Showing posts with label Easter. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Easter. Show all posts

Tuesday, 29 December 2020

We are an Easter people: the Acts of the Apostles

Triptych of Pentecost by the Florentine artist Orcagna (Andrea di Cione). Via Wikimedia Commons.
As in most early representations, the Mother of the Lord is central.

As I turn to a book that is unique in the New Testament, the Acts of the Apostles, I note that the lectionary uses it in a unique way. The church reads the stories of the earliest churches during the Sundays of Easter in place of a reading from the Old Testament. My title reflects that: it comes from a saying frequently attributed to St Augustine “We are an Easter people, and ‘Alleluia!’ is our song.”1

The Acts of the Apostles stands in a genre of its own among canonical literature, though writing legendary “Acts of …” various apostles became something of a literary pastime among the early Christians. It clearly shares a great many of the themes of Luke’s Gospel, to which it forms the sequel. If Luke’s gospel was largely the story of Jesus’ journey to Jerusalem, the Acts of the Apostles is the story of how Jesus’s word makes the journey from Jerusalem to Rome.

When the church reads the stories of the earliest churches during the Sundays of Easter as the first reading in place of one from the Old Testament, it makes two affirmations. The first is about the nature of Acts. Luke relates that in his first volume he wrote about “all that Jesus began to do and to teach, until the day he was taken up into heaven” (Acts 1:1-2 NIV). The clear implication is that this second volume is about the things Jesus continues to do and to teach. The life of the church is the work of the risen Jesus. Acts in that sense is all about the resurrection, which makes it a very appropriate book for the fifty days of Easter.

The second affirmation comes from the way it replaces the normal use of the Old Testament. Easter is interpreted as the new covenant season, beginning with the celebration of a Christian Passover deliverance, culminating in a Christian Pentecost when the Spirit is given.2 No-one knows for sure whether the tradition associating the giving of the Law with the Jewish harvest feast of Shavuot3 goes back to the time of Jesus. If it does, then Luke may be writing a rather polemical narrative contrasting the Spirit and the Law in his Pentecost story.

After Pentecost, the story moves outward. Up to chapter 12 it is primarily Peter’s story; sometimes he is accompanied by John. From chapter 13 it is primarily Paul’s story. However, Luke begins Paul’s story in the first section, and finishes Peter’s in the second, weaving them into a coherent whole. The focus of the story, and the reason the narrative passes to Paul, is that it fits better with the picture Luke wishes to convey, of the gospel going out further and further from Jerusalem until it reaches Rome. Whatever claims Paul makes for his agreement4 that the Gentile mission was his particular responsibility, Luke portrays it as God’s calling through Peter as well.

This outward move by the word of God into all the world5 is emphasised in the twin stories of Peter and Paul. Each has a defining vision; each vision is recounted three times. Paul’s experience on the road to Damascus is narrated as it happens (9:1-19), and then again in speeches by Paul to the mob in Jerusalem who’ve been trying to beat him up (22:1-21), and to King Agrippa II in Caesarea (Acts 26:1-23).

Peter’s vision is a more of a nightmare, a command to kill and eat a diverse range of species, clean and unclean alike. With the help of the Spirit, Peter interprets this as a parable: the good news of Jesus is for all races, starting with the people who have just arrived at his door. This is told in narrative sequence as it happened (Acts 10:1-48). Peter then has to repeat it almost immediately afterwards – to justify it to the indignant Jewish Christians of Jerusalem. They think it is such an apparently reckless and unprecedented decision to baptise Gentiles and eat with them that they want to hold Peter to account. (Acts 11:18). Then Peter repeats it a third time, in the discussion over whether Gentile believers should be circumcised, a matter Paul’s mission has made more acute. Peter retells his experience as an argument for coming down on Paul’s side (Acts 15:7-11).

In telling this story, of how the good news travelled from Jerusalem to Rome, Luke frequently highlights the miraculous. He wants to indicate God is constantly approving the activity of the church, and (as we saw with his emphasis on parables) he likes a good story. It means that speeches and stories are intertwined throughout the narrative. Speeches create something of a problem for the ancient historian: there was often no-one round to record them, and no easy technology for doing so.7 The responsibility of the historian was to try to include the sort of thing that would have been said, at least when they didn’t actually have access to the speech itself.

