Showing posts with label Matthew. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Matthew. Show all posts

Tuesday, 29 December 2020

Anti-semitic? The Pharisees and the Jewish people in Matthew’s gospel

In yesterday’s post on Matthew, I looked at some of his key themes. Today I want to develop that further, by looking at what seems to be a fairly complicated relationship between what we would nowadays call Christians and Jews. In Matthew’s context, both communities are made up of Jews, one a community that believes in Jesus as the Messiah, and one that doesn’t. Matthew’s group of Jesus-believing Jews may include some non-Jews, but his book seems mainly directed to Jewish believers in Jesus.

Matthew – page from the Lindisfarne Gospels

As he writes, Matthew seems keen to refute any suggestion that Christianity is a more relaxed approach to God’s demands for a holy life. He is quite clear that the new covenant promised by the prophets, and sealed by Jesus’ death and resurrection, is a more perfect way of obedience to God.

In the polemics between Jesus and various Jewish teachers, we probably hear an echo of arguments between Matthew’s church assembly and his local synagogue. In particular, he includes a blistering attack on the scribes and Pharisees as part of the lead-in to the final events of the gospel (Matthew 23). He narrates Jesus’s most serious disagreement with them, where he argues that in practice their way of observing Torah actually misses the point of Torah.

It is difficult for contemporary Christians to know quite how to read some of these attacks, especially now we realise the evil to which Christian anti-Semitism has led. The first point to make is that we are reading stories about inter-Jewish disputes, between the Jewish teacher Jesus of Nazareth, and other Jewish teachers with a different vision. These disputes come to us first preserved in stories retold by Jewish disciples, and then written up by a Jewish evangelist.

The second point is that the communities that repeated and shaped the stories about Jesus were also initially Jewish groups under serious pressure from their fellow Jews to conform to the majority view. They needed to defend themselves and their conviction that Jesus was the promised Messiah, and part of that defence was to show the majority vision was wrong or inadequate.

It also helps if we can break the casual link Christian tradition has made – following Jesus’ accusation – between the words Pharisee and hypocrite. The Pharisees deserve better treatment. One way to look at the historical Pharisees is to see them as a renewal group within Judaism. Like many other Jews, including Jesus, they wanted to see the coming of God’s kingdom. They therefore want to be more thorough in their Torah observance, and extend the piety practiced by priests in the Temple into the everyday life of the laity. They want to take the purity regulations appropriate to temple worship into the home. Then, they hope, God will see a renewed and purified people, and reward them by bringing in his kingdom.

Jesus is equally concerned with the coming of God’s kingdom, but believes the exact opposite. Jesus teaches that the kingdom is already coming with his ministry, and that as it comes it will make the people pure and holy. He therefore mixes with all sorts and conditions of people without enquiring about their state of holiness. The reason the Pharisees and Jesus come together and clash so frequently is they both think the coming kingdom is important, and both think the other are preventing it.

While on the subject of Christian anti-Semitism and Matthew’s gospel, I should also say a word about the most notorious passage in the gospel, read mainly as part of the Passion Gospel.

So when Pilate saw that he could do nothing, but rather that a riot was beginning, he took some water and washed his hands before the crowd, saying, “I am innocent of this man’s blood; see to it yourselves.” Then the people as a whole answered, “His blood be on us and on our children!” So he released Barabbas for them; and after flogging Jesus, he handed him over to be crucified. (Matthew 27:24-26)

Historically, Christians have used this to blame all Jews everywhere for the death of Jesus. This used to be so common a view that the Second Vatican Council found it necessary to rebut it in its declaration on non-Christian religions.1 My own view is that Christian tradition has misread Matthew badly here.

The evangelist shapes his gospel by portraying the ministry of Jesus as being to the Jewish people before his death, and to the whole world after his resurrection. So, while he includes some stories of Jesus interacting with Gentiles,2 what he chooses to emphasise is ministry to the “lost sheep of the house of Israel”, both in Jesus’s own mission (Matthew 15:25) and that of his disciples (Matthew 10:6). The focus changes only after Jesus is raised from the dead, when he sends them to every nation (Matthew 28:19). In his ministry, however, he has come to fulfil the law and the prophets (Matthew 5:17)

It is in this context that we must read this very difficult passage from Matthew’s passion narrative. The prophets have pointed to a new covenant, and at the Last Supper Jesus describes the cup as “the blood of the covenant which is poured out for many for the forgiveness of sins.” (Matthew 26:28). In the making of the first covenant at Mt Sinai, it is ratified by Moses sprinkling the blood of the sacrifices which accompany the covenant over the people (Exodus 24:8).

Matthew believes that to fulfil prophecy (as he understands it) the new covenant must first be ratified with the Jewish people before it can be shared with the Gentiles. Therefore, fully aware of the irony of the statement, he portrays the people accepting the blood of Jesus’ sacrifice upon themselves. The covenant is ratified unwittingly by the people who are rejecting Jesus as Messiah. But now that God’s prophetic promises have been fulfilled, the covenant can finally be shared with the nations.

