Showing posts with label Prophecy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Prophecy. Show all posts

Monday, 28 December 2020

Waiting for the return of the King: at the end of the First Testament

Today’s is the third of three posts looking at the so-called minor prophets. It brings to a close my whistle-stop tour of the First, or Old Testament for those who are trying to understand better what they read in their Sunday assemblies. Today’s four prophets are Zephaniah, Haggai, Zechariah and Malachi.

Zephaniah

Zephaniah tells us that his ministry was in the reign of Josiah. Since he attacks polytheism and idolatry, and condemns priests for breaking the law, perhaps he not only prophesies before Josiah attempts his reform, but is one of those whose ministry makes that reform possible.1

For Zephaniah, the day of the Lord will be a judgement that will purify Jerusalem, and put an end to idols. He concludes with a hopeful promise of the restoration of Jerusalem in which God himself will be king, dancing in celebration with his people as he renews them. It is this final prophecy of joy which is read in both lectionaries.2

Haggai

Haggai is one of two prophets stirring the people to rebuild the temple after their return from exile.3 The political and religious institutions are rather shaky: neither the governor nor the high priest seem to be getting much done. God’s blessing on the returned exiles will not come while they are all putting the rebuilding of their own houses ahead of the rebuilding of the house of God. No Sunday readings come from this brief book.

Detail from a woodcut by Gustave DorĂ©, via Wikimedia: Jesus enacting Zechariah’s prophecy

Zechariah

Zechariah is the longest of these minor prophets. He shares much of the same context as Haggai. His work falls into two main sections. The first, chapters 1-8, like Haggai, is concerned with the rebuilding programme. However, he also has more of a focus on the moral rebuilding of the nation, banning all those who steal and commit perjury from the land. His style is difficult, and he outlines his message drawing on slightly obscure visions. Just judgment is the root from which peace grows.

While there are hopes that the post-exilic rulers will be like a new David in the first section of the book, these messianic hopes become more evident in the second part. Chapters 1-8 contain precise dates and are more obviously about historical events. Chapters 9-14 lack such clear dates and are not organised around the interpretation of visions. Perhaps they are a later attempt to re-interpret the message of the first half as a universal vision of judgement.

Both parts end with a conviction that Jerusalem will be an international centre for the worship of YHWH, as even Israel’s enemies come to pay tribute. The only Sunday reading shared by both lectionaries includes the famous verse from early in this second part of the book. It was read by the early Christians as a prophecy of Palm Sunday, following the lead given them by Jesus, who may well be deliberately dramatising this scripture to say something about himself as king.4

        Lo, your king comes to you;
        triumphant and victorious is he,
        humble and riding on a donkey,
        on a colt, the foal of a donkey. (Zechariah 9.9 NRSV)

Malachi

The final book of the Old Testament, Malachi, also comes from the period after the exile. The temple has been rebuilt, but what concerns Malachi is that the priests are not being faithful in their worship or their teaching. Malachi doesn’t simply want a rebuilt temple, he wants – God wants – a renewed one that shows faithfulness in all aspects of life. The priests could start by being honest with their sacrifices and tithes. But when God truly visits his temple, will they be ready for him?

Two key verses from Malachi, interpreted as messianic prophecies, drive the selection of two readings from this prophet in the lectionary. The first is the promise that the sun of righteousness will rise bringing healing.5 It is a powerfully poetic image, that just as the rising sun spreads it’s light out across the whole horizon, so God’s coming will spread healing over the face of the earth. The second is the promise that the Lord will suddenly come to his temple.6

The book finishes with a prophecy of the final coming of Elijah, before the final return of YHWH to his people in glory and judgment. It is this, I think, which ensured the Christian order of the Old Testament, moving the Prophets to follow the Writings instead of leaving them between Torah and Writings. John the Baptist seems to have portrayed himself in such a way that people might wonder if he was this Elijah-figure. Jesus seems to have affirmed that he was.

It means the Old Testament concludes with the prophecy that God will send Elijah first, before he himself returns. Then the New Testament jumps straight in with the messenger John, coming as Elijah to herald the return of the king.

Notes 

  1. For a little more on Josiah’s reform, see this post on 1 & 2 Kings

  2. Year C, the Third Sunday of Advent. It is also the first reading for the festival of the Visitation of Mary to Elizabeth.

  3. We looked at this time in history (and a little later) when reading the books of Ezra and Nehemiah. It is also the same period as the next book we shall look at: Zechariah.

  4. It is the Old Testament reading for Year A, Proper 9, the 14th Sunday of Ordinary Time. Matthew, famously, interprets it rather woodenly, and seems to describe Jesus sitting on both donkey and colt at the same time.

