Showing posts with label Apocalyptic. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Apocalyptic. Show all posts

Friday, 1 January 2021

Visions, vindication and victory: the strange world of the Apocalypse

The Revelation to John, also known as the Apocalypse, contains seven letters, which make up the second and third chapters. However, it is not itself a letter, but the only New Testament book which as a whole is in the literary genre of apocalyptic. This is a type of literary description of visions that claim to unveil the meaning of history for those in the know.1 They often contain the metaphor of a journey through heavenly or spiritual realms with a guide. The vision at the heart of the Apocalypse is that the soft power of the Lamb’s self-sacrifice will be triumphant over the hard power of the mighty Roman empire. While readings from this book are used on a number of feast days,1 Revelation also provides the second reading for the Sundays of Easter in Year C. Its celebration of Christ’s triumph draws out a key aspect of the Easter gospel.

Readers are somewhat prone to introducing readings from this book wrongly. It is the Book of Revelation in the singular, not Revelations in the plural. The book itself claims to be the record of a single revelation, handed from God to Jesus and from Jesus via an angel to his servant John. There is only one secret to be unveiled: the triumph of God over evil through the cross of Christ.

Unfortunately, the obscurity and ambiguity of much of the language has made this a happy hunting ground for poets and revolutionaries, for heretics and lunatics alike. The most troubling ambiguity concerns its use of violence. Should we see the way in which the book portrays the “lion of the tribe of Judah” (Rev 5:5) as “a Lamb standing as if it had been slaughtered” (Rev 5:6) as its core, subverting the idea that victory is gained by violence? Or should we be stirred by such visions as that of the Word of God, clothed in a robe dipped in blood, riding on a white horse (Rev 19: 11-13): “From his mouth comes a sharp sword with which to strike down the nations, and he will rule them with a rod of iron; he will tread the wine press of the fury of the wrath of God the Almighty (Rev 19:15).” Christians have taken the book in both ways, and it has stirred both non-violent and violent resistance movements.

The four horsemen, by Viktor Mikhaylovich Vasnetsov. Via Wikimedia Commons.

Perhaps in recognition of its character as a disturbing book, one that nearly didn’t make it into the Bible, as well as one subject to multiple, and sometimes very strange interpretations, the lectionary takes only a select few readings from it.3 These tend to be the more straightforward passages, such as the opening ascription of praise to God, and pictures of worship in the heavenly throne room.4 Other readings come from the majestic closing chapters of the book, and the visions of a new heaven and a new earth, and the final triumph of God.5

There is only one reading from the stranger sections of Revelation used in both lectionaries, for the 15 August, in the Roman calendar the Assumption of Mary, and in the Anglican one a generic feast day of the Blessed Virgin.6 That passage is the sign of a woman in heaven, about to give birth to a child who will rule the nations.7 It is not surprising that traditional interpretation has applied that to Mary. But as in John’s gospel, there is probably more than one meaning. The evangelist never names Mary, but in her appearances at the beginning (John 2:1-11) at Cana, and the end (John 19:26-27) at the cross, she is simply described as Jesus’ mother.

It seems as if the lack of her name in the gospel is because John the evangelist also wants to use her as a symbol for Israel’s faithful remnant, from whom the Messiah came, who first trusted him, and who together with his new community of disciples, make up the church, the people of God. I suggest that something of the same symbolism is going on here in Revelation: the woman robed with the sun is both Mary, the mother of Jesus, but also the representative of the faithful remnant of Israel, on whose side (as in the book of Daniel) the archangel Michael fights the dragon.

That is, of course, why so many people either struggle with or thrill to the strange visions of the Apocalypse. So much of it is ambiguous, playing with multiple meanings. It wants to encourage the church with thoughts of the empire’s ultimate defeat, while encoding that message in sufficiently strange symbols that the Romans will fail to understand how subversive it is.

As readers today I suggest we should take our guide both from the caution with which the church accepted the book as scripture, and the carefully limited use the lectionary makes of it. There will always be those who will be misled into becoming anoraks obsessed with timetabling the end of the world (and inevitably getting it wrong). The Revelation to St John is simply too easy to misinterpret, and the core of our faith is expressed with much greater clarity in other scriptures, to which we should give the larger part of our attention.

