Showing posts with label Gospel Reading. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Gospel Reading. Show all posts

Tuesday, 29 December 2020

Truth in the dock, the Spirit at the bar: John’s distinctive themes

In the first of these two posts on John’s gospel, I looked at some of the ways he differed from the other gospels. We saw how much he organised his writing around Jewish festivals in Jerusalem, and also took a look at the problems his language created for Christian attitudes to the Jewish people. Today I want to go on to explore, especially, two key themes that are have a significant impact in the life of the church and are well reflected in the lectionary’s choices.

John the Evangelist as represented by François-André Vincent. Via Wikimedia Commons

One is the way John deploys the language of the courtroom. This begins in the prologue, with the description of John as a witness. Normally, a witness, when giving evidence, confesses what they did do or who they are, and denies what they didn’t do, or who they aren’t. The evangelist turns this on its head for emphasis:

This is the testimony given by John when the Jews sent priests and Levites from Jerusalem to ask him, “Who are you?” He confessed and did not deny it, but confessed, “I am not the Messiah.” (John 1:19-20)

What we shouldn’t miss is that this introduces a metaphorical trial context to the whole gospel. The problem is that some Christians have got so used to “testimony”, “confession” and “witness” being used as religious language, that they overlook the legal origins of the language. The question finally posed by Pilate at Jesus’ actual trial – “What is truth?” (John 18:38) – runs through the whole gospel. What is the true meaning of the law? What does true obedience to God look like? What does it mean to give true worship and glory to God? Above all, who is Jesus?

Jesus, in the synoptic tradition, has a very characteristic way of speaking when he wants to ram home his point. Highly unusually he begins his sentences with the words “Amen. I tell you …” English translations hide this, by translating by words like “truly, I tell you …”. John emphasises this unusual way of speaking, by doubling up on it: his Jesus begins solemn declarations of truth “Amen. Amen. I tell you …” In English, John’s use is typically represented by “Very truly, I tell you,” or the older “Verily, verily …”1

Jesus is the truthteller. Anyone who follows him will know the truth of his words, and that he is the one to whom the scriptures point. To follow Jesus is to find the way, the truth and the life they lead to (John 14:6). Truth will set people free. Jesus is true bread and true vine, and will give the not only real meat and drink (John 6:55) but also the Spirit of truth (John 14:17) to those who believe in him. The role of those who receive this Spirit is to be co-witnesses with the Spirit to Jesus (John 15:26-27).

(We should note in passing that “truth” does not correspond very easily with “fact”. The truth is a deeper thing than simple facts. Jesus is neither factually a loaf nor a vine, yet his words, his life, are presented by the evangelist as the true source of nourishment and life.)

The Spirit is another key theme of John’s writing, and again this gospel has a distinctive line of thought. Part of John the Baptist’s evidence about Jesus is the vision he saw at Jesus’ baptism: the Spirit coming down and remaining on Jesus (John 1:32-33). “Remain” is another key word in this evangelist’s vocabulary; often also translated “abide”, it regularly signifies a degree of permanence. It could almost be translated “take up residence”.

There is, from the beginning of the gospel, a degree of identification between Jesus and the Spirit. What Jesus does in the gospel he does as the person in whom God’s Spirit uniquely – without measure (John 3:34) – dwells, so that Jesus’s words are “spirit and life” (John 6:63). So strong does John the Evangelist make this identification that he can even say of the promise of living water that Jesus “said this about the Spirit, which believers in him were to receive; for as yet there was no Spirit, because Jesus was not yet glorified” (John 7:39 – my emphasis).

When we reach the long speeches at the Last Supper, Jesus talks about the coming gift of the Spirit. This Spirit is an Advocate (John 14:16,26; 16:7) – that is, to return to the trial metaphor, a person to help the witness give their true testimony in court. This helper will only come to others when Jesus goes to the Father – that is, in his death and resurrection. So, as Jesus speaks his last words, John says, “he handed over the Spirit” (John 19:30) .

The phrase the gospel uses does double duty. It is a euphemism for death, which is how most translations interpret it, But it is also a theological affirmation about the meaning of Jesus’ death, which is what I want to stress here. The language is also the word used of passing on a tradition: handing on the truth. This last moment of Jesus’ earthly life is then developed in the resurrection appearance to the group of apostles. He greets them with peace, breathes on them (an echo of God breathing into the clay figure of Adam) and says: “Receive the Holy Spirit” (John 20:22).

Jesus is now the giver of the Spirit that was previously presented as his exclusive possession. There is a close identity between the Spirit and Jesus, just as there is between Jesus and the Father. John’s narrative offers a profound resource for the flowering of later Trinitarian theology.

The last aspect of John’s language I shall draw attention to in this post is his vocabulary of “glory”. In daily life, it meant something like reputation and honour. In biblical usage, which John inherits from the Old Testament, it meant something like the indescribable magnificence of God’s presence. John, who loves to layer on multiple meanings in his words, draws on both the secular and the religious significance. In doing so he complements the theme of a trial: the person who is in the right, at the end of a fair trial, should go free with their honour vindicated and their reputation intact. Jesus’ glorification will be the final proof that it is he who is telling the truth about God.

Yet it is also much more than this: Jesus’s glory is intertwined with the Father’s glory. He reveals who God is, and God reveals who he is. To experience the presence of one is to experience the presence of the other. Jesus is how God chooses to be present with his people.

This is more startling when we see that John most specifically refers to the cross as the time when Jesus is glorified. A key point of crucifixion in the Roman world is that it should humiliate and dishonour the one being crucified. John’s insistence that the cross is the moment when Jesus receives ultimate honour and glory from God is a defiant assertion of a theological reality that turns every social convention about honour upside down. The cross becomes the meeting point of heaven and earth, the truest declaration of who God is, and the place where the life-giving presence – the glory – of God is to be found.