  5. Year C, the 33rd Sunday in Ordinary Time, or 2nd Sunday before Advent. (Based on differences between the Hebrew tradition and the Greek / Latin one, Malachi has different verse numbering in the ecumenical and Roman Catholic selection, but is the same reading.)

  6. The Feast of the Presentation, Years A, B & C. Malachi 3:1-4 may also be used by Protestants as an alternative reading to Baruch for Year C, Advent 2

Mixed prophets, mixed messages: Jonah, Micah, Nahum and Habakkuk

The previous post covered the first four of the minor prophets; today I look at the middle four: Jonah, Micah, Nahum and Habakkuk. Obadiah, the last of yesterday’s selection, offered the most narrowly tribal take on God’s justice.

Jonah

Today, the author of Jonah gives us a very expansive view of God’s internationalism. Unlike all the other books in this twelve book collection, the writer is not interested in the content of Jonah’s message, but in telling a story about a reluctant prophet.

Jonah and the Big Fish – a painting by Pieter Lastman (via Wikimedia)

Jonah is not easily turned into lectionary material,1 as it is a complete short story, a prophetic parable which really needs to be read as a whole. It is richly comic. God calls, and Jonah runs. God sends him to Nineveh, and he sets off in the opposite direction. God sends a storm over the boat he’s fleeing on, and the pagan sailors try hard to save him at risk to themselves, before throwing him overboard. He ends up being taken via a giant fish’s stomach to the place God wants him to be.

Nineveh is the capital of Israel’s superpower enemy. Even so the story exaggerates its size. It is presented as many times larger than any ancient city could possibly be. Jonah, ever the reluctant prophet, does the minimum he can to be able to comply with God’s mission. He fails to call the people actually to repent, and instead just threatens them with doom.

Despite this uninspiring message, the people repent, and from the king down to the animals the city fasts. God has mercy and forgives them. Jonah throws a tantrum because he’s been made to look stupid. As he feared all along, God has used his prophecy not to doom the Assyrians – Israel’s worst enemy – but to save them. Jonah would have liked a bit more smiting and much less mercy.

This profound comic parable offers a glimpse of what the hymnwriter Fr Faber called in a hymn “the wideness of God’s mercy”. The lesson Jonah the character has to learn, and Jonah the book wants to teach, is caught well in this verse from it.

     For the love of God is broader
     than the measure of our mind;
     and the heart of the Eternal
     is most wonderfully kind.
     But we make his love too narrow
     by false limits of our own;
     and we magnify his strictness
     with a zeal he will not own.
("There’s a wideness in God’s mercy", by F. W. Faber, is in most hymnbooks)

Micah

Micah is a contemporary of Isaiah, concerned about both the northern and southern kingdoms, and having words from God for both. He shares something of Isaiah’s attachment to the importance of Jerusalem, and to the renewal of David’s dynasty. He is also concerned that God’s justice should be seen in every area of life.

One of Isaiah’s more well-known prophecies is also found as one of Micah’s, that “nation will not lift sword against nation”.2 Perhaps it originally circulated anonymously and was better attributed to both prophets than lost altogether. His most famous prophecy is the one that has become part of the Christmas story, that the renewed Davidic line, like the original one, will come from Bethlehem.3 He also provides a verse that has worked its way into many prayers, that the Lord wants his people “to do justice, and to love kindness, and to walk humbly with … God.”4

Nahum

Nahum is another prophet who doesn’t feature in the main Sunday lectionaries. I suspect Jonah (the character) would have loved Nahum because the book rejoices at some much-deserved smiting of the Assyrians. While at one level it is a celebration of the impending downfall of an old and oppressive enemy, expressed in powerful poetry, at another it is a declaration of justice for a city.

The historical Nineveh rather than Jonah’s exaggerated comic one is in view. This Nineveh is never going to repent because of a half-hearted prophet issuing warnings. This city has built its wealth through violence: “a city of bloodshed, utterly deceitful, full of booty” (Nahum 3:1). There is a moral justification for delighting in its downfall: finally the great bully will be done to, just as it has repeatedly done to others.

Habakkuk

Habakkuk begins with a dialogue between the prophet and God. The prophet introduces a note we also find in some Psalms: why does God allow evil and violence, and why is justice delayed? The context appears to be around the time that Babylon defeats Assyria: there will be a kind of justice coming, but if Babylon administers justice to Assyria, the implication is that in turn she will have justice administered to her as well. Curses on the oppressor make up the central section. These work as a prophetic critique of any tyrannical empire.