Notes

  1. There is discussion of this also in the post on the main Old Testament example, Daniel.

  2. For example, All Saints’ Day, Michaelmas, Christ the King (Year B) and others.

  3. There are a few more in the Revised Common Lectionary than there are in the Roman Catholic one.

  4. Respectively Rev 1:4-8 for Easter 2 (and Christ the King), Rev 5:11-14 for Easter 3, and Rev 7:9-17 (or 7:9,14-17) for Easter 4

  5. Respectively Rev 21:1-6 for Easter 5 (and All Saints’), slightly varying selections in the different lectionaries from Rev 21 and 22 for Easter 6 (either 21:10, 22 – 22:5 or 21:10-14,22-23) and Rev 22:12-14,16-17,20 for Easter 7.

  6. Anglican diversity is such that some will pass the day over in silence, and others will mark it, like their Roman friends, with full panoply, as the Assumption.

  7. The Roman reading is 11:19,12:1-6,10, the Anglican one the slightly longer 11:19–12.6,10.

Tuesday, 29 December 2020

Riddle me this: Jesus as a misunderstood puzzle. Mark’s story

17th century icon of St Mark via Wikimedia Commons

Unlike Matthew’s carefully introduced and triumphantly concluded story, Mark begins fairly abruptly and ends even more suddenly than it begins. That beginning reflects a sense of pace that Mark injects into his gospel; Jesus is constantly on the move, and his mission is presented with a sense of urgency fitting to a figure who is announcing that the kingdom of God has come close.

When I looked at the book of Daniel, I commented that it helped establish a new literary genre. That genre, where the secrets of God’s heavens are revealed in visions so that people know how to live faithfully in the present, is called “apocalyptic”, from the Greek word for uncovering, or unveiling in the sense of revelation. Mark begins and ends Jesus’ story with unveilings.

In the account of his baptism, Jesus sees a vision and hears a voice. He sees the heavens torn apart, and God’s Spirit coming down; he hears a declaration that he is God’s Son. (Mark 1:10-11). This revealed secret will sustain Jesus’ ministry. The attentive listener knows that whatever adversity he faces, God will be with him and working through him. We, as readers of the story, know what many of its participants will struggle to understand.

The second unveiling comes at the moment of Jesus’ death. As Jesus dies Mark declares that the temple curtain is torn in two (Mark 15:38-39). Mark uses the same verb for the tearing open of the heavens at Jesus’ baptism, and the rending of the temple curtain at the time of his death. The direction, from top to bottom, seems to stress that it is God’s work. As God’s response to the death of Jesus, God himself opens up, unveils, the holiest place, the geographical and architectural symbol of the place where his heavenly glory touches the earth. Something of the divine presence, no longer confined to the Jewish temple is then, according to Mark, glimpsed in Jesus by the pagan centurion, who exclaims that “this man was God’s Son!”

Between these two dramatic unveilings of the real secret of the gospel, however, is a story of multiple conflicts and misunderstandings by nearly everyone involved. Because Mark has much less of Jesus’ actual teaching than Matthew and Luke, the miracles and exorcisms stand out more vividly. People come to Jesus because of his reputation as a healer and exorcist; they come because they need something from him, not because of who he is.

A regular feature of Jesus’ exorcisms is that the unclean spirits are the only beings who know who Jesus is, and on a number of occasions Jesus is shown telling them to keep quiet.1 When, halfway through the gospel, Peter finally blurts out his belief that Jesus is the Messiah, he too is told to keep it quiet (Mark 8:29). Mark, largely followed by Matthew and Luke, draws a picture of a Jesus who does not tell people who he is. Instead Jesus is presented as an enigma. He refers to himself typically as “the Son of Man”. This phrase is ambiguous: it can simply mean “someone like me” or even just “I” – rather like the way the Queen says “one”. In some contexts, it clearly hints at the figure described in Daniel’s vision. Most of the time, particularly in his early ministry, Jesus seems to use it as a roundabout and riddling way of referring to himself.