However, almost certainly there would have been a fairly standard sermon template or two shared around the early Christians, and it may be Luke has a source which includes such a template or two. Certainly he offers an interesting picture of the earliest Christian preaching, which includes remarkably little theology about the cross, and yet says a great deal about the resurrection, in ways which feel less developed than much of the New Testament.

One thing many readers feel gives an extra sense of being involved in the story is where Luke includes himself in it, beginning with chapter 16, as a travel companion of Paul. For some readers this is simply a stylistic device, but for most there is a sense that Luke has pulled out his old travel diary. They certainly contain some vivid details, and information that comes almost as an aside which does very little for the main story line. Unfortunately, almost as soon as the travel diary begins, the lectionary’s use of Acts stops, so readers will have to discover the delights of the story for themselves elsewhere.

Notes

  1. St Augustine was bishop of Hippo in North Africa at the end of the fourth and through the first third of the fifth century. He left a great deal of writing behind, and as far as I can tell this particular saying isn’t included, although the sentiment is. However, this saying is widely quoted and attributed to him.

  2. According to Luke, that is. In yesterday’s post I pointed out that John locates the gift of the Spirit on that first Easter day.

  3. The Feast of Weeks, marking the wheat harvest (called Pentecost in the Greek-speaking Mediterranean as it falls 50 days after Passover).

  4. See Galatians 2:9. Reconciling the rather different accounts of Paul’s first-hand impassioned argument with Luke’s more harmonious story – especially the story in Galatians 2 with the Council in Acts 15 – keeps historically-minded scholars busy. Paul may exaggerate his authority and independence; Luke may have heard a different version, and while Luke shows how Paul continues to stir up controversy, he wants to emphasise that when it comes to taking the gospel to the Gentiles, Peter and Paul share the same commitment to it; Peter, indeed, initiates it under God’s leading. Apart from this one stroppy reference in Galatians, the New Testament portrays Peter as Gentile-friendly.

  5. Luke sometimes speaks of it as an active agent: “The word of God continued to spread …” (Acts 6:7; see also 12:24)

  6. Sermons to Jewish audiences are included at Acts 2:14-36, 3:11-26, 10:34-43 (all by Peter) and Acts 13:17-41 (Paul, using similar themes). Paul’s speech on the Areopagus is narrated in Acts 17:23-31. All form the basis of lectionary readings.

  7. Shorthand had been invented in the previous century, by Cicero’s slave secretary, Tiro. However, we have no real idea how quickly or widely the idea was taken up.

Friday, 11 December 2020

Exodus: plagues and prohibitions

The second book of the bible launches into the story of Moses. It very quickly bridges the gap between the story as we left it at the end of Genesis, (with the favoured Israelites living in the nicest part of Egypt) and the point where the story of Moses begins (with the descendants of those Israelites all fully enslaved by the Egyptian Pharaoh).

We begin with Moses’ birth. The story of the midwives is a masterpiece of subversive humour as the slave-race outwits the master-race (a similar sly humour pervades the story of the plagues). From there the text skips through his upbringing in Pharaoh’s household, to the story of his first attempt to take action in favour of his birth nation. Attempting to defend a fellow-Israelite, he kills an Egyptian, then flees in fear for his life. In the desert he encounters God in a burning bush1 and receives the commission to lead Israel out of slavery from Egypt to a distant promised land.

  
Ivan Aivazovsky Passage of the Jews through the Red Sea via Wikimedia Commons

Initially reluctant, Moses returns to Egypt, accompanied by Aaron.2 The narrative becomes an extended account of ten plagues, visited on Egypt in order of increasing severity, before Pharaoh agrees to let the Hebrew slaves go. This should probably be read like a black comedy with a very dark ending: Moses and Aaron call a plague of frogs on the land. The Egyptian magicians say, “We can do that too” and bring even more plagues of frogs on the land. Various kinds of literature telling the story of oppressed people work by poking fun at the oppressors.