Habakkuk, however, is reminded that his, and indeed everyone’s, call from God, is to live lives of faithfulness whatever the context. He ends his final poem about God’s judgment with a profound commitment of his own faith. It is, though, an earlier call to faithfulness which forms the climax of the reading from Habakkuk used in the lectionary.5 This reading provides St Paul with one of his key texts: “the righteous shall live by faithfulness” (Hab 2:4).

Notes

  1. Though the Revised Common Lectionary offers a couple of readings from the closing sections of the story, this is one book where the lectionaries do not share a common Sunday reading.

  2. Micah 4:1-3 and Isaiah 2:2-4

  3. As well as most festivals of lessons and carols, Micah 5:2-5 (or 1-4 depending on different Hebrew and Greek verse numbering) is read on Advent 4, Year C.

  4. Micah 6:8. It is used, for example, by Anglicans in one of the main prayers of penitence in Common Worship.

  5. Year C, Proper 22, the 27th Sunday in Ordinary Time. (Habakkuk 1:1-4, 2:1-4 or the shorter Catholic 1:2-3, 2:2-4)

Twelve books, one scroll, mixed messages: the minor prophets (the first four).

The fourth book of prophecy in the Jewish “Latter Prophets” designation (after Isaiah, Jeremiah, and Ezekiel) is a bit of a cheat. It’s actually twelve books, the books designated in Christian classification as Minor Prophets, and in the Jewish scheme as the Book of the Twelve. At some point these books were collected together and written in a single scroll. This is probably known by the time of Ben Sirach at the beginning of the second century BC, when he refers to “the Twelve Prophets” (Sir 49:10).

There are only a small number of readings provided from the minor prophets in the Sunday lectionary – some are more significant than others. I shall take the Goldilocks option: neither treating them as one book (too long for a single blog post) nor twelve (too short for one post each). Instead I shall post three blogs each covering four of these books. That means today’s blog is on Hosea, Joel, Amos and Obadiah.

Hosea

Hosea is broadly a contemporary of Isaiah, but prophesying in the north, Israel proper, rather than in the kingdom of Judah. He is, along with Jeremiah, among the most personal and emotional of the prophets. His prophetic calling seems tied particularly to his experience of marriage. In his relationship with his unfaithful wife, he sees a picture of God’s relationship with faithless Israel. This leads to his attributing a degree of painful emotion to God which is unusually poignantly expressed. The continuous common lectionary includes a couple of readings from Hosea in its selection of the prophets.1 The main reading used in both lectionaries appears in Matthew as one of Jesus’ favourite quotations from his bible: “I desire mercy and not sacrifice”.2

Joel

Again there is only one key reading from Joel used in both lectionaries. This is the call to fast and repent. Joel develops his understanding of the day of the Lord as a day of judgment in the light of the devastation experienced by the land under a plague of locusts. His work is rather hard to place: swarms of locusts are not as easy to date as monarchs and battles. He summons the people to repent so as to avoid the worst of the disaster such a swarm would bring, and to trust God for a future with abundant food in place of the scarcity the locusts leave behind them.

A plague of locusts. (Image courtesy of CSIRO)

The power of his poetry always seems to escape the literal reference and makes the encroaching locusts a powerful metaphor for judgment. Joel’s summons to genuine repentance – “rend your hearts and not your garments” – is used as the first reading on Ash Wednesday. It is not quite the most famous verse from Joel’s central vision: that comes in the note of hope at the end which Peter quotes on the day of Pentecost as a prophecy of the Holy Spirit’s work.3

Amos

Amos presents himself as a very unofficial prophet: his legitimation comes from his call not from any form of institutional accreditation.4 This call provides one of the two readings in both lectionaries. He describes himself as a herdsman and tree-dresser, and he was active in the period before the fall of the northern kingdom of Israel, overlapping with the very beginning of Isaiah’s career in the south. He is perhaps the earliest of the prophets to get a book of his prophecies edited together and they seem to be almost unremittingly gloomy.

There is very little by way of hope in Amos. (It may be a later editor who sticks in the one note of hope in the book.) However, his vision of God’s judgement is extensive, and it is driven by a passion for justice. He details the injustices of the surrounding nations before he comes to Israel. As God’s chosen, surely Israel above all should understand God’s call to practice justice. They should know better, but because they oppress the poor and ignore God as much or more as anyone, they will suffer a sterner judgment. It is the stress on God’s concern for justice that marks the other readings from Amos in the lectionary.5

Obadiah

There are no readings from Obadiah included in the lectionary. It is, after all, only a single chapter long. Obadiah is perhaps the most tribal of the prophets. His primary concern is with the day of the Lord bringing vengeance for Israel over the neighbouring land of Edom.