Notes

  1. For example, John 3:3,5,11 – the phrase occurs 25 times in the gospel (as counted in a modern critical edition of the text). The phrase is odd in any language, and I suspect we have should have followed the example of the gospel writers and kept Jesus’ idiosyncratic use of “Amen” to begin important sayings in our English translations.

Retelling the Jesus story after long meditation: John’s gospel

I expect this to be the first of two posts on John’s gospel. But anyone coming to this version of the story after reading the other three immediately sees significant differences in both style and content. Short pithy sayings are out, and long meditations are in. There are no exorcism stories from Jesus’s ministry, but the cross is portrayed as a casting out of Satan, described as “the ruler of this world” (John 12:31). Disciples who occur as significant characters in the synoptic gospels, like James and John the sons of Zebedee, don’t get a mention, while others like Philip and Thomas, who only appear as names in the first three gospels, get speaking parts in John.

St John: one of four paintings of the evangelists in Venice’s San Sebastiano church
by Paolo Veronese.
Via Wikimedia Commons.

Tradition has identified John the son of Zebedee with the beloved disciple and the author of the gospel. Most scholars feel there are various problems with that, not least that the character of the disciple whom Jesus loved doesn’t appear in the account of the ministry, but only in the Last Supper discourse. It would also be a strangely arrogant way for a disciple of the servant lord to refer to himself. It may be much easier to see a fan of the apostle John using the phrase. Whatever relationship the gospel as we have it has to the apostle John (and the tradition it does is early and strong) it doesn’t seem to be a straightforward one of authorship.

Rather than organize a whole year around this rather different gospel, the lectionary uses it for the key seasonal times of the year and as a supplement to Mark. The longest supplementary use in ordinary time is the reading of the bread of life discourse over several Sundays in the summer1. This no doubt reflects the origins of the lectionary as a Roman Catholic one intended for the Mass, and the importance of the bread of life discourse for the church’s eucharistic theology.

One key way in which John is different from the other gospels is the more overt and reflective way the writer spells out the meaning of who Jesus is and what he does. Some people have characterized the difference between John and the synoptics as the difference between a painting and photographs. I’m not sure that works: some paintings strive for realism and some photographic work is very symbolic.

I prefer to think of this gospel as a meditation more than a straightforward story. It seems to me that John (to give the author his traditional name) is someone who has meditated very deeply on the stories of Jesus, and then carefully arranged the fruit of those meditations as a connected narrative following the pattern of the gospels he knows. He invites the reader to become a fellow meditator with him, to look out for hidden meanings with him, and delve into the mystery of faith with him. He wants to lift the curtain on the reality of Jesus, and invite the reader to see the truth behind the visible human: real bread, real light, real water, real human, real God.

Another way in which John differs from the synoptics is the amount of time Jesus spends in and around Jerusalem. After the introductory story of the wedding in Cana, only three (or three-and-a-half2) stories take place in Galilee. One is a story of Jesus healing a royal official’s son, the other two take place together, as in Mark and Matthew: the feeding of the five thousand and the walking on the lake. These Galilean stories are when John feels most like the synoptic gospels, although he returns to his own distinctive voice when he develops the bread of life meditation out of the feeding miracle.

However, most of John’s gospel takes place in Judea and Jerusalem. An exception is the conversation with the woman at the well, which takes place in Samaria. Most of Jesus’ visits to Jerusalem are occasioned by liturgical festivals: Passover twice (John 2:13ff; and from John 12 onwards), Tabernacles (John 7), Hanukkah (John 10:22) and one unspecified festival (John 5). This Judean ministry may be part of the explanation for one of the more difficult problems contemporary readers of John have to face. John regularly refers to Jesus’s opponents as “the Jews.”3

The word that comes typically to be translated as Jew originally meant “Judean – a person from Judea” and was an ethnic as much as a religious identity. In part it may be the origins of the Jesus movement as a Galilean peasant movement that lead John to repeatedly characterise the Judean leadership bluntly as “the Jews”. That fits well with the portrayal of Galilee as a safe place for Jesus, and Judea as a hostile one. It does seem to be part of John’s overall picture.

However, it also seems likely that it represents some early Christian experience of not being accepted as loyal Jews by many synagogue congregations. Twice he has some slightly odd references to people who believe in Jesus being likely to be “put out of the synagogue” (John 9.22, 12.42). Most scholars believe this may be a reference from the time John was writing, being put back into his gospel story. If John’s group is being excluded from the worship of Judean groups living among Gentiles, John will effectively reject that Judean identity as well. It seems, however, that his language slips, and “Jews” comes to mean not just Judeans, but ethnic Jews who don’t believe in John’s Messiah Jesus.

John embraces a sectarian identity with some relish: for him the world’s hatred is proof his community is truly following the rejected Jesus. Leaving his own ethnic identity behind is part of that process. It is understandable in its first-century context, but that generalised label “the Jews” has helped fuel far too much hatred and violence against Jewish people down the centuries for us to be comfortable with it. Certainly, Christians should avoid copying this item from John’s vocabulary in our own descriptions of Jesus’ ministry and conflicts with Jewish leaders of his day, even if we still have to read it as the translation which does most justice to the text of John’s gospel. Sometimes, however, I suspect we would do better to gloss it as “the Judeans” or “the Jewish leaders” depending on the context.

In my second post on John, I shall deal with two key themes of the fourth gospel: the question of truth, and the role of the Spirit.

Notes

  1. The whole of John 6 is read over five Sundays: Propers 12 – 16, or the 17th – 21st Sundays in Ordinary Time (Year B)

  2. The half-story is a brief conversation between Jesus and his brothers, when he chooses not to go up to Jerusalem with them, but to wait behind in Galilee, and go up secretly. (John 7:1-7).

  3. John and Matthew are the gospels which are most likely to get accused of anti-Semitism. They can certainly be used to fuel it, and their language can give rise to unhelpful stereotyping in the careless listener or reader. I explored the question of Matthew’s anti-Semitism in this post.