Of course, it also helps the fledgling Jesus movement take their gospel to the Gentile world, if they can be seen as well to absolve Rome of its responsibility for Jesus’ death. But I read the story as Matthew’s deliberate and ironic ambiguity. It is a key part of his design to show the covenant God makes with his people is no longer exclusive to the Jewish people. It is the climax of his story to show it is now one that spreads beyond a particular people to the whole world.

But for Matthew the new covenant is more like than unlike the first one. Yesterday I noted Matthew’s emphasis on the call to perfection. The Jews at Sinai, after receiving the covenant, had to recognise that it entailed all the words of the commandments. Now those Gentile nations who will receive the new covenant Matthew is describing, will have to obey everything Jesus has commanded (Matthew 28:20). Matthew is written to summon God’s people to be Jesus’s people. They are to seek on earth to live out the life of the kingdom of heaven.

Notes

  1. Nostra Aetate 4: “True, the Jewish authorities and those who followed their lead pressed for the death of Christ;(13) still, what happened in His passion cannot be charged against all the Jews, without distinction, then alive, nor against the Jews of today. Although the Church is the new people of God, the Jews should not be presented as rejected or accursed by God, as if this followed from the Holy Scriptures.”

  2. For example the healing of the centurion’s servant (Matthew 8:5-13).

A well-trained scribe: Matthew and the call to perfection

This will be the first of two posts on Matthew’s gospel. As he tells the story, Matthew showcases both his admiration for, and frustration with, Mark’s version of Jesus’s life. We see his admiration, because he adopts Mark’s basic idea, and often follows him almost word for word. We see his frustration because while Mark describes Jesus as a teacher, he includes very little of Jesus’ teaching. Matthew, by way of contrast, has gathered together a wide range of Jesus’ teaching, which he often presents in extended teaching sessions, beginning with the collection we now know as the sermon on the mount.1

St Matthew and the Angel, attr. Karel van der Pluym (c.1660) via Wikimedia Commons

However, Matthew does not begin there, but with an introduction skipped over by most modern readers, which is also omitted from the lectionary. Matthew begins with that Old Testament standby, a stylised genealogy. Jesus, who do you think you are – a potted family history. This neatly divides Jewish history into three equal periods of fourteen generations, Abraham to David, David to the exile, and the exile to the birth of Jesus. It is not just a royal Davidic pedigree for the Messiah, but a way of emphasising the completeness of God’s plan. Jesus is presented as the fulfilment of Israel’s history. He is David’s true royal heir, but also something more: as the hymn puts it, “great David’s greater son.”2 This is the first of Matthew’s themes to be introduced, and it is picked up in the birth story which follows.

The second of Matthew’s major themes is Jesus as a new Moses. Just as Moses went up the mountain to receive the Law from God, so Jesus goes up a mountain to sit down and give a new interpretation of the Law. This is most obvious in the series of antitheses contained in the sermon on the mount.3 Jesus intensifies some of the ten commandments, correcting Moses’ version of God’s words. The biblical commandment is introduced by a phrase like “You have heard that it was said …”. Jesus takes the commandment and authoritatively improves on it: “… but I say to you … .” It is no longer simply enough to avoid killing or adultery, people must also avoid calling people names and looking lustfully at others.

In Matthew’s gospel, Jesus sets out the standard of perfection which is meant to mark the life of God’s kingdom, beginning with the beatitudes: the blessings which will mark the age to come. Matthew, with a typically Jewish euphemism, wanting to avoid saying “God” too often, usually replaces Mark’s phrase “the kingdom of God” with “the kingdom of heaven”.

There is an implicit contrast in Matthew with the traditional approach to the Torah followed by the early rabbis.4 The rabbis’ practical teaching of Torah is largely concerned with making it observable by ordinary people. Jesus offers a counsel of perfection that goes beyond the humanly achievable (and thereby creating some significant ethical and theological problems for the church later on). At its most extreme it is summed up in the command to “Be perfect, therefore, as your heavenly Father is perfect.” (Matthew 5:48)

Despite this emphasis, Matthew became the favoured gospel in the church, precsiely because he showed more of Jesus legislating for a new community. Once expectations of Jesus’ immediate return died down, the church needed to get organised. Matthew seemed to lend itself to that purpose more than the other gospels.

Let’s take a very specific example: Jesus’s teaching about divorce. This is one of those incidents in the gospels where we see Jesus being invited, as a teacher, to offer his opinion in an area where there was considerable controversy and disagreement between leading schools of thought.5 In Mark’s gospel, Jesus’s answer to the question is presented as an absolute prohibition of divorce.6

Matthew, while largely using Mark’s words and continuing to uphold the ideal, clearly assumes Jesus didn’t mean anything quite as extreme. To him, if not to us, it seemed obvious that Jesus’s prohibition did not include the circumstances where a wife had been unfaithful. “And I say to you, whoever divorces his wife, except for unchastity, and marries another commits adultery” (Matthew 10:9). Even with the get-out clause of “unchastity” the disciples still think this is an impossibly high standard.

The church has argued about what Jesus really meant, and how to apply his teaching to daily life ever since his teaching was first heard. Yet even within the gospel story, we see the church working out how to proclaim and adapt the call to perfection for ordinary human beings living out their faith very imperfectly.