At the heart of this seems to be anger at the way Edom had tried to take advantage of the Judeans being exiled. The grievances of people who thought of each other as in some sense kin, hurt more than those of complete strangers. Israel and Edom traced their kinship and rivalry all the way back to stories of the tribal twin ancestors Jacob and Esau. The prophet looks forward to God finally giving Israel a victory, after Edom had so completely forgotten the ties of kinship as to gloat over Israel’s defeat and take what spoils they could.

Notes 

  1. The continuous Year C cycle, Propers 12 & 13. There is also a reading from Hosea in Year B in the Roman Catholic Lectionary, on the 8th Sunday of Ordinary Time.

  2. Year A, 10th Sunday in Ordinary Time, Proper 5. The verse is quoted by Jesus in Matthew 9:13, and 12:10.

  3. Joel’s prophecy of young men seeing visions and old men dreaming dreams (2:28) only appears in the lectionary as quoted in Acts. A reading from Joel’s more comforting vision of a land of plenty is also an option for Anglican celebrations of Harvest Thanksgiving.

  4. The story of Amos’ call, verses from chapter 7, is read in Year B, Proper 10, the 15th Sunday in Ordinary Time.

  5. In both lectionaries, Year C, the 25th Sunday in Ordinary Time, Proper 20. The other readings from Amos are either in the continuous lectionary, or fall on Sundays where the lectionaries differ slightly.

Daniel: interpreting divine dreams & God’s graffiti

Daniel, as I have mentioned in a previous post, is not classified among the prophets in the Hebrew Bible, but as one of the rather more miscellaneous “Writings”. The main reason for that is almost certainly because it was written quite late – around the time of the Maccabean revolt1, as an encouragement for those who were being called to give their lives, if necessary, as a faithful witness to their God. 

The writing on the wall at Belshazzar ‘s Feast. See the story in Daniel 5.

The first half of the book deals with previous examples of faith shown by the legendary characters of Daniel and his companions, Hananiah, Azariah and Mishael. The story calls them both by these Jewish names, and their Babylonian names: Daniel is Belteshazzar, and his companions Shadrach, Meshach and Abednego. It seems likely that these stories are already old by the time the author of the book of Daniel selects these characters for as the basis for his purpose of encouraging faithfulness in times of persecution.

These stories also present Daniel as a gifted interpreter of dreams, and remind the reader of some of the stories told about Joseph in Egypt. The second half of the book picks up on this aspect of Daniel’s character, the wise interpreter of mysterious dreams and visions. It presents a series of visions given to Daniel. These offer assurance that behind the ups and down of human history, God is in charge of events. The book “unveils” the meaning of events – from the Greek word for this idea of “unveiling” we get the name apocalyptic which is widely used to describe this sort of literature.

The various nations are characterised as in some sense animal-like. To be in rebellion against God is to be less than human. The figure called to represent Israel, a faithful Israel which will be vindicated by God, is presented by contrast as a human figure. Being truly human, a real child of Adam, involves being faithful to God.

This figure is named as “the son of man”, the truly human one, who Daniel sees coming into the presence of the eternal God, the Ancient of Days. He enters God’s presence to be revealed as God’s chosen and vindicated ruler for all eternity. There are other visions, and these build on earlier language in the prophets, to shape a new literary genre. (This genre will come to include the New Testament Book of Revelation, also called the Apocalypse.)

This vision of the son of man, however, in chapter 7, is the one which has the most impact on Christian understanding of Jesus. Selected verses from it provide the main occurrences of Daniel in the lectionary.2 It is not yet a title, as it will become in later Christian writing. It is a vivid way of stressing the humanity of God’s faithful people, over against the animal nature of those who set themselves against God, and lose touch with what makes people fully human.

The only other section of Daniel used in the lectionary is a brief reading from the beginning of chapter 12, a warning that the end of the present age will be marked by great distress: nonetheless God’s people should trust that he will save them.3 This section also shows, in the developed role given to the archangel Michael as guardian of Israel, how important angels were becoming in this period, and how many people speculated about heavenly actors behind earthly events.

It is never clear in this kind of apocalyptic storyline, just how much of an end is in view, how much this is a metaphor for a world-shaking political realignment, how much it is about a transformation of this world into something new, and how much about “the end of the world as we know it.” What is clear is the summons to live in hope that God will intervene decisively to right wrong, establish justice and vindicate those who have suffered persecution.