Moses leads the people out through the sea,3 and the pursuing charioteers are drowned. As we have it, there are at least two, and probably three versions combined in our bible. In one version, the sea is driven back by a strong wind all night (e.g. Exodus 14:21). We only see occasional traces of that version. In the more famous and dominant version, Moses parts the sea to create a corridor of dry land with walls of water either side of it. Then there is a poetic version as the song of Moses and Miriam in Exodus 15, which emphasises God’s action even more strongly.

This is a key story that is read especially at Easter. Christian tradition has rather minimised the violence portrayed in it (the climax of this narrative of liberation), by reading it as a foreshadowing of the cross and resurrection. This is captured most strongly in the baptism liturgy, such as these words from the Anglican blessing of the water of baptism for Eastertide.

    We thank you that through the waters of the Red Sea
    you led your people out of slavery
    to freedom in the Promised Land.
    We thank you that through the deep waters of death
    you brought your Son,
    and raised him to life in triumph. 
    (Seasonal blessing for Easter)

Putting the two together highlights Easter as a moment of liberation, not from Egyptians, but from sin and death. It is our sins which are drowned, not Egyptian chariots. Christian imagery in worship often works like this, directing attention away from any literal or historical reference, to a spiritual meaning. Given the many pages some scholars have devoted to working out what, if any, historical event lies behind the developed stories, that may be just as well. Christian spiritual reading and liturgical use is not tied to any particular historical reconstruction.

Then, in the desert, the Israelites eventually camp at Mt Sinai. Moses goes up and meets with God, receives the laws the people are to live by, with the ten commandments prominent among them, comes down, and is horrified by what he finds. In his absence, the people have invented their own version of the story, and represented God by the statue of a bull, a relatively common symbol of divine power. By contrast, the God of Moses cannot be represented by carved images. This will become the most distinctive feature of Jewish worship.

In horror, Moses breaks the stones on which the law is written. Then having prayed for the people that God will give them a second chance, he returns up the mountain to get the ten commandments4 (or ten words, the Decalogue, as the text describes them – Exodus 34:28) written out on new stone tablets. Finally, according to the instructions God has given, they set up a temple under “canvas”5: the Tent of Meeting, and worship God according to the newly given law.

Various parts of this story occur as readings in the lectionary. It helps both to have an outline of how they fit into this rather lengthy narrative, and also an awareness that quite a lot of law has been collected together into this story.

At the heart of it is a pattern we see repeatedly in the scriptures. God acts on his people’s behalf, which is usually referred to as God’s grace. God then expects his people to respond in obedience. They fail, and the covenant needs to be restored; God’s grace is then experienced as forgiveness. This is a pattern shared by both Jew and Christian in scripture and in tradition, and articulated in our liturgies.

Notes

  1. This is a very important story in which Moses is given God’s name. I will write a separate post on it at the start of next week.
  2. It seems to be another sign of the way the editors collected different traditions and wove them together, that Aaron appears, without explanation, as Moses’ brother in the land of Midian, despite Moses’ family being part of the enslaved Hebrews population of Egypt.
  3. Exactly which body of water the story has in mind is not entirely clear. The traditional translation of “Red Sea” is misleading in that it doesn’t refer to what we call the Red Sea today. It might, as many translations indicate in footnotes, be translated Reed Sea – the sea where the reeds are abundant.
  4. In fact, it’s rather difficult to divide the commandments into ten. The churches of the Reformation follow Jewish numbering, which treats the commandment to have no other gods as one, and that to have no carved images as two. The Roman Catholic church, following St Augustine, treats those as one single commandment, and takes the commandment(s) on not coveting as the ninth and tenth commandments. See, for example, the Anglican and Roman Catholic versions.
  5. Canvas is of course our material for tents. Exactly what material the Israelites used is not fully clear. In Exodus 36 some tent-hangings are made of linen (v8) some of goats’ hair (v14), and some of leather (v19).

Friday, 20 November 2020

The Easter cycle

The Easter cycle is quite similar to the Christmas cycle I explored in the previous post. There is an extended period of preparation, Lent, which leads up to the events of Easter, and an extended period of celebration after Easter which finishes on the feast of Pentecost. The origins of Lent appear to be as a time of preparation for baptism in those places that celebrated baptisms at Easter. However, it has long since become primarily a time for attending to a more disciplined life of faith.

