Friday, 11 December 2020

Horrible histories, terrible texts – a sidebar on when scripture seems unholy

There are a number of places in the bible where we encounter stories that are difficult, not only because we find them hard to understand, but because we find them morally repugnant. Quite often, the biblical story-teller narrates them without giving the listener any real clue what to think about them. The feminist scholar Phyllis Trible refers to them as Texts of Terror1 and many of those she focusses on are about women as the victims of male violence.

Some of these stories occur already in the first book of the Bible, so this seems like a good place to comment on them. One of the most famous of this kind of story – but by no means the worst – is at once bafflingly brutal and strangely powerful. It is effectively what we today would call a story of physical child abuse. It crops up in the lectionary on several occasions.

This is the story of Abraham taking Isaac, his only son, to sacrifice him at God’s command. At the last moment, God prevents the human sacrifice, and provides a ram instead. The story, found in Genesis 22, is used in the continuous Sunday lectionary, in Year A (Proper 8)2. It is also one of the key readings at the Easter Vigil in all three years.

Detail of sculpture depicting the sacrifice of Isaac, seen in Jerusalem shopping mall

When we read a difficult story like this, the first thing to remember is that the bible is full of stories which illustrate people’s partial, limited and mistaken understandings of God. Theologically, we speak of God accommodating himself to the limits of our human understanding, and therefore also the cultural limits of what at any period of history we can grasp.

Additionally, the bible’s story-tellers and editors seem content to employ a “warts and all” approach to their characters, even central heroic characters, and don’t tell us what to think about their morals. Just because something is described, doesn’t mean it’s necessarily approved of by the writer.

Many people think it seems fairly likely that various tribes and peoples from this time practiced some form of (at least occasional) human sacrifice. This story emerges, therefore, in a culture where people could conceive of God requiring human life. Its most significant feature then is that it ends not with a human sacrifice, but with the offering of a ram. Historically, it may represent a key moment in the understanding of the God of Israel as a God who does not require human sacrifice. That will instead be rejected by later law and custom as a pagan practice, not to be followed by the people of God.

The story portrays God as both frighteningly demanding, and ultimately gracious. God appears to Abraham at the beginning as the kind of deity we might all secretly fear God is like: cruel and capricious. At the end of the story he is revealed as generous and full of blessing. The story begins with God as a generic name for the deity, and ends with the name YHWH – the name3 by which Israel comes to know God as the one who enters into a gracious covenant relationship with them.

Then there is the character of Abraham: what sort of a man is he, and what must it be like to be torn between God and the son of his old age, who represents all his hopes of God’s promise being fulfilled? Most readers (and listeners) find the story draws them in as much as it repels them.

This is a story that also has a considerable afterlife. Perhaps in part that is precisely because it is horrible. Events in human lives, in all societies, and in global politics can be horrific indeed. At one level, it is therefore important, and perhaps generative of deeper thought, that the horrors of life appear in scripture, even if it appears God is implicated in them.

The deeper story to which Christians believe all scripture points is that of the God who takes the terrors of evil on Godself, and enters the desolation of the God-deserted on the cross. It’s just that some scriptures point to it not be proclaiming the gospel, but showing the dark side of life, and the way people seek to involve God in it, as cause, scapegoat, or vengeful judge. Scripture is not always clear at the point the story is told, whether this is about the understanding or misunderstanding of God. It is only when we look through the lens of the cross and resurrection that we begin to get our true bearings.

I mention some examples here of the echoes of this story of the Abraham and Isaac, to illustrate how enriching a deeper acquaintance with this brutal and baffling tale has been.

It finds echoes in the New Testament, when Paul speaks (using language drawn from this story) of God, “who did not withhold his own Son, but gave him up for all of us” (Romans 8:32). No longer does God only provide a ram for Abraham, but his own Son for the whole human race.

It also has a considerable afterlife in Jewish thinking, where it is referred to as ‘the binding of Isaac”. The rabbis treat it as if Isaac made a willing sacrifice of himself, in return for which God will grant blessings to his people. And a version of the story also appears in the Quran: there, because Abraham’s son is not named, Islamic tradition frequently treats it as the (also willing) sacrifice of Ishmael.

