Showing posts with label Kings. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Kings. Show all posts

Saturday, 26 December 2020

From triumph to disaster: First & Second Kings

As with the books of Samuel, there are rather more excerpts from Kings in the continuous ecumenical lectionary, than there are in the related set of Old Testament readings. This additional set brings a semi-continuous reading of the stories of Elijah and Elisha, two prophets fabled for their interventions in politics and the miracles they worked as proofs that God favoured them.1

The books of Kings take the story of Israel’s monarchy from the death of David to the deportations to Babylon that marked the end of the kingdom of Judah, and the beginning of the Exile.2 A significant amount of time is devoted to David’s son, Solomon, and particularly his building of the temple. The writer enjoys offering lavish and detailed descriptions of its construction, and he will end his story with its dismantling and the despoiling of its sanctuary.

(At the start of the books of Kings3 the kingdom of Israel is portrayed as at its greatest extent (one still longed for by settlers and ultra-Orthodox Jews seeking to redraw the map of the Middle East). At the end of them, it is brought to ruin. They start with the high point of the monarchy, they finish with the end of the monarchy.)

Rubens’ picture of the Judgement of Solomon – this story is told as an example of Solomon’s wisdom
in 1 Kings 3:16-28. Although Solomon’s prayer for wisdom, appears in the lectionary in Year A as Proper 12, 17th Sunday in Ordinary Time, this story showing the prayer was answered, does not.
Picture from Wikimedia Commons.

It is probably because of the temple that the writer, with his descriptions of Solomon’s wealth and wisdom, lets him off rather lightly compared to other kings. He sounds almost regretful when he mentions Solomon’s many hundreds of wives and concubines, allowed to practice their own pagan religions, and eventually swaying Solomon to join them in the worship of other gods and goddesses.

Solomon’s departure from an obedient faith in YHWH alone, the faith of his father David, leads to the break-up of his kingdom after his death. In this division of the land, the northern kingdom becomes known as Israel, with its capital city in Samaria. The much smaller southern kingdom of Judah remains focussed on Jerusalem. From this point on the writer of Kings will tell the story of both kingdoms as they intertwine, until he comes to Ahab, king of Israel.

With Ahab, he interrupts a barebones narrative of succession to tell a significant series of stories about Elijah, Ahab’s nemesis. Ahab represents a pragmatic and polytheistic politics emphasising the common Canaanite religion. Elijah stands for an uncompromising allegiance to the worship of YHWH alone. The conflict between the two characters and their viewpoints takes up the last third of the first book of Kings.

The second book begins with an ascension narrative for Elijah, a legendary finale for a legendary character, in which his power passes to his disciple Elisha. Elijah passes into heaven and Jewish mythology. He will become in due time a figure who is expected as the forerunner of a Messiah, the harbinger of a golden age. This hope appears in some of the gospel dialogues about John the Baptist and Jesus, and to this day in orthodox Jewish tradition many believe Elijah visits every circumcision ceremony and every Passover meal.

The early chapters of second Kings tell various stories about Elisha and his engagement with the politics of Israel, the northern kingdom, following his master Elijah. Generally these are less confrontational than the Elijah stories and Elisha rather fades out of the story as the narrator returns to describing the reign of various kings of both northern and southern kingdoms, and the eventual fall of Samaria (in 721 BC) and Jerusalem (in 597 BC). None of these later stories appear in the lectionary, despite the overlap with the lectionary’s most popular prophet, Isaiah.4

Isaiah is active in the southern kingdom at the time the north falls. A key story where God preserves Jerusalem and the southern kingdom of Judah when the northern kingdom of Israel falls to Assyria, is found in both 2 Kings and Isaiah.5 It is also one of those rare occasions when there is a reference to the same event in a secular source. The Assyrian record mentions the siege of Jerusalem, but it is not listed as one of the cities captured by their army.6

From the fall of the north, to the end of the book, 2 Kings continues the story of the southern kingdom of Judah, and its kings. The high point for the storyteller / editor is the reign of King Josiah. Josiah is associated with reforms of Israelite religion which look awfully like the ideals promoted in the book of Deuteronomy: one God, no idols, one central sanctuary under the king’s eye, no local syncretism in the rural hinterlands.

Josiah’s program of YHWH alone leaves the marks of its success on the archeological record. Yet he was able to achieve it because the Assyrian empire was failing and he had political room to manoeuvre. The growing rise of Babylonian power soon put an end to that, and his successors turned away from his reforms to the politics of compromise and pragmatism accompanied to some degree by the return of other cults and gods. It was to no avail: the kingdom fell to Babylon, the leadership was deported to Babylon, and the Exile away from YHWH’s land began.