Finally, I should note that the book of Daniel went on being edited. The Greek text contains some additional stories missing from the Hebrew version, which are collected together in the Apocrypha in many Bibles, but printed in the appropriate place as part of the main text of Daniel in Roman Catholic ones.

These include two fables, the story of Susanna showcasing Daniel’s role as a wise judge, and another, even more fabulous version of the story of Daniel being thrown into the lion’s den which has the same basic outcome, but is used primarily to mock pagan idol worship. The most significant addition, however, as far as the liturgy goes, is the Song of the Three.4 This poem is placed on the lips of Hananiah, Azariah and Mishael as the words they use to praise God from the middle of the fiery furnace. It was known to older generations of Christians, especially Anglicans who attended Matins, as the Benedicite, a hymn of praise to God. 

Notes

  1. See this post on the books of the Maccabees for more about the revolt.

  2. The Feast of the Transfiguration, Years A, B and C, and Christ the King, Year C occur in both lectionaries. The Revised Common Lectionary also provides it an alternative reading for Ascension Day in all years, and a slightly different selection from Daniel 7 for All Saints in Year C.

  3. Year B, 33rd Sunday in Ordinary Time.

  4. There is also an additional canticle of lament and penitence given to Azariah alone. 

On the impossibility of describing God: the weird of Ezekiel

Ezekiel may be one of the longer books of the bible, but there are comparatively few readings from his prophecies which occur in the lectionary. Those that do tend to reflect the most straightforward aspects of his message. Right from the beginning, however, Ezekiel draws his listeners in to bizarre descriptions of his visions. Perhaps fortunately for readers and preachers, these are omitted from the Sunday cycle of readings.

Ezekiel’s visions – a woodcut by Hans Holbein via Wikimedia Commons

As a priest, he has a particular interest in the Lord’s glorious presence dwelling in the temple. The book begins with visions given to the prophet in Babylon, and part of the burden of Ezekiel’s message is that the Lord’s glory had left the temple in disgust. Much of the first half of the book, despite being set in Babylon, seems to be addressed to the residents of Jerusalem before their exile.

Ezekiel puts a great deal of stress on the transcendence of the God who nonetheless addresses him as “mortal man.”1 Even in his visions of God, he stresses that what he sees is only an approximation of the living and invisible God: he sees “the appearance of the likeness of the glory of the Lord” (Ezekiel 1:28). The combination of detailed description, and the way it is presented as an approximation of what cannot be fully described leads to Ezekiel being a favoured source for mystics, especially some Jewish mystical traditions.

However, the passages used in the lectionary draw on some of Ezekiel’s less visionary prophecies. He characterises Israel as a rebellious people.2 He offers a parable of Israel as a tree showing God as the one who brings the high low, and raises the low up high.3 Most notably he rejects a traditional understanding of law and divine punishment: children will not be punished for the sins of their parents, but parents and children for their own sins. It goes some way to forming the basis from which an understanding of individual personal responsibility can emerge.4 The priest or prophet, however, is responsible for another’s sin if he does not warn the person to repent.5

Ezekiel devotes some attention to the calling of the leaders, the shepherds of Israel, here seemingly including those aristocracy who share the king’s rule. This leads to one of his more famous prophecies, that God will raise up a true shepherd, a new David. As well as providing a related reading for Christ the King,6 this provides the background to John’s presentation of Jesus as the Good Shepherd.

His most famous prophecy, however, comes in chapter 37. This is the vision of the valley of dry bones coming to life as God sends his Spirit upon them. Selected verses from this are used as the first reading for Lent 5 in Year A, when the gospel is the raising of Lazarus. It is one of the key texts that helps develop the language of resurrection that later writers will draw on, although here in Ezekiel it is resurrection as a metaphor of new hope for the nation, rather than about the afterlife for individuals.7

Notes

  1. Literally, “son of man” one of the many times that expression is used, beginning in 2:1 and then very frequently throughout the book. It is not a title, but a reminder of Ezekiel’s identity as human and mortal before the indescribable glory of God.

  2. Ezekiel 2:1-5, the related reading in Year B for Proper 9, the 14th Sunday in Ordinary Time.

  3. Ezekiel 17:22-24, Year B, 11th Sunday in Ordinary Time, Proper 6.

  4. Ezekiel 18:1-4, 25-32 (Ecumenical) or 18:25-28 (Roman Catholic), Year A, Proper 21, 26th Sunday in Ordinary Time.

  5. Ezekiel 33:7-11 (or 7-9) Year A, 23rd Sunday in Ordinary Time, Proper 18

  6. Christ the King, Year A.

  7. The Revised Common Lectionary also includes it as a possible reading during the Easter Vigil, and an alternative reading for Pentecost.