Sometimes, as I say, the most awful stories are also the most powerful stories, because they resonate with our own most awful experiences. This story, for example, in yet another afterlife, is harnessed by the First World War poet Wilfred Owen, to speak of the horrors and futility of war. He suggests that the morality of the political and military leaders of his day has failed to learn the lessons of the binding of Isaac. Here is the poem.

    So Abram rose, and clave the wood, and went,
    And took the fire with him, and a knife.
    And as they sojourned both of them together,
    Isaac the first-born spake and said, My Father,
    Behold the preparations, fire and iron,
    But where the lamb, for this burnt-offering?
    Then Abram bound the youth with belts and straps,
    and builded parapets and trenches there,
    And stretchèd forth the knife to slay his son.
    When lo! an angel called him out of heaven,
    Saying, Lay not thy hand upon the lad,
    Neither do anything to him, thy son.
    Behold! Caught in a thicket by its horns;
    A Ram! Offer the Ram of Pride instead.

    But the old man would not so, but slew his son,
    And half the seed of Europe, one by one.
    Wilfred Owen, The Parable of the Old Man and the Young.4

 Notes

  1. Phyllis Trible Texts of Terror: Literary-Feminist Readings of Biblical Narratives Philadelphia: Fortress Press 1984
  2. The Sundays of Ordinary time, and the issues of how they are named and numbered are discussed here. A subsequent post will say something about the three years, so let me sum it up in a brief comment here. In ordinary time, the Revised Common Lectionary provides alternative readings for the Old Testament. The catholic lectionary on which it is based has an Old Testament reading related to the gospel story. The ecumenical revision offers an alternative which reads some key stories of the Old Testament through semi-continuously, here in year A, for example, reading excerpts from the story of Abraham Sunday by Sunday.
  3. I will say more about this name in a subsequent post
  4. This poem can be found (often in a slightly different version) in many collections of war poetry. This is from Wilfred Owen: The War Poems ed. Jon Stallworthy, London: Chatto and Windus, 1994. Stallworthy says the poem was probably written in July 1918. Owen was killed in action on 4 November, a week before the Armistice.

 

Genesis: let's start at the very beginning

The bible and Maria von Trapp share the same approach to learning: they start at the very beginning. Getting the do-re-mi of the scale right was essential to appreciating the sound of music; understanding the world as God’s good creation is the foundation for hearing the song of the universe.

The pillars of creation – a detail from M16, the Eagle Nebula © NASA, ESA, Hubble Heritage

The book of Genesis falls into two distinct sections: the opening eleven chapters belong to a time essentially outside history. They deal with the same topics as the myths of other ancient Mesopotamian cultures: creation, flood, humanity and god(s). However, they give these common elements their own spin. The biblical God does not need help making the world. The biblical world is not a battleground between gods, but a home for humanity made by a kind creator. This God does not typically create or destroy on a whim, or in competition with other deities, but looks for humanity’s well-being, while expecting his people to behave morally.

This last point is sometimes hard to see: very often in the Bible, a story is recounted without the author appearing to pass moral judgement. On other occasions there seems to be something of a gap between earlier understandings of God and morality, and those we think are moral today. But however much we might need to wrestle with the text, there is an overarching sense that a good God demands good behaviour from those God has dignified with the divine image.

The second section of the book elaborates tales of the ancestors, in particular Abraham, Isaac and Jacob. These stories have been long told and retold in different tribal contexts before they reach their written form. Eventually they get edited together into a single whole (with who knows hoe many intermediate stages).

Together they tell how an extended family of travelling cow and sheep herders ends up being associated with a particular land, a land promised to Abraham by God. This collection ends with a separate cycle of stories around Joseph, whose coat, sadly for musical theatre, simply had long sleeves rather than being amazingly technicolored. With Joseph, the family leave the land they had been promised and end up living rather a wealthy life in Egypt.

Tim Rice and Andrew Lloyd-Webber knew a good story when they heard one. And I find it helps to read these stories by thinking of myself as a story-teller. You might want to imagine how, at the end of the day, the clan gathers after work around the fire, and the tribe’s poets and story-keepers tell some of the ancestral stories.