A view has grown up in church circles that Jesus used parables to explain his teaching. Mark’s Jesus in fact says the opposite, quoting from Isaiah:

And Jesus said to the disciples, “To you has been given the secret of the kingdom of God, but for those outside, everything comes in parables; in order that 'they may indeed look, but not perceive, and may indeed listen, but not understand; so that they may not turn again and be forgiven.'” (Mark 4:11-12)

This rather difficult idea needs to be understood in the light of Jesus’s reticence about his identity. If someone does perceive who he is – if someone does respond to the truth in his teaching – it will be because God has drawn that person to Jesus, revealed the meaning of the parable, prompted genuine repentance, or disclosed the secret of Jesus’s identity.

This links to the problems the disciples have in understanding Jesus. From the moment Peter declares he believes Jesus is the Messiah, Jesus starts having to teach them that Messiah doesn’t mean what they think it means. Peter is appalled by Jesus’ first attempt to describe his fate and tries to talk him out of it: Jesus labels this the work of Satan (Mark 8:31-33). The next time Jesus tries to teach them about the way of the cross, the disciples get into an argument about which of them is the greatest (Mark 9:30-37). The third time he prophecies his death, James and John come up asking for the best seats in the kingdom of God. (Mark 10:32-40). There is a lot that God still needs to reveal to them beyond a basic faith that Jesus is the Messiah.

These then, are some of Mark’s key themes: Jesus finds himself at the heart of God’s conflict with evil, casting out unclean spirits and healing the sick. His parables and miracles alike challenge people to ask themselves who he is, but most fail to come up with the right answer. Even his own family, and those he grew up amongst fail to see who he is.2 His own disciples barely understand who he is; they miss the point of his feeding miracles and even after recognizing him as God’s Messiah, they refuse to accept his teaching about what that means.

At the end, Jesus must endure his fate alone: his three closest friends fall asleep while he prays in the garden, Peter denies he knows him, and at the very end of his life, Jesus prays the first verse of a psalm which laments that even God has forsaken him (Psalm 22.1 quoted in Mark 15:33). If it were not for the closing revelation of the unveiled sanctuary and the centurion’s confession, the reader too might wonder whether Jesus is truly God’s agent bringing in God’s kingdom.

The ending of Mark’s gospel seems to fit well with this picture. I noted earlier that Mark ends abruptly. The gospel ends so abruptly at 16:8 that many subsequent readers have wanted to supply an ending. Some have actually done so: there are various endings (or combinations of endings) which have been added to Mark’s gospel in different early manuscripts. The most widely used ending, numbered as verses 9-20, is often supplied in modern Bibles at least as an appendix. The lectionary, however, sticks with the abrupt ending, and only offers an Easter reading of Mark 16:1-8. It ends with Mark’s seeming anti-climax: “[The women] said nothing to anyone, for they were afraid.”

I have talked a lot about Mark’s view of revelation: only God can show people who Jesus really is. Only God can open the meaning of Jesus’ teaching and person for his hearers. The ultimate revelation of Jesus is his risen presence, the entry point that has replaced the temple curtain as the gateway into God’s glory, God’s holy dwelling place. Therefore it seems appropriate that Mark does not show us the risen Jesus. Only the risen Jesus can disclose himself to the listener or reader. We who hear Mark’s account need God to complete the resurrection story for us, by revealing the risen Christ to us in our present and personal experience.

Notes

  1. For example, Mark 1:34; 3:12. Since a German scholar called William Wrede drew attention to what he called the “Messianic Secret”  in 1901, it has become almost a cliché. For the very sceptical Wrede it was invented by Mark to explain away the absence of any clear claim by Jesus to be the Messiah in the Christian oral tradition. However, it fits equally well with a Jesus who has a very different conception of a messianic calling to the prevalent political understandings of his day. Wrede’s book was finally translated into English as “The Messianic Secret” 70 years after its German publication.

  2. See particularly Mark 3:31-35 for the family, and Mark 6:1-6 for his hometown visit

Monday, 28 December 2020

Daniel: interpreting divine dreams & God’s graffiti

Daniel, as I have mentioned in a previous post, is not classified among the prophets in the Hebrew Bible, but as one of the rather more miscellaneous “Writings”. The main reason for that is almost certainly because it was written quite late – around the time of the Maccabean revolt1, as an encouragement for those who were being called to give their lives, if necessary, as a faithful witness to their God. 