When the call of God is a tale of woe: Jeremiah, Lamentations, and Baruch

 A story circulates about St Teresa of Avila in several versions. The most common is that she is making her way back to her convent in a storm when her horse slips, and deposits her in the mud. In indignant prayer she admonishes God: “If this is how you treat your friends, no wonder you’ve got so few of them.”

Jeremiah would have agreed with the sentiment. He seems to be the prophet who both finds his calling most irresistible, and most uncomfortable and unwanted. He is therefore often miserable about his life trapped between the rock of his vocation, and the hard place of the people who reject it.

Michelangelo’s portrayal of weeping Jeremiah

Whereas there was no real need for the Revised Common Lectionary to include an alternative continuous track from Isaiah since there are so many related readings, it goes to town on Jeremiah. When reading through the prophets in Year C, it tried Isaiah for two brief Sundays before passing quickly to Jeremiah, where (with one addition of a reading from Lamentations) it provides semi-continuous readings for nine Sundays, Propers 16-24. There are a reasonable number of readings in the related track, again too many to deal with each one individually, although nowhere near as many as from Isaiah.

Jeremiah, the book, like most of the prophets, is an edited collection of poems and stories which occurred at different times in the prophet’s working life. Unusually with Jeremiah there is a significant degree of biography as well. In particular Jeremiah sets up a contrast between true prophets (Jeremiah) and false (pretty much everybody else).

Jeremiah’s work has some clear affinities with Deuteronomy, and the religious reform linked to the book of Deuteronomy that was initiated under King Josiah. This placed heavy stress on the worship of YHWH as the one true God, and a renewed call to obey the law given by God. In particular, Jeremiah sees the growing power and aggression of Babylon as an instrument God will use to punish Judah and Jerusalem, as Josiah’s successors fail to live up to his reform, and fall back into polytheistic ways.

This leads to Jeremiah being characterised as a defeatist and a traitor by the court prophets. These royally approved prophets carry on a rather carefully selective version of Isaiah’s belief that God will defend Jerusalem because his temple stands there (Jeremiah 7:1-7). Unfortunately for them, and for the nation, God is trying to say something different to their age through Jeremiah. Having the Jerusalem temple will be no defence for people who worship Baal and Astarte (Ishtar) alongside YHWH. It is there as a promise of an exclusive covenant.

Jeremiah comes to see that a new covenant will be needed, and he particularly stresses the inward aspect of that covenant, and of obedience to God in the heart (Jer 31:23-34).

Perhaps because Jeremiah is too well connected as a member of a priestly family, he is not executed for treason, only imprisoned for his loyalty to God. The powers that be, however, interpret his message, his faithfulness to YHWH, as treason to the nation. He lives and works in turbulent times, where the truth or falsehood of a prophecy can be a capital offence, or the military defeat of a nation. Again and again in the prophets, religion is politics carried out in a divine frame of reference.

When this national drama is overlaid on the psyche of a young man who feels things very deeply, as Jeremiah clearly does, we as readers are drawn into his internal drama, the intense depression into which his calling leads him. He is clearly tempted to despair at times, and only kept going by the overwhelming conviction of his calling, and the company of his friends, and his friend and scribe Baruch.

There is something of a Jeremiah tradition marked by continuing editing until quite a late stage. The book exists in two editions, a long Hebrew Bible version, and a somewhat shorter and differently arranged Greek Bible text.1 This existence of different versions of Jeremiah adds to the sense that, apart from the broad historical context outlined above, the readings selected in the lectionary will be understood as much in relation to the gospel as to their original setting.

The Jeremiah tradition is continued in the book of Lamentations. Because so much of Jeremiah’s prophecy is expressed as lament, it seemed natural to attribute these anonymous poems to Jeremiah, not least because they reflect the destruction of Jerusalem he lived through. Perhaps they should be better known in a world where so many end up fleeing destroyed homes and cities because of the violence of others. Unfortunately, the only widely used verse is quoted as an affirmation without the context of desolation and adversity.2

This is part of the same tendency to suppress lamentation in the modern church’s use of the Old Testament that we also saw with the Psalms. Nonetheless, some of the language of Lamentations does colour the Holy Week liturgy, and there is some sparing use of it in the alternative continuous lectionary.