The tribe has camped tonight at Bethel as they travel with their flocks in search of good pasture. The elder recites a story about the ancestor Jacob, how he received his new name of Israel, and why therefore he called this place Bethel (which means “house of God”)1. The story tells the tribe something about the place, and reminds them that they too can expect to find God meeting them on their travels. When you read these stories in Genesis, you are reading well-worn and frequently told tales of guidance for the tribes that come to know themselves as the people of God.

Versions of the stories, set in a period that appears to fall roughly between 1800-1500 BC, probably got written down for the first time once Israel acquired a king and a temple. Scribes – i.e. professional writers – typically belong to a royal court or temple establishment. The versions we read today represent the end of several centuries of retelling and editing.

Sometimes, different versions of the same story were valued enough by different story-tellers and editors, that they end up side by side in the final edition. For example, in the main storyline of the great flood, Noah takes two of each kind of animal aboard the ark. The final edition also includes (at the beginning of Genesis 7) a short excerpt from another later tradition. In that version, Noah is told to take seven pairs of clean (ritually acceptable) animals, and one pair of unclean animals into the ark. If you run across something that seems to you like a contradiction or repetition, it probably represents the end result of this process of collecting. The editors would rather have two different versions woven together, both of which they valued, than lose one for the sake of consistency.

It may not be the modern way of editing, but consistency seems to be a modern virtue, not an ancient one. It is when we try to make the stories fit our pre-conceived notions of what they should be like, that we stop appreciating the oral story-telling artistry that has gone into making them. We worry over the detail and miss the meaning. The 19th century American poet and essayist Ralph Waldo Emmerson once wrote: “A foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds.”2 The collectors and editors of the biblical texts were far less bothered by foolish consistencies than some of their modern readers and interpreters.

Notes

  1. It’s all there in chapter 35 of Genesis.

  2. Self-Reliance (Essays, First Series)

 

Monday, 30 November 2020

When is a law not a law?

The first broad genre a Christian reader encounters in a description of the bible’s contents is “law”. Whenever the scriptures are referred to in the pages of the New Testament by genre, it is nearly always “the Law and the Prophets.” (I discussed this language a bit here.) And many people are used to hearing references to the books of Moses, or the law of Moses, in relation to the first five books of the bible.

However, what the reader finds when starting these books is not laws, but stories. It takes 50 chapters of Genesis and 19 more chapters of Exodus before we get to the giving of the law. This alerts us to a certain problem with the language of “law”.

Detail of a Torah scroll

So what’s in a name? The first five books of the bible are referred to by various names, especially Pentateuch (meaning “five scrolls”), Books of Moses, Torah (the Jewish term we’ve encountered earlier) and Law. This last is, as we’ve said, the one that crops up most often in the New Testament. Whichever terms we use, we are referring to Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers and Deuteronomy. It is the first, and most important, section of the bible for Jews.

The Greek word nomos was a regular translation of the Hebrew word torah before the early Christians started to use the language. It translates accurately as “law” in many contexts, but can also mean “custom and usage”. These can also be meanings of the Hebrew word.

Torah, however, is probably much better translated directly into English as “instruction” or “teaching”. It is broader than law, and while there are a great many laws included in these first five books, they also include other types of writing – stories about a mythical time when the world was made, tales of fabled ancestors, poetry like the song of Moses and Miriam (Exodus 15), various collections of laws, and a very long speech (Deuteronomy) presented as Moses’ farewell discourse before his death.

These books of instruction, then, are something of a jumble of genres, not just as a collection, but also varying within each book. How they instruct us will vary from section to section, and a reader needs to stay alert to the different types of writing presented in the same book.

Before starting at the beginning

This blog series now moves on to the longest section, as much intended for repeated reference as reading immediately. Nonetheless, I hope each post will be interesting enough to read in its own right as it is blogged. Since I am going (with one or two extras here and there) to blog my way through the books of the Bible in their canonical order, you might expect that to begin at the beginning would mean starting with Genesis. However, I want to take a couple of steps back, and begin with another word starting with the same three letters: genre.

At this point, though, I need to enter a caveat. I blog these posts on books of the bible not as an expert, but as a fellow reader. I venture to claim a degree of knowledge, and a reasonable depth of study for much of (but not all) the New Testament books. But when it comes to the Old Testament I have no particular expertise. I’m simply another reader sharing something of what I read. My reading always begins by asking what sort of book I’m reading.