To infinity and beyond! (journeying via Jerusalem) – Luke’s journey structure

In my first post on Luke, I noted how important Jerusalem was for the way he tells his story. The story begins in Jerusalem with Zechariah’s temple service, and ends there too with the disciples in the temple praising God. From the time of the transfiguration, Luke talks of Jesus journeying to Jerusalem, arriving there on that first Palm Sunday. And in his second volume, Luke tells the story of how the good news is carried from Jerusalem at the beginning of the story, to Rome, the heart of the empire, at the end.

The story of the transfiguration (Luke 9:28-36) is a key moment. Unlike the other gospels, Luke provides some content for Jesus’ conversation with Moses and Elijah during the transfiguration. This story in all three synoptic gospels should be read as owing much to the literary genre of apocalyptic: a conversation with heavenly figures that (explicitly only in Luke) reveals the significance of what is happening in history.

While all three synoptic evangelists link the story with Jesus beginning to predict his death, Luke spells out that death as the subject of the conversation: they “were speaking of his departure, which he was about to accomplish at Jerusalem” (Luke 9:31). Luke’s word for “departure” – a perfectly normal meaning of the word – is “exodus”. It is at least possible that he expects his listeners to hear the echo of the historic exodus: Jesus’ death will accomplish some kind of liberation.

Luke appears to write mainly for a Gentile audience, represented by the person to whom he addresses his work, Theophilus (a name meaning “friend of God”). Despite that, he is influenced by ways of thinking we find in Jewish apocalyptic literature, as most of the early Christians are. One particularly striking example, which is often misread, comes when Jesus commissions his disciples to share his work.1

When his disciples return from their preaching mission, seriously impressed with their new ability to cast out demons, Jesus exclaims: “I watched Satan fall from heaven like a flash of lightning” (Luke 10:18) Traditionally, this has been understood as a reference to a “time” before time when some angels fell. Jesus’s vision has been interpreted as a reference to something he saw in his eternal existence as the Son with the Father. However, in Luke’s first century context, we should probably understand it as a heavenly vision Jesus sees as the disciples successfully begin sharing his mission to liberate the world from the power of evil. It is the successful widening of Jesus’s mission that, for Luke, heralds the defeat of Satan.

The cross as God’s triumph over the power of evil is further announced when Jesus’ journey to Jerusalem reaches its climax. Luke’s story of Jesus’ final approach to the city is notable for some of the details he includes. While the other gospels refer to crowds shouting “Hosanna”, Luke specifically attributes the exclamation of praise to “the multitude of disciples”. What they shout appears to be a deliberate echo of the angels’ song at Jesus’s birth:

Blessed is the king who comes in the name of the Lord!
Peace in heaven, and glory in the highest heaven!”
(Luke 19:38)

The birth of the king is a promise of peace on earth, the death of the king (the end the listener knows is coming) will accomplish peace in heaven. If the cross is the moment when Jesus comes into his kingdom,2 the entry to Jerusalem is the beginning of it.

The apocalyptic idea that heavenly events correspond to earthly ones is again present, but this time Luke stands it on its head. What happens in Jerusalem will affect what happens in eternity. The war between good and evil in the heavenly realm will be brought to a triumphant end, and God will indeed be glorified. Satan is indeed fallen from heaven, and the missionary work of the apostles will now, in Luke’s sequel, begin.

Jesus’ earthly ministry ends in a strange victory, as the king returns to the king’s city to enter into his kingdom. The sequel is all about the announcing of that good news: that Jesus has become God’s true anointed king. It is time in Acts to take the good news of that victory out from Jerusalem to the whole world, showing the practical effects worked by the Holy Spirit because of the triumph of the cross.

Notes

  1. Luke 10: 1-20, a slightly shortened version of this is read as Year C, Proper 9, the 14th Sunday in Ordinary Time.

  2. This appears to be the implication of the conversation between Jesus and the so-called penitent thief: The time the bandit refers to as “when you come into your kingdom” is referred to by Jesus as “Today”. (Luke 23:42-43)

When repentance is more God’s work than ours: Luke’s stress on divine mercy

The comedian Emo Philips used to have a great one-liner:

When I was a kid I used to pray every night for a new bicycle. Then I realised that the Lord doesn’t work that way so I stole one and asked Him to forgive me.

St Luke has more about repentance and forgiveness in Jesus’ ministry than the other gospels, and in a way his take on it is as strange as Emo’s. Luke’s Jesus is very much the friend of sinners.

Detail from an icon of St Luke in Great Lavra monastery on Mt Athos; via Wikipedia

It should be said straight away that Judaism was very much in favour of repentance, and was always happy to see sinners engage in it. It’s just that some of those who clashed with Jesus didn’t recognise people’s responses to Jesus as repentance. Repentance was laid out clearly in the law. It involved making sacrifices and reparation, and amendment of life. Partying with Jesus didn’t look much like that kind of serious acknowledgement of sin.

I want to look at three specific examples. The first is the way Luke tells the story of the woman who anoints Jesus’ feet while he is at supper (Luke 7:36-50). The woman is simply described as a sinner in this city. She comes in and begins to wash Jesus’ feet with her tears, dry them with her hair and anoint them with ointment. Simon the Pharisee, Jesus’s host, thinks that, at best, it reveals Jesus’s ignorance of her reputation. Jesus then tells Simon and his guests a story of two debtors, both unable to pay their debts, one debt ten times the size of the other. The very generous creditor lets them both write off their debts.

Jesus then asks Simon which debtor will love the generous creditor more. Simon has no choice but to give the obvious answer: the one who owed the most. Jesus then compares Simon’s lack of hospitality to the woman’s (over-)effusive welcome. He suggests that the great love she is showing him now shows how much God has forgiven her. He finishes by assuring her she is forgiven. The rather subtle point is that to show love for Jesus is in and of itself evidence of forgiveness. Love for Jesus is love for God. Forgiveness by Jesus is forgiveness by God. The system of sacrifice and reparations appears superfluous in Jesus' presence.

