12:3 – “So I want to make it clear to you that no one says, “Jesus is cursed!” when speaking by God’s Spirit, and no one can say, “Jesus is Lord,” except by the Holy Spirit.” (Common English Bible) The Law, which only knows the pre-resurrection reality, says there’s a curse on Jesus, the Spirit, gift of resurrection life, says Jesus is God’s vindicated Messiah – the one with God’s own name of “Lord”.

  3. Though he also seems to be aware that there was something very different about it as well: the description he uses for his experience is not so much “born again”, but “like a miscarriage” (1 Cor 15:8)

  4. See the discussion about Jesus, the Pharisees and the kingdom of God in the section on Matthew’s gospel.

  5. See the discussion of the books of the Maccabees in this post.

  6. In so far as a single short passage offers a summary of Paul’s gospel, Philippians 2:6-11 is as good a contender as any for the role.

  7. The references are Romans 16:3, 16:1.

  8. Romans 16:7 (Jerusalem Bible). Despite the name being obviously feminine, some scribes had turned this into an unknown male name, Junias, and other interpreters, like the translators of the King James Bible, has decided Paul must mean she was “of note among the apostles”. Sometimes Paul gets the blame for what his interpreters do with his writings.

  9. 1 Corinthians 11:2-16. There are good reasons (including the argument of chapter 11 about what women should wear while speaking in church) for thinking the later verses, 1 Cor 14:34-35, which command women to be silent in church, are a later addition by a scribe to Paul’s letter. In some copies of the letter they occur in a different place. This often means something a scribe originally jotted in the margin has found its way into the main text.

  10. 1 Cor 7:4. The section as a whole is longer, but continues to balance the rights of both.

  11. This introduction is already too long! But I shall say more to help locate Paul in his social context in the next posts on Romans and 1 Corinthians especially.

Welcome to Lection and Liturgy

Welcome to Lection and Liturgy. I have backed up to this site a series of posts making a guide to the whole of the Christian Bible, aimed p...

Some frequently read posts