When a story begins “Once upon a time …” we automatically deduce some things about the story, including the idea that it is not history or fact we’re dealing with. George Lucas played on the idea when he began his Star Wars trilogy “A long time ago, in a galaxy far, far away …” to tell the viewers something about the film that would follow. On the other hand, if we pick up a book and it begins something like this, we know we are reading history: “Life changed irrevocably for the people of the British Isles in 1066 AD, when William the Bastard turned into William the Conqueror. His defeat of Harold at Senlac Hill, a few miles inland from Hastings, became the defining fact about both William and the creation of late mediaeval England.”

Photo of Senlac Hill, nr Battle – via Wikimedia Commons by Simon Carey / CC BY-SA 2.0

We have different responses, because we are reading different sorts of writing. None of us, I venture, sat watching the beginning of Star Wars, and thought to ourselves, “I wonder which galaxy this happened in”. But if you’d picked up my fictional text on the Norman Conquest, you might, for example, want to look at an historical map and see exactly where Senlac Hill was, and that would be quite an appropriate response.

This difference between types of writing is what we mean by the term genre, and the writings that make up the bible fall into several different genres. Some are obvious at first glance, like law, history, letter or poetry. Others may take a little while to understand, as they come to us from a time and culture with some very different conventions to our own. Genre, however, makes a good place to begin our understanding of the bible, and how we might approach reading it.

In this section of the project, I will cover the contents of the bible in sections that group them according to their genre. In each section, I will first explore something about the group or genre as a whole, and then include a little about the books within it, paying most attention to the books that are used most frequently in the lectionary. I shall include deuterocanonical or apocryphal books alongside the undisputed Old Testament books,1 with their appropriate genres of historical, wisdom and prophetic books (and in the traditional Greek bible order). The chapter headings will make clear their disputed and deuterocanonical status.

When we come to the New Testament, because the gospels are the dominant organising books of the lectionary, I shall give more time and space to them than to the other books of the bible. I note that in the Catholic tradition, the gospel – mainly read at Mass – is read by an ordained person: the deacon (if there is one) or a priest. Those who are in this tradition will need to read those blog posts as a guide to listening to the gospel rather than reading it. Those from other traditions are often used to lay people reading the gospels as they do the other biblical books, so they will be unsurprised to find the gospels covered more extensively in a reader’s guide.

Notes

See this post for an explanation of the Old Testament contents, and how we got them. The term “deuterocanonical books” is explained in note 6 of that post (and in the glossary).

Saturday, 28 November 2020

Dramatic Readings

The last post in this section on the practicalities of reading looks at something slightly different. Sometimes you can consider a reading by more than one voice. An obvious example is dramatic reading. This can be overdone, and it’s neither to everyone’s taste, nor for every occasion. But there are times it may enrich the practice of public reading.

The most common use of dramatic reading is the tradition of reading the passion narratives, Matthew, Mark and Luke on the Palm or Passion Sunday1 of their respective years, and John on Good Friday. A number of churches have made wider use of dramatic readings, and particularly on occasions when a wide age range is present. There have even been dramatized Bibles produced filled with as much dramatic reading as possible. As far as I am aware, they are not presently in print.

On the whole, it’s more likely as a reader that you will be asked to participate in a dramatic reading, rather than be in a position to decide to read a passage with others. The key, perhaps, is to remember it’s a dramatized reading, not a play, and you are enabling people to hear the scriptures rather than making entertaining comments on them. You cannot, therefore, take any large liberties with the text. There is a place for including genuine dramatic plays in worship, but those are provided as a supplement for understanding the scriptures, not a means of proclaiming them.

In an ideal world, a dramatic reading, and perhaps especially the reading of the whole Passion, is something that is best rehearsed.2 A rehearsal not only gives people a sense of when they need to come in snappily and responsively, but also helps to work out where people need to stand for good microphone access. If the acoustics of the church, and the limitations of the sound system, means that a dramatic reading of the passion (which is often read with around ten voices) will be barely audible in your building, then it may be better either to limit the parts, or not to do it at all .

There are other possibilities apart from a full dramatic reading. Perhaps a poetic passage may benefit from two voices reading alternate verses. Or when reading a particularly long reading, there may be ways of sharing it between two or three voices that help promote attentive listening. All I want to do here is flag up the possibility that reading does not always have to mean a single voice.