The second story is that of Zacchaeus the tax collector (Luke 19:1-10). He is trying to see who Jesus is. Presumably he has heard something about Jesus which includes his unusual tolerance for tax-collectors like Zacchaeus. He then finds Jesus stopping right where he has climbed a tree to be able to see. Jesus not only stops, he invites himself to Zacchaeus’ house for the evening. This act of acceptance prompts Zacchaeus to change his life: he is going to make restitution of any money he has cheated out of others, and give half of his property away to the poor. The forgiveness of God that Jesus mediates creates repentance in Zacchaeus.

The third illustration includes three parables Luke sequences together (Luke 15:1-32). Luke explains that Jesus tells these to justify his keeping company with tax collectors and sinners. The parables are the lost sheep, the lost coin and the lost son. In the first two it’s quite clear that all the emphasis is on the work of the shepherd finding the sheep, and the woman searching for the coin. Yet the joy of the shepherd and the woman are compared to the joy of the angels over a repentant sinner. It sets up the expectation that the searcher contributes more to the making of repentance than the one who is found.

To my mind this introduces an interesting ambiguity to the story of the lost son – or possibly the story of the foolish father. The father waiting daily by the gate, the father who runs down the road to embrace his son before he can get a word out, the father who brushes aside any thought of penance in favour of a celebration –– how like the shepherd and woman is he in doing all the heavy lifting? Does the son want reconciliation, or simply a better situation than the one he currently find himself in? Whichever way we understand it, the emphasis is on the prodigal forgiveness of the father, far more than the change of heart in the son.

While Luke uses the language of repentance, his emphasis is on forgiveness. For Luke, God, and Jesus as his agent are the primary initiators of forgiveness. This theme runs throughout the gospel, and is drawn into the climactic narrative of the crucifixion: Jesus prays for the forgiveness of the soldiers who crucify him, and welcomes the crucified bandit who recognises him as king. The risen Jesus himself summarises the consequences of his passion and resurrection in these terms: “repentance and forgiveness of sins is to be proclaimed in his name to all nations, beginning from Jerusalem” (Luke 24:47).

Repentance is about being found by the searching God. Repentance is created when God embraces the sinner. It is not so much my gateway back to God, as it is the fruit of knowing myself to be found, loved, embraced, and lifted to my feet, by the God who acts in Jesus to do that very thing.

A gospel rich in stories: Luke

If (as I noted yesterday) Mark feels rushed, Luke feels well-paced. Unlike Matthew he does not collect Jesus’ teaching into long sections, but intersperses it with stories. He describes his work as an “orderly account” and implies that he knows of others which aren’t! Perhaps because he is such an accomplished story-teller himself, he makes a point of including more parables than the other gospels, including two which usually number among people’s favourites: the Good Samaritan, and the parable often referred to as the Prodigal Son.

Luke includes quite a wide range of material, and seems to be aiming for a rounded picture. Perhaps sometimes he includes a story because he thinks it’s too good to leave out. But this wealth of Jesus-tradition means that it is sometimes harder to detect his key themes than it is with Matthew and Mark. Because of this wealth of material, I’m going to break this section on Luke into three blog posts, over three days.

Anonymous 18th century Russian icon of St Luke. Via Wikimedia Commons.

There are some characteristic emphases which Luke stresses. These include the importance of stories of women in the gospel, Jesus as someone who regularly gives time to prayer, and the role of the Spirit. Luke seems to offer a very particular take on the concept of repentance, and he stresses the divine initiative more than the human response. He also throws up a number of signals about the future inclusion of the Gentiles in the Jesus movement, beginning with Simeon’s prophecy over the infant Jesus that he will be “a light to lighten the Gentiles” (Luke 2:32).

However, the emphasis that comes closest to being an organising theme is Jesus and Jerusalem. The story begins in Jerusalem with Zechariah’s temple service, and ends there too with the disciples in the temple praising God. From the time of the transfiguration, Luke has Jesus journeying to Jerusalem as a leitmotif, which seems to carry subtle hints of his belonging as king in the royal city.

Most of the familiar Christmas story comes from Luke. Matthew really only contributes the wise men and the massacre of the infants. Luke’s opening chapters on Jesus’ birth deliberately echo the language and stories of the Greek bible. He is signalling to his readers that this is a continuation of the same story. He uses these opening chapters to underline Jesus’ identity and destiny. From the beginning Jesus is the one who will sit on the throne of his ancestor David (Luke 1:32).

Joseph’s lineage as a descendant of David is stressed further in the story of the journey to Bethlehem, and angels announce the birth of a saviour in David’s town (Luke 2:1-7). The language of saviour may pass a modern reader by as a conventional title for Jesus. It was, however, also a title claimed by emperors. When combined with the titles Lord and Christ in the same angelic announcement, it seems that we should see this clearly as a proclamation of royal, even imperial, birth.

The very earliest stages of Jesus’ ministry also hint at both the rejection he will suffer, and the universal scope of the mission that will spring from his ministry. Although Luke refers to Jesus preaching throughout Galilee and gaining a good reputation, he chooses to begin the story of Jesus’s ministry not with one of these, but a story about his relatively unsuccessful return to Nazareth.

Luke shows Jesus reading the scripture in the synagogue1 but then going on to (metaphorically) shake the dust of his hometown off his feet. As he begins his sermon, Jesus emphasises that “no prophet is accepted in the prophet’s hometown” (Luke 4:24). He goes onto remind his listeners that Elijah was sent to a foreign widow rather than helping an Israelite one, and Elisha healed a Syrian leper but not a Jewish one.2 Unsurprisingly they dislike this message, and reject the messenger. Luke seems to have one eye on encouraging churches that may be attacked by fellow Jews for accepting Gentiles. They should know that Jesus too has a similar experience.