In tomorrow’s post on Matthew, I will look at one of the biggest difficulties in reading Matthew: the complicated relationship his community has with their Jewish neighbours.

Notes

  1. The sermon on the mount is chapters 5–7. The other main teaching sections are chapter 10 (Jesus instructs his disciples on how to be missionaries), chapter 13 (a whole series of parables about the kingdom), chapter 18 (how disciples should behave towards one another) and chapters 24-25 (the future and the last judgement).

  2. The hymn “Hail to the Lord’s anointed” by James Montgomery.

  3. These begin at Matthew 5:21.

  4. Rabbi is an honorific title meaning “my master” which a disciple might use as a sign if respect for their teacher. It seems to have been in use well before there was an identifiable class of people labelled “rabbis”. Exactly when it stopped being simply a polite form of address, and became a classification of a particular group of people – “the rabbis” is rather hard to tell but almost certainly after the time of Jesus. It nonetheless marks a convenient way of referring to early Jewish teachers of Torah.

  5. There was a well-known disagreement on the question of divorce between two leading schools of thought in first-century Palestine: the strict school of Shammai (divorce permissible only for adultery) and the lenient school of Hillel (divorce for almost any reason including a burnt dinner). The story is referred to in the Mishnah (collected teachings and interpreations of Torah published early in the third century AD.)

  6. See Mark 10:9-11. Mark also customises Jesus’ teaching for a Roman audience by interpreting it apply to women divorcing husbands as well. Jewish law did not allow a woman to initiate divorce, Roman law did.

Four portraits, no photo: every gospel tells a story

The order of the biblical books is is not accidental but deliberate. The Old Testament ends with prophecy. The New Testament begins with the gospel that puts the greatest stress on Jesus as the fulfilment of prophecy. This is Matthew’s version of the story of Jesus.

The canonical order is almost certainly not the order in which the gospels were written. In a rare instance of near universal academic agreement, biblical scholars think that this sub-genre of ancient biography was invented by Mark: the first person to write a gospel.

The four evangelists, gospel book cover. Photo © Philip Barrington

There is also universal agreement that the gospels of Matthew, Mark and Luke are in some way interrelated. After that scholars begin to part company. The majority think that one key relationship between the gospels is that Matthew and Luke both adapt Mark in different ways. They tidy up his story (and his grammar!) and supplement it with a range of additional stories they value. There are other theories. However, these three gospels are recognisably not only talking about the same person, but telling similar stories about him.

Because of this similarity these three gospels together are often, for convenience’s sake, called the synoptic gospels. The word synoptic means they can be looked at together with a single eye or glance. By contrast John’s gospel tells the story of Jesus in a very different way. He leaves out most of the stories in the first three (for example, there are no exorcisms), and includes some different stories (for example, the weding at Cana). He also offers his own take on the stories he shares with the others, for example, making the feeding of the five thousand the context of a very long sermon.

In all the gospels, there is – in terms of the conventional approach to biography – a disproportionate amount of space given to the final events of Jesus’ life, and especially his last twenty-four hours. The cross casts a long shadow backwards over the earlier chapters. It is clear from the beginning that this is where the story is going.

The scholar who called Mark’s gospel (and the same applies to the others) “a passion narrative with an extended introduction”1 may have been exaggerating, but he catches something of how important the death and resurrection of Jesus is to the telling of his life. The stories are shaped by the ending, and it is the ending of the story that, for believing writer and listener alike, makes Jesus the teacher they need to follow. It is the ending that makes it “gospel”.

The gospel reading dominates the lectionary,2 and gives the lectionary its three year shape. Each of the synoptic accounts gets a lectionary year to tell the story of Jesus, and John’s gospel is used to supplement them at the main festivals, and also to fill out the lectionary year when Mark, the shortest gospel, is being read. This approach draws on a very old tradition of reading and preaching through one key book of the bible at a time,3 and combines it with the present understanding of the gospels as interrelated but distinctive.

Each gospel writer has their own emphases, and being aware of these can help the reader appreciate how a particular story is being told. The sense that there is one story being told in different ways is reflected in the traditional titles given to each gospel. We read “The gospel according to …”: one gospel, four diverse ways of expressing it. We have different and distinctive versions of the story from particular writers with their own theological beliefs and concerns.

As it stands, the text of each gospel manuscript does not include an author’s name. Whether they were written by the person whose name very quickly became associated with each, or at least had a connection with that person’s work, gives scholars something to write learned articles and books about. For the purposes of this blog series, however, I am simply going to use the received names for the gospel writers without much discussion of exactly what relationship each text has with its traditional author.

Notes

  1. A German scholar called Martin Kähler, in a now out-of-print book published in 1892.

  2. See this post for a longer discussion of how the lectionary is organised.

  3. Many of the early Christian teachers like St Augustine produced major sermon commentaries in this way.

Welcome to Lection and Liturgy

Welcome to Lection and Liturgy. I have backed up to this site a series of posts making a guide to the whole of the Christian Bible, aimed p...

Some frequently read posts