While there is more that could be said about the practice of reading, the greatest aid to reading is understanding, and I am therefore (from the beginning of next week) moving on to the final, and by far the longest, section of this project. In what remains I look not at each lection, or each Sunday’s set of readings, but at each book of the Bible while keeping in mind those parts of it that are used in public worship . I hope that by grasping the overall context, you will be be better placed to locate the passage you are reading in its proper place, and understand more of what it is saying.

In this way, I want the emphasis to be on helping you understand, not simply telling you my interpretation of the reading. As you grow in understanding, so you may find you read differently in succeeding years, and help those who listen to you gain new insights because you have come to the text with your own fresh understanding.

Notes

  1. The contemporary Roman Catholic Church uses the name Passion Sunday for the Sunday that begins Holy Week, on which the Passion is read as a central part of the liturgy. Anglican (and some other) Churches maintain an older tradition also used by Roman Catholics before 1970, of calling the fifth Sunday of Lent Passion Sunday, because that was when readings, thoughts and devotions began to move away from Lenten disciplines, and more towards the Cross and Passion. The Sunday that begins Holy Week is therefore known by the name Palm Sunday, recognising Jesus’ entry into Jerusalem, which shapes the start of the liturgy.
    Palm Sunday / Passion Sunday is also a day to be careful with the lectionary. Two gospel readings are provided. The Palm Gospel is read as part of the entrance rite, before what is, in many churches, a procession with palm branches and palm crosses. This narrates Jesus coming down the Mount of Olives to the city. Readings from the Old Testament (with psalm) and Epistle come in the usual place, and then, without the usual congregational responses, the Passion Gospel is read, in shorter or longer version. It is this reading that is normally read dramatically, with different readers reading the parts of the different groups and characters.

  2. Versions of the Passion Narratives are available here with additional guidance on using them. I always mark copies up with a highlighter pen for each person participating.

Reading well: five basics

In my previous post, I mentioned a list of five key things to watch out for which will help you to read well. Today I want to go through that list in more detail, and add a sixth for those of you (the majority) using sound systems.

Pitch

All of us speak with a varying pitch, and it helps people understand what we say. Normally, for example, we end a question with a rising tone1. As a basic rule, in most contexts for public reading, it is good make sure we do end questions on a rising pitch, and statements on a falling one.

Most of us do better reading in a slightly lower tone than we speak naturally in. It helps our voice carry more clearly. However, I have heard people lower their voices drastically when reading or praying: it is incredibly distracting. Your voice should be as near to your normal one as possible, but slightly lower in its overall pitch. Avoid anything that sounds “put on” or artificial.

Get to know your sound system. (Image is CC.0 – Public Domain)

Pace

Listen to anyone speaking: they will speed up and slow down as they speak. One of the ways we typically emphasise something as important is to speak more slowly. (This can be exaggerated for comic effect, and if we do over-exaggerate our changes of pace when reading, people will instinctively wonder if we’re trying to be funny.) Varied pace is not only natural, it adds interest, and a good reader injects some variation into the speed of the reading. Just as you will normally want to read at a slightly lower pitch than you speak, so also you will want to read at a slightly slower pace than your average speaking voice. As a rule of thumb, the larger the building you are reading in, the more slowly you will want to read.

Sound your consonants

In ordinary speech, we don’t always speak very clearly. The most common consonants that go missing are the “t” and “d” sounds in the middle of words, and the “g” sounds at the end, especially words ending in “-ing”. These are the key ones to watch out for when listening to yourself read, but keep an ear open for the others as well. Doing this will also help you slow down a little bit.

Keep your voice up

It’s surprising how many people drop the volume of their voice towards the end of a sentence. It’s the most common reason you might turn to your neighbour and ask “what did they just say?” As I noted above, you will probably want to lower the pitch of your voice at the end of a statement. You may even want to end the sentence more slowly. But do not lower the volume at the same time. I suspect this is the most common mistake people make, and you may want to practice until you can lower your pitch without turning down your volume control.

Speak at a good volume

Some people simply speak too quietly, yet almost all of us are capable of speaking with sufficient volume to read loudly enough to be heard. This is something that needs practice, so that we can learn how our voice is carrying, and what the right volume for any particular building is. The best way to do this is to ask a friend – and this is another good reason for churches holding group training sessions – to listen, while seated in different places in the church building. It is worth remembering that in most of our congregations many people have a degree of age-related hearing impairment, and in almost all of them, people are more likely to sit nearer the back than the front.