In fact, much more than the other gospels, if they do it at all, Luke stresses Jesus as a model for Christians. Even his death is portrayed as a model martyrdom, and in Acts, Luke will show Stephen imitating Jesus. It is part of this idea of the imitation of Jesus, I suspect, that lies behind the stress Luke puts on Jesus at prayer throughout his ministry. If this is how much prayer matters to Jesus, he implies, how much more does it matter for the Christian.

When he edits Mark’s account of Jesus’ baptism, he moves the vision Jesus is given of the Spirit descending like a dove. In Mark it happened while Jesus was coming up out of the water. In Luke it happens immediately afterwards when Jesus was praying (Luke 3:21). The theme of Jesus as a person of prayer continues through the gospel.

Jesus spends a night in prayer before choosing the Twelve (Luke 6:12) He is praying alone before he asks Peter and the others who people think he is (Luke 9:18), and in Luke’s gospel the reason he takes Peter, James and John up the mountain (before the transfiguration) is to pray. (Luke 9:28) Luke keeps this theme going, and it is on one such occasion, when his disciples see him praying, that they ask him to teach them. That is the context for Luke’s Jesus to teach them the Lord’s Prayer (Luke 11:2-4). They want to learn to pray because they see him praying.

In the next post, coming next week, I want to look at how Luke handles one very specific theme: repentance.

Notes

  1. I looked at this story in some detail earlier in this series.

  2. The story about Elijah is in 1 Kings 17, and about Elisha in 2 Kings 5

  3. Luke’s version, perhaps for literary effect, is somewhat briefer than Matthew’s, included in the sermon on the mount. It is Matthew’s version (more or less) that the church uses in liturgical prayer.

Riddle me this: Jesus as a misunderstood puzzle. Mark’s story

17th century icon of St Mark via Wikimedia Commons

Unlike Matthew’s carefully introduced and triumphantly concluded story, Mark begins fairly abruptly and ends even more suddenly than it begins. That beginning reflects a sense of pace that Mark injects into his gospel; Jesus is constantly on the move, and his mission is presented with a sense of urgency fitting to a figure who is announcing that the kingdom of God has come close.

When I looked at the book of Daniel, I commented that it helped establish a new literary genre. That genre, where the secrets of God’s heavens are revealed in visions so that people know how to live faithfully in the present, is called “apocalyptic”, from the Greek word for uncovering, or unveiling in the sense of revelation. Mark begins and ends Jesus’ story with unveilings.

In the account of his baptism, Jesus sees a vision and hears a voice. He sees the heavens torn apart, and God’s Spirit coming down; he hears a declaration that he is God’s Son. (Mark 1:10-11). This revealed secret will sustain Jesus’ ministry. The attentive listener knows that whatever adversity he faces, God will be with him and working through him. We, as readers of the story, know what many of its participants will struggle to understand.

The second unveiling comes at the moment of Jesus’ death. As Jesus dies Mark declares that the temple curtain is torn in two (Mark 15:38-39). Mark uses the same verb for the tearing open of the heavens at Jesus’ baptism, and the rending of the temple curtain at the time of his death. The direction, from top to bottom, seems to stress that it is God’s work. As God’s response to the death of Jesus, God himself opens up, unveils, the holiest place, the geographical and architectural symbol of the place where his heavenly glory touches the earth. Something of the divine presence, no longer confined to the Jewish temple is then, according to Mark, glimpsed in Jesus by the pagan centurion, who exclaims that “this man was God’s Son!”

Between these two dramatic unveilings of the real secret of the gospel, however, is a story of multiple conflicts and misunderstandings by nearly everyone involved. Because Mark has much less of Jesus’ actual teaching than Matthew and Luke, the miracles and exorcisms stand out more vividly. People come to Jesus because of his reputation as a healer and exorcist; they come because they need something from him, not because of who he is.

A regular feature of Jesus’ exorcisms is that the unclean spirits are the only beings who know who Jesus is, and on a number of occasions Jesus is shown telling them to keep quiet.1 When, halfway through the gospel, Peter finally blurts out his belief that Jesus is the Messiah, he too is told to keep it quiet (Mark 8:29). Mark, largely followed by Matthew and Luke, draws a picture of a Jesus who does not tell people who he is. Instead Jesus is presented as an enigma. He refers to himself typically as “the Son of Man”. This phrase is ambiguous: it can simply mean “someone like me” or even just “I” – rather like the way the Queen says “one”. In some contexts, it clearly hints at the figure described in Daniel’s vision. Most of the time, particularly in his early ministry, Jesus seems to use it as a roundabout and riddling way of referring to himself.

A view has grown up in church circles that Jesus used parables to explain his teaching. Mark’s Jesus in fact says the opposite, quoting from Isaiah:

And Jesus said to the disciples, “To you has been given the secret of the kingdom of God, but for those outside, everything comes in parables; in order that 'they may indeed look, but not perceive, and may indeed listen, but not understand; so that they may not turn again and be forgiven.'” (Mark 4:11-12)

This rather difficult idea needs to be understood in the light of Jesus’s reticence about his identity. If someone does perceive who he is – if someone does respond to the truth in his teaching – it will be because God has drawn that person to Jesus, revealed the meaning of the parable, prompted genuine repentance, or disclosed the secret of Jesus’s identity.

This links to the problems the disciples have in understanding Jesus. From the moment Peter declares he believes Jesus is the Messiah, Jesus starts having to teach them that Messiah doesn’t mean what they think it means. Peter is appalled by Jesus’ first attempt to describe his fate and tries to talk him out of it: Jesus labels this the work of Satan (Mark 8:31-33). The next time Jesus tries to teach them about the way of the cross, the disciples get into an argument about which of them is the greatest (Mark 9:30-37). The third time he prophecies his death, James and John come up asking for the best seats in the kingdom of God. (Mark 10:32-40). There is a lot that God still needs to reveal to them beyond a basic faith that Jesus is the Messiah.