The writing on the wall at Belshazzar ‘s Feast. See the story in Daniel 5.

The first half of the book deals with previous examples of faith shown by the legendary characters of Daniel and his companions, Hananiah, Azariah and Mishael. The story calls them both by these Jewish names, and their Babylonian names: Daniel is Belteshazzar, and his companions Shadrach, Meshach and Abednego. It seems likely that these stories are already old by the time the author of the book of Daniel selects these characters for as the basis for his purpose of encouraging faithfulness in times of persecution.

These stories also present Daniel as a gifted interpreter of dreams, and remind the reader of some of the stories told about Joseph in Egypt. The second half of the book picks up on this aspect of Daniel’s character, the wise interpreter of mysterious dreams and visions. It presents a series of visions given to Daniel. These offer assurance that behind the ups and down of human history, God is in charge of events. The book “unveils” the meaning of events – from the Greek word for this idea of “unveiling” we get the name apocalyptic which is widely used to describe this sort of literature.

The various nations are characterised as in some sense animal-like. To be in rebellion against God is to be less than human. The figure called to represent Israel, a faithful Israel which will be vindicated by God, is presented by contrast as a human figure. Being truly human, a real child of Adam, involves being faithful to God.

This figure is named as “the son of man”, the truly human one, who Daniel sees coming into the presence of the eternal God, the Ancient of Days. He enters God’s presence to be revealed as God’s chosen and vindicated ruler for all eternity. There are other visions, and these build on earlier language in the prophets, to shape a new literary genre. (This genre will come to include the New Testament Book of Revelation, also called the Apocalypse.)

This vision of the son of man, however, in chapter 7, is the one which has the most impact on Christian understanding of Jesus. Selected verses from it provide the main occurrences of Daniel in the lectionary.2 It is not yet a title, as it will become in later Christian writing. It is a vivid way of stressing the humanity of God’s faithful people, over against the animal nature of those who set themselves against God, and lose touch with what makes people fully human.

The only other section of Daniel used in the lectionary is a brief reading from the beginning of chapter 12, a warning that the end of the present age will be marked by great distress: nonetheless God’s people should trust that he will save them.3 This section also shows, in the developed role given to the archangel Michael as guardian of Israel, how important angels were becoming in this period, and how many people speculated about heavenly actors behind earthly events.

It is never clear in this kind of apocalyptic storyline, just how much of an end is in view, how much this is a metaphor for a world-shaking political realignment, how much it is about a transformation of this world into something new, and how much about “the end of the world as we know it.” What is clear is the summons to live in hope that God will intervene decisively to right wrong, establish justice and vindicate those who have suffered persecution.

Finally, I should note that the book of Daniel went on being edited. The Greek text contains some additional stories missing from the Hebrew version, which are collected together in the Apocrypha in many Bibles, but printed in the appropriate place as part of the main text of Daniel in Roman Catholic ones.

These include two fables, the story of Susanna showcasing Daniel’s role as a wise judge, and another, even more fabulous version of the story of Daniel being thrown into the lion’s den which has the same basic outcome, but is used primarily to mock pagan idol worship. The most significant addition, however, as far as the liturgy goes, is the Song of the Three.4 This poem is placed on the lips of Hananiah, Azariah and Mishael as the words they use to praise God from the middle of the fiery furnace. It was known to older generations of Christians, especially Anglicans who attended Matins, as the Benedicite, a hymn of praise to God. 

Notes

  1. See this post on the books of the Maccabees for more about the revolt.

  2. The Feast of the Transfiguration, Years A, B and C, and Christ the King, Year C occur in both lectionaries. The Revised Common Lectionary also provides it an alternative reading for Ascension Day in all years, and a slightly different selection from Daniel 7 for All Saints in Year C.

  3. Year B, 33rd Sunday in Ordinary Time.

  4. There is also an additional canticle of lament and penitence given to Azariah alone. 

Welcome to Lection and Liturgy

Welcome to Lection and Liturgy. I have backed up to this site a series of posts making a guide to the whole of the Christian Bible, aimed p...

Some frequently read posts