Showing posts with label Two Ways. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Two Ways. Show all posts

Sunday, 27 December 2020

Too many cooks make light work – Proverbs

All cultures have proverbs. They often contradict each other, like the two I’ve jumbled up in the title of this post. Too many cooks spoil the broth; many hands make light work. Part of the wisdom of using proverbs is working out what the appropriate saying for any particular situation is. The biblical book of Proverbs contain a number that fall into the same category as our English proverbs. However, it also contains some more extended reflections on the nature of wisdom, which work rather better as readings.

While the continuous alternative lectionary provides a few readings from Proverbs, the main related provision offers only two for Sundays. These passages come from one of those extended reflections. This one concerns the personified figure of wisdom, and it provides a key text for the development of Christian thinking about God as Trinity.1

 

Wisdom is portrayed as an instrument of creation –Image courtesy of Nasa

There are two themes about wisdom which are picked up in the writings of the early church. One is of a companion with or through whom God creates. The other is as the provider of the food with which God nourishes his people. This is not understood as another God, but as a way of talking about the importance of God’s wisdom to both his work of creation, and to his provision for people who live the light of that wisdom.

It was fairly common to present ethics as two ways of life and death.2 In the wisdom tradition these ways are personified as Lady Wisdom and Lady Folly. Sometimes, the opposite of Lady Wisdom is portrayed as a temptress, a good-time girl who wants nothing better than to persuade the young man to stray from the path of wisdom in her direction. For some people, the idea that instruction in wisdom is given by an older man to a younger man, while women are either the ideal to be sought, or temptresses to be avoided, creates some fairly obvious problems for reader and interpreter. Others find much that is positive in the association of God’s own wisdom being portrayed as feminine.

The figure of wisdom, presented as a woman companion of God,3 is the beginning of God’s creative activity. She is also portrayed as the one who prepares a free meal of bread and wine to attract those who might otherwise miss the point of wisdom. It is a nicely subversive picture to have God’s wisdom and rationality portrayed as female, when so much of history has identified such characteristics as masculine. Rationality, Proverbs seems to suggest, belongs to God’s feminine side.

The attraction of this passage to the early church should be clear: a first-begotten companion of God who offers people bread and wine as the food of wisdom. Lady Wisdom becomes a type for how the church would think about Jesus. She is the outline black and white sketch. He is the technicolour reality. It is for this reason these high points of Proverbs make it into the lectionary.

The rest of the book is more varied: the early sections are poetry that lead up to these key chapters, the later sections more conventionally proverbial. Like our proverbs, you wouldn’t want to read many of them together in a row. They are a repository of ideas out of which a wise person might select the right guidance for the occasion. 

Notes

  1. The first consists of selected verses from Proverbs 8. It is used as a reading at the Easter Vigil, and on the Feast of the Most Holy Trinity, Year C, and Anglicans also use it for the 2nd Sunday before Lent. The second is what follows on in Proverbs 9, the invitation to eat at wisdom’s table: it relates to a gospel on Jesus as the bread of life (Year B, 20th Sunday in Ordinary Time, Proper 15).

  2. See the post on Deuteronomy for more on this theme.

  3. This is no doubt helped along by the fact that the Hebrew and Greek words for wisdom are feminine nouns.

Friday, 11 December 2020

Hey, say it again, Moses – the book of Deuteronomy

The name Deuteronomy in Greek means second law: it catches something about the nature of the book. It is a retelling of the story of the previous three books, Exodus through to Numbers. It is, in that sense, a republication of the law – a second edition. It takes the stylised form of a very long farewell address by Moses at the end of his life, looking forward to what he will not see: the final entry of the people into the promised land.

It serves also as a pivot in the Bible, looking back to the other books of the law, and forward to the history which will follow, Joshua through to Second Kings. That history has clearly been edited by someone (or some people) who wanted to draw attention to some of the themes of Deuteronomy. Key to those themes is a presentation of two ways: a way of life and a way of death. The idea of constructing moral instruction around two ways is a common theme of the ancient world.

Two ways: “I have set before you today life and prosperity, death and adversity” Deut 30:15

For the writers and editors of Deuteronomy and the history which follows, the covenant with God provides the way of life. Turning from the covenant, disobeying God’s law, and worshipping other deities, these things make up the way of death. Meditating on the law is a key means of holding to the way of life. This is made clear by the most repeated text in Jewish tradition, which Jesus also cites as the first commandment.

Hear, O Israel: The Lord is our God, the Lord alone. You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your might. Keep these words that I am commanding you today in your heart. Recite them to your children and talk about them when you are at home and when you are away, when you lie down and when you rise. (Deuteronomy 6:4-7 NRSV)

Deuteronomy has a rather straightforward, even simplistic view of the life of faith. Obey God, and you will prosper: your crops will grow, your children will multiply, your riches will increase. Forget God, and what you owe to his grace, and it will all go horribly wrong. It, and the history that follows, are first and foremost written to explain why it did all, indeed, go horribly wrong.

The book as we have it now, and the history which follows, are shaped by the experience of the disaster we know as the exile, although there was almost certainly an edition that existed beforehand. This period, about which we shall think some more on other occasions, saw the destruction of Jerusalem by the Babylonian Empire, and at least the leading families, aristocracy, priesthood and intelligentsia, uprooted and taken into exile in Babylon. In other words, rather than focussing primarily on prosperity, it is concerned to explain this disaster, and why it is not about God’s weakness. On the contrary it is God’s strength that he judges the immorality and faithlessness of the nation. Exile is the consequence of God keeping his word and bringing disaster on those who broke theirs.

The readings which are used in the lectionary are some of the key places where these themes are affirmed. The whole book is a summons to obedience and faithfulness, to walk in the paths that lead to life. It was particularly popular in the time of Jesus: it is, for example, the third most quoted book in the New Testament (after Psalms and Isaiah). Psalms and Deuteronomy are also the most common books in the Dead Sea Scrolls collection from Qumran.

The message of Deuteronomy’s two ways continues on into early Christianity. The earliest Christian book we have outside the Bible (and almost certainly written earlier than some of the books in it) begins like this:

There are two ways, one of life and one of death, and there is a great difference between these two ways. Now this is the way of life: First, you shall love God, who made you. Second you shall love your neighbour as yourself; but whatever you do not wish to happen to you, do not do to another.1

This central message of Deuteronomy, transposed into a Christian key, became a fundamental staple of the early church’s essential teaching about behaviour. Choose life!

Notes

  1. Didache 1:1-3, cited from Michael W. Holmes The Apostolic Fathers (3rd edition) Baker Academic: Grand Rapids, Michigan, 2007.
    This book, the Didache (a Greek word meaning teaching) is subtitled “The teaching of the Lord to the Gentiles by the twelve apostles”. Its combination of scripture, Jewish tradition and Jesus’ teaching is obvious from this beginning. It could have been written anytime between about AD 50 and 150, although most people think it belongs in the first century. Its Christian content sounds quite like that in St Matthew’s gospel.

Welcome to Lection and Liturgy

Welcome to Lection and Liturgy. I have backed up to this site a series of posts making a guide to the whole of the Christian Bible, aimed p...

Some frequently read posts