These then, are some of Mark’s key themes: Jesus finds himself at the heart of God’s conflict with evil, casting out unclean spirits and healing the sick. His parables and miracles alike challenge people to ask themselves who he is, but most fail to come up with the right answer. Even his own family, and those he grew up amongst fail to see who he is.2 His own disciples barely understand who he is; they miss the point of his feeding miracles and even after recognizing him as God’s Messiah, they refuse to accept his teaching about what that means.

At the end, Jesus must endure his fate alone: his three closest friends fall asleep while he prays in the garden, Peter denies he knows him, and at the very end of his life, Jesus prays the first verse of a psalm which laments that even God has forsaken him (Psalm 22.1 quoted in Mark 15:33). If it were not for the closing revelation of the unveiled sanctuary and the centurion’s confession, the reader too might wonder whether Jesus is truly God’s agent bringing in God’s kingdom.

The ending of Mark’s gospel seems to fit well with this picture. I noted earlier that Mark ends abruptly. The gospel ends so abruptly at 16:8 that many subsequent readers have wanted to supply an ending. Some have actually done so: there are various endings (or combinations of endings) which have been added to Mark’s gospel in different early manuscripts. The most widely used ending, numbered as verses 9-20, is often supplied in modern Bibles at least as an appendix. The lectionary, however, sticks with the abrupt ending, and only offers an Easter reading of Mark 16:1-8. It ends with Mark’s seeming anti-climax: “[The women] said nothing to anyone, for they were afraid.”

I have talked a lot about Mark’s view of revelation: only God can show people who Jesus really is. Only God can open the meaning of Jesus’ teaching and person for his hearers. The ultimate revelation of Jesus is his risen presence, the entry point that has replaced the temple curtain as the gateway into God’s glory, God’s holy dwelling place. Therefore it seems appropriate that Mark does not show us the risen Jesus. Only the risen Jesus can disclose himself to the listener or reader. We who hear Mark’s account need God to complete the resurrection story for us, by revealing the risen Christ to us in our present and personal experience.

Notes

  1. For example, Mark 1:34; 3:12. Since a German scholar called William Wrede drew attention to what he called the “Messianic Secret”  in 1901, it has become almost a cliché. For the very sceptical Wrede it was invented by Mark to explain away the absence of any clear claim by Jesus to be the Messiah in the Christian oral tradition. However, it fits equally well with a Jesus who has a very different conception of a messianic calling to the prevalent political understandings of his day. Wrede’s book was finally translated into English as “The Messianic Secret” 70 years after its German publication.

  2. See particularly Mark 3:31-35 for the family, and Mark 6:1-6 for his hometown visit

Anti-semitic? The Pharisees and the Jewish people in Matthew’s gospel

In yesterday’s post on Matthew, I looked at some of his key themes. Today I want to develop that further, by looking at what seems to be a fairly complicated relationship between what we would nowadays call Christians and Jews. In Matthew’s context, both communities are made up of Jews, one a community that believes in Jesus as the Messiah, and one that doesn’t. Matthew’s group of Jesus-believing Jews may include some non-Jews, but his book seems mainly directed to Jewish believers in Jesus.

Matthew – page from the Lindisfarne Gospels

As he writes, Matthew seems keen to refute any suggestion that Christianity is a more relaxed approach to God’s demands for a holy life. He is quite clear that the new covenant promised by the prophets, and sealed by Jesus’ death and resurrection, is a more perfect way of obedience to God.

In the polemics between Jesus and various Jewish teachers, we probably hear an echo of arguments between Matthew’s church assembly and his local synagogue. In particular, he includes a blistering attack on the scribes and Pharisees as part of the lead-in to the final events of the gospel (Matthew 23). He narrates Jesus’s most serious disagreement with them, where he argues that in practice their way of observing Torah actually misses the point of Torah.

It is difficult for contemporary Christians to know quite how to read some of these attacks, especially now we realise the evil to which Christian anti-Semitism has led. The first point to make is that we are reading stories about inter-Jewish disputes, between the Jewish teacher Jesus of Nazareth, and other Jewish teachers with a different vision. These disputes come to us first preserved in stories retold by Jewish disciples, and then written up by a Jewish evangelist.

The second point is that the communities that repeated and shaped the stories about Jesus were also initially Jewish groups under serious pressure from their fellow Jews to conform to the majority view. They needed to defend themselves and their conviction that Jesus was the promised Messiah, and part of that defence was to show the majority vision was wrong or inadequate.

It also helps if we can break the casual link Christian tradition has made – following Jesus’ accusation – between the words Pharisee and hypocrite. The Pharisees deserve better treatment. One way to look at the historical Pharisees is to see them as a renewal group within Judaism. Like many other Jews, including Jesus, they wanted to see the coming of God’s kingdom. They therefore want to be more thorough in their Torah observance, and extend the piety practiced by priests in the Temple into the everyday life of the laity. They want to take the purity regulations appropriate to temple worship into the home. Then, they hope, God will see a renewed and purified people, and reward them by bringing in his kingdom.

Jesus is equally concerned with the coming of God’s kingdom, but believes the exact opposite. Jesus teaches that the kingdom is already coming with his ministry, and that as it comes it will make the people pure and holy. He therefore mixes with all sorts and conditions of people without enquiring about their state of holiness. The reason the Pharisees and Jesus come together and clash so frequently is they both think the coming kingdom is important, and both think the other are preventing it.

While on the subject of Christian anti-Semitism and Matthew’s gospel, I should also say a word about the most notorious passage in the gospel, read mainly as part of the Passion Gospel.

So when Pilate saw that he could do nothing, but rather that a riot was beginning, he took some water and washed his hands before the crowd, saying, “I am innocent of this man’s blood; see to it yourselves.” Then the people as a whole answered, “His blood be on us and on our children!” So he released Barabbas for them; and after flogging Jesus, he handed him over to be crucified. (Matthew 27:24-26)

Historically, Christians have used this to blame all Jews everywhere for the death of Jesus. This used to be so common a view that the Second Vatican Council found it necessary to rebut it in its declaration on non-Christian religions.1 My own view is that Christian tradition has misread Matthew badly here.