Finally, we arrive at the apocryphal or deuterocanonical book of Baruch. This represents a fairly late development of the Jeremiah tradition, probably from the last century before the Christian era. It comprises both a book attributed to Baruch, Jeremiah’s scribe, particularly focussed on Jerusalem and its restoration, and a different version of the letter Jeremiah wrote to the exiles.3 The focus on the renewal of Jerusalem means Baruch provides a reading for Advent, a passage that echoes Third Isaiah rather more than Jeremiah,4 and inspired the Advent carol, “People Look East”. It also provides one of the prophetic readings for the Easter Vigil.

Notes

  1. Both versions have been found in Hebrew among the Dead Sea Scrolls.

  2. These are the verses that have inspired more than one hymn or song from Lamentations 3:22-23 “The steadfast love of the Lord never ceases, his mercies never come to an end; they are new every morning; great is your faithfulness.”

  3. Jeremiah’s letter to the exiles is at Jeremiah 29:4-28. The longer letter included as Baruch 6 is completely different and focussed on living among a people who worship idols. In some editions of the Apocrypha, this chapter (still numbered 6) is printed as a separate book, the Letter of Jeremiah.

  4. Advent 2, Year C.

The New Testament’s favourite Hebrew prophet: Isaiah

Of all the prophets, Isaiah is the one most often read in the lectionary. It is also the most quoted book, apart from the Psalms, in the New Testament. Isaiah provides some of the key Old Testament readings for both the Christmas and Easter lectionary cycles, and much of the libretto for Handel’s Messiah.

The book as we have it falls into three main sections. Much of the first section, chapters 1-39, relate to the time when Assyria is the major power in the Middle East. Isaiah’s ministry covers the time of four kings of Judah, and by the end of his prophesying Israel, the northern kingdom has fallen, and Judah, especially the city state of Jerusalem, stands alone.

One of the features which makes Isaiah stand out in his day is the miraculous deliverance of Jerusalem from an Assyrian siege. The section of 2 Kings which includes this story is also repeated as chapters 36-39 of Isaiah. Isaiah emphasises that the Lord has made his home on Mt Zion. If his people trust him, he will defend them. According to the biblical account, the Assyrian King Sennacherib’s army are struck down by God, possibly by a plague. Sennacherib’s own records give no account of why his siege failed, but merely recount an unsuccessful siege of Jerusalem and a substantial financial tribute.1 This failed siege is seen in scripture as a stunning vindication of Isaiah’s prophecy.

A detail of the Assyrian carved record of Sennacherib’s campaign (see note 1)

Perhaps because of this prophetic success, Isaiah’s theology was carried on by one or more disciples, who not only edited his voluminous prophecies, but brought his theology up-to-date for subsequent generations. Most notable among these disciples was the anonymous prophet2 who prepared the people for the end of their exile in Babylon, nearly 200 years later. The section containing his work is the most coherent in the book, consisting of chapters 40-55. It is also the section which is most used in the lectionary.

While this anonymous prophet, sometimes called Isaiah of Babylon, continues the emphasis found in Isaiah of Jerusalem on the importance of that city, he particularly uses the first Isaiah’s way of identifying God as the Holy One of Israel. The most significant sections of his prophecy, however, are what have become known as the Servant Songs, most famously the song of the suffering servant,3 read in the Good Friday Liturgy, and treated from New Testament times on as a prophecy of the crucifixion.

This and the other servant songs have always presented something of a conundrum: whom did Isaiah have in mind? Some have seen the servant as inspired by Jeremiah, others as a self-portrait, and others as at least in part the nation’s calling. Perhaps the prophet is simply offering a vision of the kind of person God wants: what true calling means. It is a vision that Christians see reaching its fulfilment in Jesus of Nazareth in such a way that it is impossible for them to read these texts without hearing the gospel story.

If the first section of Isaiah perhaps has more prophecies focussed on the calling of a true king, and the second on the calling of a true servant, the final section has a significant vision of the promised kingdom, Jerusalem triumphantly restored, where there will be true justice and peace. All these themes occur throughout the book, and help make it feel like a unity, but they can be seen as emphases of their particular sections.

The readings from Isaiah in the lectionary are too numerous to mention. However, their significance will often derive more from relating them to the gospel of the day than from their context in the book of Isaiah. With Isaiah more than any other book of the Old Testament, the Christian theological tradition tends to overpower the historical context. This is especially true in Ordinary Time; let me take two examples to illustrate.

In Year A, Proper 22, the 27th Sunday in Ordinary Time has a reading from Isaiah 5, which portrays God as the owner of a vineyard, a metaphor for his people Israel. The gospel reading has Jesus telling a parable about the owner of a vineyard, and the disrespect its tenants show him. In Year B, on the 24th Sunday in Ordinary Time, Proper 19, an excerpt from one of the servant songs relates to a gospel in which, after Peter confesses Jesus is the Messiah, Jesus tries to teach his disciples that the cross is the way of true service.