Practice with the sound system

Most churches have some kind of sound system, although these are of variable quality. The most important reason for using it is where, as is usual, it is linked to a loop system for those with hearing aids. Because each sound system has its own peculiarities, it helps to be comfortable with the one you’re using, and that usually means practicing with it. The biggest thing to watch out for, and this is particularly the case with microphones placed close to your mouth, is “p” and “b” sounds. The air hitting the microphone from these plosive sounds can make a very distracting “popping” noise.

The other thing I always do nowadays is make sure my phone is in flight mode. This is not only so that I don’t get a phone call while in church: it is to avoid interference with the sound system.

Put these five basic things into practice, and you will find you’re reading clearly and engaging your listeners.

Notes

  1. In a great many social contexts, people increasingly also use a rising inflection at the end of statements, a practice often referred to as “uptalking”. It is best avoided when reading in public. 

 

Reading well: listen to yourself

When I first started reading in public, I wore glasses all the time (I now tend to wear contacts most of the time) and I don’t have a very pronounced bridge on my nose. This meant my glasses regularly tended to slide down my nose, and I had unconsciously developed the habit of pushing them back up my nose at regular intervals, even if they had barely slipped at all. For some people, this was a distracting form of punctuating the reading, and I needed a kind critical friend to tell me I was doing it. I found a way of adjusting them once in a pause before I began reading, and then making sure I didn’t do it again.

The first thing that will help you read well is having a critical friend in the congregation. They can observe you when you are actually reading, and tell you honestly both what you are doing well, and whether there are things you should try to change. It helps if, from time to time, they can sit in a different place, including at the back of the church (the seats that, in any denomination, tend to fill up first).

Earrr, image by צביה licensed under CC 3.0

A critical friend, however, at least in an ideal world, should not be where you begin. I think churches generally could do more to train those who read, especially by holding practice sessions for new readers. Whether through a local school or dramatic society, most communities have someone around who can offer some basic voice production guidance, and would often be happy to help out. It can be really beneficial to have had the chance to practice reading in the building(s) in which you will regularly read, and to have feedback from others on what you need to do.

Some common things many readers need to practice include these:

  • lower the sound register of your voice,
  • slow your pace,
  • enunciate your consonants more clearly,
  • keep up the volume towards the end of your sentences,
  • more generally speak up.

That list should also warn you of some of the most common mistakes people make:

  • speaking at too high a pitch,
  • reading too quickly,
  • losing the consonants at the ends of words,
  • dropping your voice towards the end of a sentence,
  • speaking too quietly.

They are also all things that with only a little bit of practice we can all put right fairly easily. I will come back to this list in more detail in the next post.

With the technology built into most phones today, it is also relatively easy to record yourself, on audio or video. Most people do not like the sound of their own voice — the literal sound, that is! On those occasions we hear recordings of ourselves, most of us are surprised to hear what we sound like.

Normally we hear our voice as much from inside our heads as from outside. The first time anyone hears what they sound like entirely from outside their own heads in a recording, their instant reaction is “that doesn’t sound like me”. However, it is what other people hear all the time. You are the only person who doesn’t really know what you sound like to others.

It takes a little bit of time, then, to get used to hearing yourself. But once you have done so, listen carefully to yourself reading a passage of the Bible out loud in church, with and without the sound system working. This is an opportunity all churches should offer all of their readers, and it is well worth doing this as a group exercise with the whole reading team in a church.

Such groups always offer more experienced readers a chance to share their experience, and, to be brutally honest, sometimes offer an opportunity to help an experienced reader make a much-needed improvement in how they read. Peer support, criticism and encouragement is a great help, but whether you can or can’t do this as a group exercise, you can still go ahead and record yourself. Particularly if it’s a large building, there may be a significant echo; the echo will nearly always be less when the building is full than when it is empty.

And that’s a key step in improving how you read: listen to yourself!

Welcome to Lection and Liturgy

Welcome to Lection and Liturgy. I have backed up to this site a series of posts making a guide to the whole of the Christian Bible, aimed p...

Some frequently read posts