The faith, however, which had been renewed under Josiah, stirred by the prophets, and treasured in the holy book club of Deuteronomy fans, found a new and fertile soil in Babylon, from which it would emerge with a new appreciation that the God of Israel was not tied to one land, but was with his people still: YHWH was the creator, the God of all the earth.

Notes

  1. The readings of the Elijah-Elisha cycle are part of Propers 4-9 in Year C’s continuous lectionary.

  2. The Exile is explained in this post.

  3. Remember that in Jewish tradition, 1 & 2 Kings are treated as a single scroll or book, one of the four Former Prophets (see the link in note 2).

  4. Isaiah was clearly an important book in Jesus’ day. Multiple copies of it were found among the Dead Sea Scrolls, and it is quoted very frequently in the New Testament – more than any other Old Testament book except the Psalms. It is unsurprising that it is also used more in the lectionary than any other Old Testament book apart from Psalms.

  5. 2 Kings 18:13 – 20:19 is for the most part identical to Isaiah 36:1 – 39:8

  6. If you want to know more about the details from Sennacherib’s (the Assyrian king’s) records, then this Wikipedia article is a good starting point.

The problems of power: First and Second Samuel

There are a few carefully selected stories from the two books of Samuel which occur in the lectionary. There is a larger number in those churches which use the continuous Old Testament lectionary. This wider selection is not surprising, as these books tell the story, often quite critically, of the establishment of the Israelite monarchy. They also present a warts-and-all picture of the man who would come to be revered as the ideal king, David of Bethlehem.

King David Playing the Harp (detail), Gerard van Honthorst, 1622, via Wikimedia Commons

The book begins with the story of Samuel’s birth to Hannah and Elkanah, though Hannah, desperate to conceive, is the main character. Her story, and that of the eventual birth of her son as an answer to prayer, is echoed by Luke when he comes to tell the story of Mary and Elizabeth at the beginning of the gospel. Hannah gives her miracle baby, Samuel, back to God and he is brought up in the sanctuary at Shiloh. He grows up to become a prophet ruling Israel after the fashion of the judges (see this post), through charismatic authority.

The Israelites remain impressed by Samuel, but have no confidence in his sons. They become convinced that their fortunes in the face of Philistine hostility will only improve if they adopt the idea of monarchy, and so they ask Samuel for a king. This is seen as a rejection of God’s direct rule, and Samuel tells the people that kings are basically corrupted by their power, but if they want an autocrat they will have to live with the demands of one for their taxes and indentured service.

The first king (and in these early stages “king” means little more than war leader) chosen is Saul. Initially portrayed favourably, he is then presented as descending into madness, exacerbated by his jealousy of the up-and-coming David. Behind the scenes (we as readers know this, Saul as a character does not) God has decided David should inherit Saul’s kingdom, and Saul is unfit to lead.

Eventually David becomes king, but he remains troubled by war and conflict, including civil war with his own son. He is pictured as both fervent for God, and corrupted by the power he has. One particularly powerful story illustrating this is included in the lectionary.1

David desires Bathsheba, whom he has seen from his palace taking a rooftop bath. Bathsheba, however, is the wife of Uriah the Hittite. Eventually, David arranges to have Uriah placed in the most dangerous part of the battle, and Uriah is killed. David thinks he has got away with it, until he is confronted by Nathan the prophet, who strips away the pretence. David confesses, and is both punished and pardoned by God. Later, Psalm 51 would get associated with this story, as David’s psalm of penitence.2

David may be the hero, but he is shown to be deeply flawed and corrupted by his power. What saves him is his willingness to acknowledge this and repent. Yet in the story of Nathan confronting him, we see what becomes a key pattern for later prophets and for the church in its turn. There is nowhere in scripture a divide between religion and politics. Speaking truth to power is an essential calling of those who are called to be God’s ministers.

In making David a model king, later Jewish and Christian storytelling rather airbrushed some of the complexities of David aside. Yet acknowledging that people, politics, and the exercise of power are always complex is an important part of making good decisions. At its best the story in the books of Samuel, blending various traditions about David together into a not-quite-seamless whole, keeps David’s imperfections in view, and makes it clear that even absolute monarchs are accountable for their actions.

Notes

  1. Year C, 11th Sunday in Ordinary Time

  2. The heading to Psalm 51 says: “A Psalm of David, when the prophet Nathan came to him, after he had gone in to Bathsheba.” No-one quite knows how to interpret these headings. Is it a claim David wrote it, or the name of a collection? The closing verses seem to suggest it belongs in the time of Exile. Is “Psalm of David” a reference to a collection – a hymn book if you like? Or, rather like our own use of responsorial psalms, is it a suggestion that this psalm should be sung as a response to the story of David, Nathan and Bathsheba?

Welcome to Lection and Liturgy

Welcome to Lection and Liturgy. I have backed up to this site a series of posts making a guide to the whole of the Christian Bible, aimed p...

Some frequently read posts