Essentially, prophecies from the book of Isaiah, all three sections, do so much to shape the Christian gospels, that now, especially when reading from Isaiah in the liturgy, the gospel inevitably shapes our understanding of what Isaiah is about. There is perhaps no other book of the Old Testament where it is so hard to imagine what Jewish readers hear when they listen to the same text. Whether it is helping us interpret Christmas with “unto us a boy is born”,4 or Good Friday with “he was wounded for our transgressions”,5 Christians read Isaiah as a book about Jesus, almost a fifth gospel.6

Notes

  1. Sennacherib’s monumental inscription is now in the British Museum, it includes a reference to shutting Hezekiah up “like a bird in a cage”. See https://www.britishmuseum.org/research/collection_online/collection_object_details.aspx?objectId=295077&partId=1

  2. Scholars tend to refer to the Isaiah who prophesied in Jerusalem beginning in 740BC as First Isaiah, or occasionally Isaiah of Jerusalem, and to the one who prophesied in Babylon around 540BC as Second Isaiah, or Isaiah of Babylon. For convenience’s sake, rather than because people think they all came from the same author, chapters 56-66, largely coming from the time after the Exile, are sometimes referred to as Third Isaiah.

  3. Isaiah 52:13–53:12 is the Old Testament Reading for Good Friday. The responsorial psalm is Psalm 22. The passion narratives of all four gospels echo phrases from these two readings which underscore their value, and help the early Christians interpret the crucifixion as God’s triumph prepared for by the prophets, rather than a disastrous end to the Jesus movement. An excerpt from the suffering servant passage is also read as the related reading on the 29th Sunday in Ordinary Time, Proper 24, Year B.

  4. Isaiah 9:6

  5. Isaiah 53:5

  6. One scholar in fact titled his book on Isaiah The Fifth Gospel, (John Sawyer – Cambridge University Press, 1996)

Making prophets: the economy of justice

As we turn in this series to the prophets, we also return to some overlap between Jewish and Christian ways of grouping the books of the bible. What Christians call the prophets largely overlaps with the books grouped by Jewish tradition as the latter prophets.

You will recall from the discussion of the historical books that Jewish thought groups Joshua, Judges,1 & 2 Samuel (1 scroll) and 1 & 2 Kings (1 scroll) as the former prophets. There are also four scrolls of the latter prophets: Isaiah, Jeremiah, Ezekiel and the Twelve. The twelve are the so-called minor prophets: those whose books are considerably shorter than the lengthy works of the first three. The Christian bible inserts Daniel between Ezekiel and the minor prophets. 

The prophets’ poetry often drew on imagery from the world they knew, including agriculture

There are also some differences between the faith traditions. Christians, but not Jews, include Daniel among the prophets. Christian tradition also links two books with the prophet Jeremiah and therefore includes them among the prophets: one is the undisputed book of Lamentations, the other the deuterocanonical or apocryphal book of Baruch. Jewish tradition includes Daniel and Lamentations as scripture,1 but not the book of Baruch.

Broadly speaking, each prophetic book is primarily a collection of poetic oracles and judgements, edited together by one or more later collectors of the material. On many occasions the reason for a prophet composing a particular poem or prophecy is obvious; sometimes it seems at best more generic, and at worst obscured by the editor. Despite these difficulties, there is usually a relatively clear core of prophecies making up the main message of each book.

At the heart of the prophetic message is a call to the people of Israel to live as people who indeed have YHWH as their God. That means justice – especially for the poor, and fidelity in worship. Together both reflect a proper dependence on God rather than on either accumulating possessions, or compromising with other nations and their gods. Implementing justice and offering right worship are seen as going hand in hand, rather than presented as alternatives.

One feature of the Christian arrangement of the books (Law, History, Wisdom, Prophecy) is that it emphasises the Old Testament as looking forward to the New. The prophets point to the one who is to come, who will establish God’s justice, and bring in the kingdom. It helps greatly that the last book of the Twelve is Malachi, which ends with what Christian tradition has always read as a prophecy of the coming of John the Baptist: an immediate introduction to the gospel which follows. 

Notes

  1. In the section of the Hebrew Bible called the Writings.

Welcome to Lection and Liturgy

Welcome to Lection and Liturgy. I have backed up to this site a series of posts making a guide to the whole of the Christian Bible, aimed p...

Some frequently read posts