The evangelist shapes his gospel by portraying the ministry of Jesus as being to the Jewish people before his death, and to the whole world after his resurrection. So, while he includes some stories of Jesus interacting with Gentiles,2 what he chooses to emphasise is ministry to the “lost sheep of the house of Israel”, both in Jesus’s own mission (Matthew 15:25) and that of his disciples (Matthew 10:6). The focus changes only after Jesus is raised from the dead, when he sends them to every nation (Matthew 28:19). In his ministry, however, he has come to fulfil the law and the prophets (Matthew 5:17)

It is in this context that we must read this very difficult passage from Matthew’s passion narrative. The prophets have pointed to a new covenant, and at the Last Supper Jesus describes the cup as “the blood of the covenant which is poured out for many for the forgiveness of sins.” (Matthew 26:28). In the making of the first covenant at Mt Sinai, it is ratified by Moses sprinkling the blood of the sacrifices which accompany the covenant over the people (Exodus 24:8).

Matthew believes that to fulfil prophecy (as he understands it) the new covenant must first be ratified with the Jewish people before it can be shared with the Gentiles. Therefore, fully aware of the irony of the statement, he portrays the people accepting the blood of Jesus’ sacrifice upon themselves. The covenant is ratified unwittingly by the people who are rejecting Jesus as Messiah. But now that God’s prophetic promises have been fulfilled, the covenant can finally be shared with the nations.

Of course, it also helps the fledgling Jesus movement take their gospel to the Gentile world, if they can be seen as well to absolve Rome of its responsibility for Jesus’ death. But I read the story as Matthew’s deliberate and ironic ambiguity. It is a key part of his design to show the covenant God makes with his people is no longer exclusive to the Jewish people. It is the climax of his story to show it is now one that spreads beyond a particular people to the whole world.

But for Matthew the new covenant is more like than unlike the first one. Yesterday I noted Matthew’s emphasis on the call to perfection. The Jews at Sinai, after receiving the covenant, had to recognise that it entailed all the words of the commandments. Now those Gentile nations who will receive the new covenant Matthew is describing, will have to obey everything Jesus has commanded (Matthew 28:20). Matthew is written to summon God’s people to be Jesus’s people. They are to seek on earth to live out the life of the kingdom of heaven.

Notes

  1. Nostra Aetate 4: “True, the Jewish authorities and those who followed their lead pressed for the death of Christ;(13) still, what happened in His passion cannot be charged against all the Jews, without distinction, then alive, nor against the Jews of today. Although the Church is the new people of God, the Jews should not be presented as rejected or accursed by God, as if this followed from the Holy Scriptures.”

  2. For example the healing of the centurion’s servant (Matthew 8:5-13).

A well-trained scribe: Matthew and the call to perfection

This will be the first of two posts on Matthew’s gospel. As he tells the story, Matthew showcases both his admiration for, and frustration with, Mark’s version of Jesus’s life. We see his admiration, because he adopts Mark’s basic idea, and often follows him almost word for word. We see his frustration because while Mark describes Jesus as a teacher, he includes very little of Jesus’ teaching. Matthew, by way of contrast, has gathered together a wide range of Jesus’ teaching, which he often presents in extended teaching sessions, beginning with the collection we now know as the sermon on the mount.1

St Matthew and the Angel, attr. Karel van der Pluym (c.1660) via Wikimedia Commons

However, Matthew does not begin there, but with an introduction skipped over by most modern readers, which is also omitted from the lectionary. Matthew begins with that Old Testament standby, a stylised genealogy. Jesus, who do you think you are – a potted family history. This neatly divides Jewish history into three equal periods of fourteen generations, Abraham to David, David to the exile, and the exile to the birth of Jesus. It is not just a royal Davidic pedigree for the Messiah, but a way of emphasising the completeness of God’s plan. Jesus is presented as the fulfilment of Israel’s history. He is David’s true royal heir, but also something more: as the hymn puts it, “great David’s greater son.”2 This is the first of Matthew’s themes to be introduced, and it is picked up in the birth story which follows.

The second of Matthew’s major themes is Jesus as a new Moses. Just as Moses went up the mountain to receive the Law from God, so Jesus goes up a mountain to sit down and give a new interpretation of the Law. This is most obvious in the series of antitheses contained in the sermon on the mount.3 Jesus intensifies some of the ten commandments, correcting Moses’ version of God’s words. The biblical commandment is introduced by a phrase like “You have heard that it was said …”. Jesus takes the commandment and authoritatively improves on it: “… but I say to you … .” It is no longer simply enough to avoid killing or adultery, people must also avoid calling people names and looking lustfully at others.

In Matthew’s gospel, Jesus sets out the standard of perfection which is meant to mark the life of God’s kingdom, beginning with the beatitudes: the blessings which will mark the age to come. Matthew, with a typically Jewish euphemism, wanting to avoid saying “God” too often, usually replaces Mark’s phrase “the kingdom of God” with “the kingdom of heaven”.

There is an implicit contrast in Matthew with the traditional approach to the Torah followed by the early rabbis.4 The rabbis’ practical teaching of Torah is largely concerned with making it observable by ordinary people. Jesus offers a counsel of perfection that goes beyond the humanly achievable (and thereby creating some significant ethical and theological problems for the church later on). At its most extreme it is summed up in the command to “Be perfect, therefore, as your heavenly Father is perfect.” (Matthew 5:48)

Despite this emphasis, Matthew became the favoured gospel in the church, precsiely because he showed more of Jesus legislating for a new community. Once expectations of Jesus’ immediate return died down, the church needed to get organised. Matthew seemed to lend itself to that purpose more than the other gospels.