The recovery of a long Eastertide is relatively recent, but, unlike Epiphany, Easter is not fighting any strong cultural currents, and it has deeper roots. Moreover the tone of joy naturally suits the uplifting mood of time outside the church, at least in the northern hemisphere, as we move into spring and (sometimes) early summer, and leave the winter months behind. As an old Easter hymn says:

"Lo, the fair beauty of earth, from the death of the winter arising,
every good gift of the year, now with its Master returns."

Salve, festa dies by Venantius Fortunatus (6th century)
as translated by the editors of the English Hymnal (New English Hymnal 109)

Lent, Holy Week, Easter – ending with Pentecost




There are some places where the two lectionaries diverge. In particular, the Revised Common Lectionary (followed here also by the Church of England) offers the alternative of remembering the Transfiguration of Jesus on the last Sunday (as they called it) after Epiphany, instead of on the 2nd Sunday of Lent like the Roman Catholic Lectionary. According to its compilers, this allowed for it to be treated as the last Sunday of an Epiphany season for those who wanted to do that.1 It still works as an introduction to Lent, but the reason for reading these stories in Lent was also a powerful reminder that the reason for embracing particular spiritual disciplines is to create some space in our lives for the Spirit’s transforming work. 

The readings of Lent in one way or another invite us to contemplate how we respond to the gift of God. The liturgy that surrounds them tends to be stripped back. The Gloria in Excelsis is left out of the Eucharist, and there is no use of any “Alleluia” to greet the gospel. It is also normal to avoid hymns which use the word. It is not that Lent is meant to be joyless, but that by paring the mood down, we set up a greater contrast with our Easter celebrations.

You may have noticed that it’s quite hard to get Lent match a period of forty days. It has not always started on Ash Wednesday in all church traditions, and in some it is still treated as ending with the more intense time of Maundy Thursday evening through Good Friday to Holy Saturday evening. It is possible to get an exact forty days also by including the final days before Easter but excluding the Sundays. Since the lectionary is very clear we are keeping the Sundays of Lent, it doesn’t make much sense to me to leave them out! I think it is better not to worry too much about counting days, and treat the whole season as an opportunity to grow in faith. After all, most round numbers in the Bible shouldn’t be treated as numbers to do sums with, but as rather more symbolic amounts of time.

Eastertide, by contrast with Lent, is marked with joy. One marked feature of the lectionary is that there is no Old Testament reading as there is for the rest of the year. The first reading in Eastertide comes from the Acts of the Apostles. This is not intended to denigrate the Old Testament in any way. A number of those readings from Acts are from apostolic sermons based on Old Testament texts. It is a way of saying Easter is supremely a new covenant, good news of Christ season, and the decision to use Christian texts is intended to underline that idea. It is especially appropriate because much of Acts presents stories of the earliest Christian preaching of the resurrection – a more dominant note than the crucifixion.

All the readings in Eastertide celebrate the resurrection of Christ, and the hope of new life for humanity and creation. Within that celebration there are two particular days marked out, based on the story as Luke tells it. He gives the timescale of forty days of instruction from the risen Jesus, before he is taken from the apostles’ sight (Acts 1:3), placing Ascension Day on Thursday of the 6th week of Easter, and he narrates the events of the Spirit’s coming on the day of Pentecost, fifty days after Passover / Easter.

Matthew’s gospel gives us no timescale, and John (and probably Paul) collapse the complex of resurrection and the gift of the spirit, theologically at least, into a single event. As with the Christmas story, where Luke gives us Annunciation, Visitation, Naming and Presentation as well as birth, it is primarily Luke’s writings that form the basis of much of our church calendar as he gives a timetable for the events that follow Easter.

Notes 

  1. For anyone who fancies becoming a bit of a lectionary nerd, the Introduction to the Revised Common Lectionary can be downloaded as a PDF from this page: https://www.commontexts.org/rcl/

Welcome to Lection and Liturgy

Welcome to Lection and Liturgy. I have backed up to this site a series of posts making a guide to the whole of the Christian Bible, aimed p...

Some frequently read posts