Let’s take a very specific example: Jesus’s teaching about divorce. This is one of those incidents in the gospels where we see Jesus being invited, as a teacher, to offer his opinion in an area where there was considerable controversy and disagreement between leading schools of thought.5 In Mark’s gospel, Jesus’s answer to the question is presented as an absolute prohibition of divorce.6

Matthew, while largely using Mark’s words and continuing to uphold the ideal, clearly assumes Jesus didn’t mean anything quite as extreme. To him, if not to us, it seemed obvious that Jesus’s prohibition did not include the circumstances where a wife had been unfaithful. “And I say to you, whoever divorces his wife, except for unchastity, and marries another commits adultery” (Matthew 10:9). Even with the get-out clause of “unchastity” the disciples still think this is an impossibly high standard.

The church has argued about what Jesus really meant, and how to apply his teaching to daily life ever since his teaching was first heard. Yet even within the gospel story, we see the church working out how to proclaim and adapt the call to perfection for ordinary human beings living out their faith very imperfectly.

In tomorrow’s post on Matthew, I will look at one of the biggest difficulties in reading Matthew: the complicated relationship his community has with their Jewish neighbours.

Notes

  1. The sermon on the mount is chapters 5–7. The other main teaching sections are chapter 10 (Jesus instructs his disciples on how to be missionaries), chapter 13 (a whole series of parables about the kingdom), chapter 18 (how disciples should behave towards one another) and chapters 24-25 (the future and the last judgement).

  2. The hymn “Hail to the Lord’s anointed” by James Montgomery.

  3. These begin at Matthew 5:21.

  4. Rabbi is an honorific title meaning “my master” which a disciple might use as a sign if respect for their teacher. It seems to have been in use well before there was an identifiable class of people labelled “rabbis”. Exactly when it stopped being simply a polite form of address, and became a classification of a particular group of people – “the rabbis” is rather hard to tell but almost certainly after the time of Jesus. It nonetheless marks a convenient way of referring to early Jewish teachers of Torah.

  5. There was a well-known disagreement on the question of divorce between two leading schools of thought in first-century Palestine: the strict school of Shammai (divorce permissible only for adultery) and the lenient school of Hillel (divorce for almost any reason including a burnt dinner). The story is referred to in the Mishnah (collected teachings and interpreations of Torah published early in the third century AD.)

  6. See Mark 10:9-11. Mark also customises Jesus’ teaching for a Roman audience by interpreting it apply to women divorcing husbands as well. Jewish law did not allow a woman to initiate divorce, Roman law did.

Four portraits, no photo: every gospel tells a story

The order of the biblical books is is not accidental but deliberate. The Old Testament ends with prophecy. The New Testament begins with the gospel that puts the greatest stress on Jesus as the fulfilment of prophecy. This is Matthew’s version of the story of Jesus.

The canonical order is almost certainly not the order in which the gospels were written. In a rare instance of near universal academic agreement, biblical scholars think that this sub-genre of ancient biography was invented by Mark: the first person to write a gospel.

The four evangelists, gospel book cover. Photo © Philip Barrington

There is also universal agreement that the gospels of Matthew, Mark and Luke are in some way interrelated. After that scholars begin to part company. The majority think that one key relationship between the gospels is that Matthew and Luke both adapt Mark in different ways. They tidy up his story (and his grammar!) and supplement it with a range of additional stories they value. There are other theories. However, these three gospels are recognisably not only talking about the same person, but telling similar stories about him.

Because of this similarity these three gospels together are often, for convenience’s sake, called the synoptic gospels. The word synoptic means they can be looked at together with a single eye or glance. By contrast John’s gospel tells the story of Jesus in a very different way. He leaves out most of the stories in the first three (for example, there are no exorcisms), and includes some different stories (for example, the weding at Cana). He also offers his own take on the stories he shares with the others, for example, making the feeding of the five thousand the context of a very long sermon.

In all the gospels, there is – in terms of the conventional approach to biography – a disproportionate amount of space given to the final events of Jesus’ life, and especially his last twenty-four hours. The cross casts a long shadow backwards over the earlier chapters. It is clear from the beginning that this is where the story is going.

The scholar who called Mark’s gospel (and the same applies to the others) “a passion narrative with an extended introduction”1 may have been exaggerating, but he catches something of how important the death and resurrection of Jesus is to the telling of his life. The stories are shaped by the ending, and it is the ending of the story that, for believing writer and listener alike, makes Jesus the teacher they need to follow. It is the ending that makes it “gospel”.

The gospel reading dominates the lectionary,2 and gives the lectionary its three year shape. Each of the synoptic accounts gets a lectionary year to tell the story of Jesus, and John’s gospel is used to supplement them at the main festivals, and also to fill out the lectionary year when Mark, the shortest gospel, is being read. This approach draws on a very old tradition of reading and preaching through one key book of the bible at a time,3 and combines it with the present understanding of the gospels as interrelated but distinctive.

Each gospel writer has their own emphases, and being aware of these can help the reader appreciate how a particular story is being told. The sense that there is one story being told in different ways is reflected in the traditional titles given to each gospel. We read “The gospel according to …”: one gospel, four diverse ways of expressing it. We have different and distinctive versions of the story from particular writers with their own theological beliefs and concerns.

As it stands, the text of each gospel manuscript does not include an author’s name. Whether they were written by the person whose name very quickly became associated with each, or at least had a connection with that person’s work, gives scholars something to write learned articles and books about. For the purposes of this blog series, however, I am simply going to use the received names for the gospel writers without much discussion of exactly what relationship each text has with its traditional author.

Notes

  1. A German scholar called Martin Kähler, in a now out-of-print book published in 1892.

  2. See this post for a longer discussion of how the lectionary is organised.

  3. Many of the early Christian teachers like St Augustine produced major sermon commentaries in this way.

Welcome to Lection and Liturgy

Welcome to Lection and Liturgy. I have backed up to this site a series of posts making a guide to the whole of the Christian Bible, aimed p...

Some frequently read posts